The Doctor Rules!!!!!! discussion

260 views
Episodes > What if you could write a Doctor Who episode?

Comments Showing 101-150 of 228 (228 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by JessTheMess (new)

JessTheMess | 7 comments They have to team up to get the girl the eleventh doctor is trying to find cant remember her name sorry


message 102: by Marlene (last edited Jan 25, 2013 07:15PM) (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) I'm in. Do we all play a different character, or something?


message 103: by [deleted user] (new)

I'll make a roleplay discussion so we can start fresh!


message 104: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments OKAY. So. Everyone who wanted to participate would "play" a different character. Writing in third person would ust make the editing easier.
I've had an idea for a plot where no on ehas to play the Doctor if they don't think they can stay in character and we can explore and make up the inside of the TARDIS's 300+ rooms as we go along!

The plot really SHOULD be decided before hand. If we just go along, it's going to get really complicated. We're not Moffat. We can't just write outselves into corners and pop back out again.

Make another topic: Plot ideas? That way we can all decide. Since this is a place where we "write" a Doctor Who episode, I'm sure we can come up with something fun and creative. We also need to decide which Doctor we want, if we want a paradox with more than one... We've got a lot to talk about!


message 105: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Since it's the 50th, I think we should get all the Doctors involved somehow. Maybe all the incarnations of the Doctor are trapped inside the TARDIS by an evil monster who managed to slip inside, and we need to save them!

Ooooh, I have an idea! Since we will never make it to the level of storytelling as Moffat, why don't we make it a crossover roleplay? I want a Star Trek/Doctor Who one! We could have the Borg invade the TARDIS and try to assimilate the Doctors!


message 106: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments I personally hate crossovers. I think each thing should shine on its own.

We don't have to have just one roleplay. I can make an entire roleplay group. There can be crossovers galore and a major one that's JUST Doctor Who. I wanna make a novel and submit it for like, I dunno, just show it to the BBC and see what they think of it. *shrug*


message 107: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) I love crossovers. That's why Doctor Whooves is the best. *offended sniff* But I see your point.


message 108: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments I DESPIES MLP OH MY GOD. Even if it IS Doctor Who in MLP form I'm still gonna vomit. BLECH.

Okay, then. So should I mke a group for this so we can organize it like a proper roleplay or no?


message 109: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Axela, bad girl! HAVE YOU EVEN WATCHED THE SNOW? I'm a fan of these ponies:



Not these ponies:



Now, tell me, for the love of Mary, have you watched any of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic?


message 110: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments No. And I flatly refuse.

It's a little kids' show. Or it's at LEAST supposed to be.

I won't watch a little kids' show.


message 111: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) C'mon, it's a good kid's show. Just because something is for kids, doesn't mean it's bad. Like how Harry Potter is a kid's book, but it's good for everyone. Or how Batman: The Animated Series was intended just for little boys, but it was so well animated, written, and acted that anyone can watch and enjoy it! MLP: FiM is just the same way. It's a very sophisticated show with good plots, interesting characters, funny jokes, and a good message. You can't judge something you haven't watched.

Believe it or not, I was the same way as you. I loathed the show, even if I hadn't watched it. Then I decided, hey, if I'm gonna bash something, I might as well actually find out about it. I watched an episode, decided I hated it, but then I couldn't resist. I had to watch another. And another. And another. And then after ten episodes or so, I finally admitted that I was a Brony.

Come to the dark side, Axela, where friendship is magic.


message 112: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments Nope. I refuse. Sorry. I'm not taking the moral high ground on this one. I have not nor will I ever watch it. And I'm not gonna lie: the actul style of drawing even pisses me off. I have an undying hatred for stuff that's animated but doesn't even follow anatomy. Do those things even have hooves? A blue horse? With rainbow hair? I can't stand that hind of fantasy with that kind of animation. I'm sorry. You can't convert me.


message 113: by Marlene (last edited Jan 26, 2013 12:19PM) (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Because something doesn't closely follow real anatomy, you don't like it? O_O So that knocks out Looney Tunes, Rocky and Bullwinkle, Disney films, Pixar films, Dreamworks films, and pretty much all cartoons. Gotcha.

Oh, well, I won't try to convert you anymore. I just thought I would give it a shot! *hug*


message 114: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments Doesn't follow real anatomy at all. If you follow it closely enough, I can stand it.

