Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
coincidence? i think not
date
newest »

Yeah, I noticed that. :) There's actually a picture about that, if I can find it... One second...
Yes! My family's not like that. We show our love more than say it. You hardly ever hear "I love you" here. We're just constantly caring. Always is my favorite world. I will always be a part of my family. Even after death. Always.

Yeah. I mean, loving someone is FINE. But we throw it around a lot, making it feel as if you're not as loved as when you just show it.

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!"
You, my friend, have your priorities straight

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!"
You, my friend, have your priorities straight"
Thank you, thank you. I try.


Did you ntoice the plot hole in snapes flash back (in the movie)?

A smile on your face? I was crying when i finihed! I actully havnt read the 19 years later becase its so heart breaking to know its over


Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?






Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?"
The memory is probably what haunted Snape, not what he actually saw. It might be what he pictured to have happened.

Nope, because the snake in the first movie was a male Brazilian boa constrictor. Nagini is a female viper.
And wouldn't it have killed Harry, instead of thanking him? And how come he never seemed to hear what Nagini was saying, when he could talk to snakes? Maybe it has to be talking to him, and it never was... :/


Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?"
Didn't that only happen in the movie, not the book? I remember being upset that they added it to the movie...


Here it is!!"
impressive! I did not notice that at all in the book and movie. Just another hidden treat that I missed in the movie and book.

Also, the plot hole in the movie is not necessarily a mistake. It was not in the books, no. But, it is entirely plausible that Snape, as Voldemort's right hand man, would be nearby that night, go in to see Lily dead, then he could have left before Hagrid arrived to take Harry from the house.

I've written very long comments there that I won't repeat here,so I just thought I'd let everyone know that there are more comments for those of you who may be interested in it.
The topic is called, I believe, "Snape, Harry, Voldemort - The Peverell Brothers?" :)


No, Nagini was not that snake. The snake in the zoo was a boy who was born in the zoo. Nagini is a girl.

Voldemort- the one who died for power
Snape- the one who died for love
Harry- the one who ..."
Did you mean *greeted* death?
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Voldemort- the one who died for power
Snape- the one who died for love
Harry- the one who greated death like an old friend