Harry Potter discussion

516 views
Questions > Which character's death were you most affected by ? And who would you want to bring back ?

Comments Showing 51-81 of 81 (81 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Daniella (new)

Daniella Salonga | 2 comments I cried when Sirius died! Definitely Sirius.


message 52: by Chrissy (new)

Chrissy (crazycatlady_booknerd) | 78 comments Lupin.... Or fred


message 53: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 9 comments I was most affected by dobby and Fred's death but I would most like to bring back Sirius


message 54: by Sammi (new)

Sammi (sammip290) | 3 comments EVERYONE!!

But I would want to bring back at least one of Harry's parents, Sirius, Lupin, Dumbledore, and Dobby.

But I would also want... Fred, Hedwig,Severus, Tonks, and Mad-eye.


message 55: by Sammi (new)

Sammi (sammip290) | 3 comments Yes and it's really sad, cause you feel really sorry for George, he and Fred did everything together since they were born, and to have someone like that gone from your life, well it's just depressing. ;(


message 56: by Sammi (new)

Sammi (sammip290) | 3 comments Yeah... Poor George ;(
You know, right now, in my other harry potter group, uh, these people have literally gone evil! If you wanna check it out, it's on the chat page. :)


message 57: by Madeline (new)

Madeline Parise | 3 comments I was most affected by Snape's death. He's by far the bravest character in the whole series. It's terrible because by the time everyone realises he's actually a good person, he's not even alive. He basically sacrifices himself- not only himself but the life and the relationships he could have lead. Now doesn't that make you sad? While he was out playing spy for Dumbledore, everyone was hating on him and wanting him dead, and when he actually DID die, he was finally respected- but he wasn't even there to see that.
All he ever knew was hate.


message 58: by Jolijn (new)

Jolijn triss, and fred
from allegiant and harry potter


message 59: by Jolijn (new)

Jolijn dumbledore and Dobby too!


message 60: by Catherine (new)

Catherine (mikgnuoyeaj) Fred! The movie didn't really explain it well, but JK Rowling sure did. The movie made Emma Watson aka Hermione Granger cry, so it kind of made it like she liked him ... my cousin (who was watching that movie with me and never read or watched the other Harry Potter movie/books) was asking me, "Is that girl his girlfriend?"
Anyway, yeah, I think Fred's death was the saddest. What Ron said ("I wanna kill - Deathe Eaters" or something like that) was really good and supported his death.

I want to bring Tonks and Lupin back! Lupin really supported Harry in his third year, and was like a third father to him (James, Sirius, then him). Tonks was really funny and cheerful - she'd make a good mother to Teddy. And poor Teddy!


message 61: by gabbi (new)

gabbi | 27 comments No doubt Fred, but if I could bring back all of them I would (Sirius, hedwig, Dobby, Dumbledore, Cedric)


message 62: by Gabby (new)

Gabby | 31 comments Fred I would definitely back Remus and Fred


message 63: by Sammie (new)

Sammie Val🧸💐🤍 (shessammie) | 5 comments snape and sirius :,(


message 64: by Pearl (new)

Pearl Salzman | 111 comments The deaths that hit me the hardest were Dobby and Fred😭😭😭 it was sooo sad when Dobby died because he did it saving Harry’s life,and when Fred died it totally made me cry. He really didn’t deserve to die.

If I could bring anyone back,I think it would be Fred, but also there are so many other good characters that die that it’s hard to choose.


message 65: by Neve (new)

Neve | 11 comments I can’t choose between Snape Fred and sirius they all made me bawl


message 66: by Safa (new)

Safa (digitalbookcafe) | 13 comments Fred, Sirius and Remus and Tongs🥲


message 67: by Violet (new)

Violet | 16 comments SNAAAPE😭😭😭


message 68: by alexis .ᐟ .ᐟ (new)

alexis .ᐟ .ᐟ (girlloser_extraordinaire023) Dumbledore's death affected me the most. Not because I like him as a character (personally I think he kinda sucked), but since his death made things feel more real.
Before that it's like 'yeah, yeah, not that serious' but after that it's like 'This just got real.
And for what characters) I would bring back:

Lupin and Tonks (so Teddy would grow up with his parents instead of with his grandmother.)
Fred Weasley (so both the Weasley twins would have lived past Voldemort's death.)
Hedwig (so Harry's kids could meet her.)
And lastly Snape (so the kids of Albus's Generation could meet him.)


message 69: by shelby ☆ (new)

shelby ☆ Sirius's death hit me hard. Same thing with Lupin.


message 70: by Monroe (new)

Monroe denton | 41 comments snape you have your mom's eyes i cried knowing the last thing snape said was Lilly's eyes


message 71: by Annette (last edited Nov 01, 2023 07:50AM) (new)

Annette Hernandez | 64 comments Cedric, or Collin Creevey, both were too young to die. I mean at least Lupin got to be married, and Fred got to open his business, and Sirius got to at least graduate, and Dobby... well I really don't how old Dobby would be in elf years, but he seemed happy.


message 72: by Klara (new)

Klara T | 80 comments Hedwig and padfoot


message 73: by Klara (new)

Klara T | 80 comments And Fred


⋆˚࿔kiki˚⋆ {barely active} For me I think it would be definitely Fred and Dobby but I also Lupin and Tonks because they just had a baby 😭


message 75: by Torono (new)

Torono (mrtorono) Snape obviously because you don't like him until he dies, then he's one of your favorite characters. Also Remus...


message 76: by Evie (new)

Evie Smith Siriussss!! But not just because he died, its because of how broken Harry was esp in the moments directly following


message 77: by Danna (new)

Danna Mannani | 3 comments Dumbledore and Snape and Dobby and sirius


message 78: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer | 30 comments definitely Snape because what a plot twist! you go through the whole series thinking he's one of the bad guys only to find out AS HE'S DYING that he's been one of the best guys all along. so not only was I heartbroken by his death but I felt like such a jerk too. Hedwig's death was terrible too because she literally flies in front of the killing curse to protect Harry. and Dobby because he died saving Harry and his friends. and I'm getting choked up now writing this so I'm stopping here lol


-.Max-Blaze-Sola.- (xx_bloody-sunshine_xx) | 29 comments SNAPE AND DOBBY!!!!


message 80: by Brook (new)

Brook Bunch | 67 comments I have three, well really four, Remus, dobby, and Fred. Serious too if I could have a perfect world.


Sophie [thoughts of oranges]  Foster | 42 comments I was crying for all of them but definitely I would bring back fred


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top