*hug* Nice try. Seriously, not bad.


message 115: by Marlene (last edited Jan 26, 2013 12:43PM) (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Axela wrote: "Doesn't follow real anatomy at all. If you follow it closely enough, I can stand it.

*hug* Nice try. Seriously, not bad."


I'm sorry, I just have to respond to the allegations that ponies completely don't follow pony anatomy. That isn't true. The ponies of MLP: FiM follow the anatomy close enough so that it works within the style, and the universe that they're in. They look like ponies, and you recognized them as being ponies, so therefore it works. Just like how Daffy from Looney Tunes looked like a duck, even though he has two arms and stands on two legs like a human. And Disney! They are serial abusers of big eyes. I loathe big eyes in cartoons, but I put that aside and watch them anyway.

Look, I don't expect you to be a fan of the show or be converted, but I don't like it when people hate something they have no reason to, or dislike something despite the fact that they haven't watched it. Especially when that show is something that I have a special love for, and a show that makes me happy to watch.

There. I'm done. Next time, just say that you're not interested, but you have nothing against the show, and I'll leave you alone. ;)


message 116: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments *facepalm* DUCKS WALK ON TWO LEGS IN THE FIRST PLACE.
Sorry, had to point it out.

LOL Okay, okay, I'm done, I'm done. Jeez. I have problems. Anyways.

THE ROLEPLAY. YEAH. THAT THING.

Who all's in?


message 117: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Teehee. Forgot about that. I guess I meant that Daffy walked like a human, and didn't waddle like a duck. I'm a genius! :D

And yeah, roleplay thing! I am totally there. If you want to make a group, or just make a special topic for it, I am cool with that.


message 118: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments I'll make us a group for it. I'll call it exactly this: The Doctor Rules!!!!!! Roleplay


message 119: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Sounds good! That way Kirk doesn't get too bogged down with roleplay posts, and we make it so we can keep all our discussions and ideas in one place.


message 120: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments Created!


message 121: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments THE ROLEPLAY GROUP HAS BEEN CREATED AND SET UP. ALL IT NEEDS IS MEMBERS AND POSTS. PLEASE JOIN AT YOUR EARLIEST CONVENIENCE IF YOU ARE INTERESTED IN PARTICIPATING. ALL MODS ON THIS GROUP THAT JOIN MY NEW ONE WILL BE MADE MODS THERE AS WELL.

THANK YOU

THAT IS ALL



message 122: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Could you provide a link? I looked for it in the new groups section, but I couldn't seem to find it.


message 124: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Thank you, Axela! :)


message 125: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments No problem! :D


GlitchObsession-Eridan's Matesprit (DontlaughIknowwhereyoulive) Eris ~ C'est pour cela que je suis née wrote: "Axela, bad girl! HAVE YOU EVEN WATCHED THE SNOW? I'm a fan of these ponies:



Not these ponies:



Now, tell me, for the love of Mary, have you watched any of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic?"


YES! I HAVE!!!!! I LOVE IT! <3


message 127: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Wow, I realized I just said "WATCH THE SNOW" instead of "WATCH THE SHOW." Genius Eris strikes again!

Brohoof, Oncie! /)*(\ Who are your favorite characters?


GlitchObsession-Eridan's Matesprit (DontlaughIknowwhereyoulive) Back at ya! ;D My favorite charters in Friendship is Magic are Zecora, Pinkie Pie, FlutterShy, and Apple Bloom. Oh! I CAN'T forget Discord! He's my abolute FAV! In the fanfic(Friendship is Witch Craft) they are Discord, ScrewBall, Doctor Whooves(of course) and his companions, and Derpy.


message 129: by Marlene (last edited Mar 22, 2013 11:27AM) (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Yay, Friendship is Witchcraft! :D I love the fandom and what they create so much! I am even strangely fascinated by Rainbow Factory. O_O

I just got my Doctor Whooves pony from Hot Topic a few days ago! I'm so happy with it. He goes along perfectly with my Derpy doll. I'm going to make them have adventures in my small model TARDIS!


message 130: by Elysia (new)

Elysia (elysia_rae) Eris ~ C'est pour cela que je suis née wrote: "Yay, Friendship is Witchcraft! :D I love the fandom and what they create so much! I am even strangely fascinated by Rainbow Factory. O_O

I just got my Doctor Whooves pony from Hot Topic a few days..."



