Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Harry Potter, #7) Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows discussion


205 views
coincidence? i think not

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Hufflepuff_princess  Anyone else notice how harry, voldewart and snape are like the three brothers from the deathly hallows?

Voldemort- the one who died for power
Snape- the one who died for love
Harry- the one who greated death like an old friend


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah, I noticed that. :) There's actually a picture about that, if I can find it... One second...


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)



Here it is!!


Hufflepuff_princess  Thats is totally going to be my new wallpaper!! Im glad im not the only one who noticed that


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

:) It's an awesome picture. :D


Hufflepuff_princess  You know your a potter head when "always" means more than "love"


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Haha, yep!


Hufflepuff_princess  I feel like people throw around the word "love" a little too much


message 9: by [deleted user] (new)

Yes! My family's not like that. We show our love more than say it. You hardly ever hear "I love you" here. We're just constantly caring. Always is my favorite world. I will always be a part of my family. Even after death. Always.


Hufflepuff_princess  I admit my famly says "love you" to each other constantly, although we show our love as well. Though if you go on facebook or a highschool 'love' will show up alot!


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah. I mean, loving someone is FINE. But we throw it around a lot, making it feel as if you're not as loved as when you just show it.


message 12: by Avani (last edited Aug 02, 2012 02:19PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Avani Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "You know your a potter head when "always" means more than "love""

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!


Hufflepuff_princess  Avani wrote: "Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "You know your a potter head when "always" means more than "love""

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!"


You, my friend, have your priorities straight


Avani Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "Avani wrote: "Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "You know your a potter head when "always" means more than "love""

SO TRUE. Just look at my profile picture!"

You, my friend, have your priorities straight"


Thank you, thank you. I try.


Poonam I didn't notice that. But I'm really excited about it!


Aurora How in the world did I not notice that? I pride myself on noticing that sort of stuff?


message 17: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana I did notice it, but only after I closed the book with a smile on my face and started to think all through, not while I was reading it.


message 18: by Hufflepuff_princess (last edited Aug 02, 2012 02:56PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Hufflepuff_princess  Aurora wrote: "How in the world did I not notice that? I pride myself on noticing that sort of stuff?"
Did you ntoice the plot hole in snapes flash back (in the movie)?


message 19: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana what plot hole?


Hufflepuff_princess  Anna wrote: "I did notice it, but only after I closed the book with a smile on my face and started to think all through, not while I was reading it."

A smile on your face? I was crying when i finihed! I actully havnt read the 19 years later becase its so heart breaking to know its over


message 21: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana yeah a smile on my face while tears burned my cheeks, I know I cried after the 19 years after even more, though I was angry at the author for 2 reasons: ending the series and she named Harrys kids only after Harrys life, no name had to do with Ginny, witch made me so mad!


Hufflepuff_princess  Anna wrote: "what plot hole?"

Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?


message 23: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana Oh yeah right!!! I had totally forgotten that part, I think the author just made a huge mistake....aghh it annoyed me a little


Aurora Or maybe I did notice it. Then again, the last time I've read the whole series front to back was five years ago, so I don't really know.


message 25: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana Oh you should totally read them again:) each time I do I find something different that I hadent figured out the last time.


داليا صلاح I didn't notice that but i love how the author made every part of the series is connected with hidden link


Hufflepuff_princess  I heard that the snake harry set free in the first book turned out to be nagini. Idont know if its true or not though


Avani Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "Anna wrote: "what plot hole?"

Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?"


The memory is probably what haunted Snape, not what he actually saw. It might be what he pictured to have happened.


message 29: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana I guess


Avani Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "I heard that the snake harry set free in the first book turned out to be nagini. Idont know if its true or not though"

Nope, because the snake in the first movie was a male Brazilian boa constrictor. Nagini is a female viper.


message 31: by [deleted user] (last edited Aug 02, 2012 03:17PM) (new)

And wouldn't it have killed Harry, instead of thanking him? And how come he never seemed to hear what Nagini was saying, when he could talk to snakes? Maybe it has to be talking to him, and it never was... :/


message 32: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana Where did you hear that? totally made up, and plus the snake in the first book was nice, Nagini is a total bitch hahah sorry


Hufflepuff_princess  Ok, thank you for clearing that up, it was killing me not knowing if it was true or not!


Alexandra Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "Anna wrote: "what plot hole?"

Remember he scene where harry is looking at snapes memorys? Well he sees lily die, but snape wasnt there, so how is that apart of his memorys?"


Didn't that only happen in the movie, not the book? I remember being upset that they added it to the movie...


Kailey OMG i totally did NOT notice that! That is awesome!


Caroline That's sooooo awesome I can't believe I didn't notice that before!!! Wow!! That's crazy!!!


Melissa For those who did not realize it, do not feel bad. I had to be told by my sister, who didn't even read the series, about the connection between the three brothers and Snape, Harry, and Voldermort. Though, shortly after hearing her say it, I did realize it was true. Interesting connection.


L'Poni Hadley Star •Don't let the Muggles get you down• wrote: "

Here it is!!"


impressive! I did not notice that at all in the book and movie. Just another hidden treat that I missed in the movie and book.


message 39: by Jeni (last edited Aug 14, 2012 06:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jeni Actually, Nagini DID talk to Harry. Remember when he and Hermoine went to Godrick's Hallow and Bathilda Bagshot took Harry upstairs? He could hear her speaking then.

Also, the plot hole in the movie is not necessarily a mistake. It was not in the books, no. But, it is entirely plausible that Snape, as Voldemort's right hand man, would be nearby that night, go in to see Lily dead, then he could have left before Hagrid arrived to take Harry from the house.


Ciara There's another thread about this already, if anyone is interested in even more information on the topic.
I've written very long comments there that I won't repeat here,so I just thought I'd let everyone know that there are more comments for those of you who may be interested in it.

The topic is called, I believe, "Snape, Harry, Voldemort - The Peverell Brothers?" :)


Elizabeth Day J.K. Rowling is a magical woman who planned everything. :) Also, did anyone know that Nagini was that snake that Harry released at the zoo in the first book? :) I heard that somewhere.


Brianna Elizabeth wrote: "J.K. Rowling is a magical woman who planned everything. :) Also, did anyone know that Nagini was that snake that Harry released at the zoo in the first book? :) I heard that somewhere."

No, Nagini was not that snake. The snake in the zoo was a boy who was born in the zoo. Nagini is a girl.


Magen Hufflepuff_princess wrote: "Anyone else notice how harry, voldewart and snape are like the three brothers from the deathly hallows?

Voldemort- the one who died for power
Snape- the one who died for love
Harry- the one who ..."


Did you mean *greeted* death?


FallingAngels Great theory! I love the picture! Copy, Paste!


message 45: by Aena (new) - rated it 5 stars

Aena i noticed that too. definitely a reference to the three bros, the three of them ...


back to top