I watch MLP, can I get a brohoof? Any way, I LOVE love love Applejack and Fluttershy. They're both very cute and funny. I don't know, I kind of relate well with Fluttershy, she's really quiet, like me. :)

Wait, Doctor Whooves? I mean, is that like a canon thing? If so, would you be so kind as to point me in the direction of the episode? :D

Also, the RP sounds cool, I'll check it out!


GlitchObsession-Eridan's Matesprit (DontlaughIknowwhereyoulive) can you send a link to rthe RP?


message 132: by Marlene (new)

Marlene Ocampo (seeyouspacecowboy) Elysia wrote: "Eris ~ C'est pour cela que je suis née wrote: "Yay, Friendship is Witchcraft! :D I love the fandom and what they create so much! I am even strangely fascinated by Rainbow Factory. O_O

I just got m..."


Sorry for the late response! I've been bad at keeping up with the internet these days. Here ya go: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U0QDt... That is a fan animation which uses audio from a fan radio show. The Doctor isn't technically speaking acknowledged by Hasbro, but there is a background pony on the show who has an hourglass cutie mark, and a mane like Ten's, so the crossover was born! I have a really neat Doctor Whooves doll that I got from Hot Topic, so I'm very happy with it!


message 133: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments Obsession-ONcie, I already did, go up a page. :)


message 135: by Sinda (new)

Sinda Quietus (superwholockedtrekacrossthestars) | 553 comments Mod
If I could write a Doctor Who episode I'd make all the companions meet up and squabble about who the Doctor likes best. Seriously, that would be fun. And timey wimey.


message 136: by Axela (new)

Axela | 415 comments And Donna could sass EVERYONE.


message 137: by Novia (new)

Novia (novroz) | 236 comments I want eleventh to meet Captain Jack. Why haven't they met is a bit annoying. I kept hoping Jack will be in this or that episode.

He was supposed to live long but why hasn't Eleven met him yet?

If I could write one episode, it would be Eleven and Jack together


message 138: by Nishtha (new)

Nishtha (wheresmystory) I want Jenny(Doctor's daughter) to come back.If I could write a episode it would be like Jenny has regenerated and Clara is Jenny.She was living a human life and she lost her timelord pocket watch. So she can not remember who she is!


message 139: by Lynne (new)

Lynne Stringer I want Jack and River in an episode together. My, wouldn't that be something!


message 140: by Novia (new)

Novia (novroz) | 236 comments ah yes... I have been waiting for Jenny too!!


message 141: by Stéphanie (new)

Stéphanie (stepinator) if I were to write a doctor who episode. I would bring back donna, amy, rory and river. and they would meet up with like harry potter and supernatural and merlin and stuff... oooohhh and david tennant would also be in the episode. and alexander skarsgard:)


message 143: by Emily (new)

Emily (lafillebrigitte) | 1085 comments Maybe I'm just slow to notice things but don't we have two Jennys now?


message 144: by [deleted user] (new)

I haven't seen the Doctor's Daughter yet but her name is Jenny right?
And also Madam Vastra's wife Jenny.


message 145: by Novia (new)

Novia (novroz) | 236 comments yup...two Jenny but I don't think they are the same.

I just hope no writer suddenly makes them as the same person because the daughter knows who her father is


message 146: by [deleted user] (new)

It's a common enough name I guess

I mean look at all the Smiths

Mickey Smith

Sarah Jane Smith

John Smith, I guess

Matt Smith


message 147: by Ben (last edited May 28, 2013 01:55PM) (new)

Ben Harrison | 1 comments I wouldn't write 1 episode. I myself would write a full doctor, meaning from to point he changes to the next change. I have written my Doctor Who books. Just 2. A chapter is an episode, 75-85 episodes in each book. My own worlds, creatures, monsters, riddles, puzzles and designs. I only use three already made up creature and that's the Weeping angels, Daleks and Cybormen. they have to be on the show. Now all I need is to show Steve Moffat this somehow. This is what I want in life. all I care for is to write for the show. one wish, one dream, one man begging. Me Benjamin Harrison(2)


ϻαđίѕσи ~ I'm gonna be free, and I'm gonna be fine, but maybe not tonight yeah I noticed that there were two Jenny's too! and I agree that they better not make them the same person but I do want the doctors daughter Jenny to come back.


message 149: by Lauren (new)

Lauren Stoolfire I would write myself into the episode and then insist I play myself.


message 150: by Ollie (new)

Ollie Bradshaw (sebastian-bach) | 52 comments Ide write Jack with matts doctor together that would be awesome they would be perfect feeding off each other I think


back to top