Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (Harry Potter, #1) Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone discussion


402 views
What Character would you have Johnny Depp play in Harry Potter

Comments Showing 51-83 of 83 (83 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Elizabeth Day Ryan wrote: "As many of you may have noticed, Johnny Depp and Bellitrix (not sure of her real name) typically end up in the same movie. Which HP character would he play in the movies if you could put him in the..."

Her name is Helena Bonham Carter :)


message 52: by Aena (new) - rated it 5 stars

Aena XENO LOVEGOOD!!!
he just reminds me of the mad hatter. xD


message 53: by Heba (new) - rated it 4 stars

Heba I can't see him in any of the characters, but if I had to say someone, it would be Sirius.


Melissa Ryan wrote: "As many of you may have noticed, Johnny Depp and Bellitrix (not sure of her real name) typically end up in the same movie. Which HP character would he play in the movies if you could put him in the..."

Have Johnny play all the male characters and Helena play all the female characters. That would be a trip...


Melissa Johnny as Sirius would of been pretty awesome, but no one can replace Garry Oldman.


Charetta Totally Peeves


Iman the Bookwitch Gracieface wrote: "Two Words: Igor Karkaroff"

That would be EPIC!!!!!
i agree with this guy!


Fatma Sirius Or Snape


message 59: by Katy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Katy Z. Lovegood


message 60: by [deleted user] (new)

Sirius Black...Obviously.


Laura Xenophilius Lovegood. Definitely.


Angeline Joseph Tim wrote: "No Johnny Depp, please. It would cheapen the movie." Agreed!


message 63: by Leah (new) - added it

Leah J.K. said that she wanted the cast to be strictly British. Obviously, she stretched that requirement over the years, because many secondary characters were Irish (Evanna Lynch) and Scottish (Katie Leung), but the cast was very much strictly British. Johnny Depp does not reach that requirement.


Tracy I'm not sure about an exact character, but I think any outgoing, loud, rude-ish personality would have worked....


Jannie Huang Snape. Totally Snape.


message 66: by Kill the Spare (last edited Nov 02, 2012 10:34AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kill the Spare Sirius... Du-uh!


Maritza wrote: "Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham-Carter (Bellatrix) only work together if the movie is directed by Tim Burton...Now there's an idea! Tim Burton's version of HP! That would be wicked! ;p"

Oh my God, yessss!!


Ciara I don't think that'd work.
J.K gave information to the prosuction team but don't think she'd approve of an American "Harry Potter."
Tim'd make it too eccentric and would change too much, I feel.
He's a great director but I wouldn't want another Harry Potter remake.

Besides, the movies are amazing as they are, right?


Ciara *The production team.


Richa Kaul Mad-Eye Moody


Oakleigh Aguirre Crookshanks


Mikela Sirius!


message 72: by Kill the Spare (last edited Nov 02, 2012 04:53PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kill the Spare Ciara *I love Harry Potter!* wrote: "I don't think that'd work.
J.K gave information to the prosuction team but don't think she'd approve of an American "Harry Potter."
Tim'd make it too eccentric and would change too much, I feel.
..."


Yeah he'd make them eccentric.. but it would be an interesting perspective.. not a remake.. I just wish that he had been originally involved with at least one of the movies..


message 73: by Leah (new) - added it

Leah He's not a Brit!


Soccer.10 Elia wrote: "The reason he and Helena Bonham Carter (Bellatrix) end up in a lot of the same movies is because Johnny Depp does a lot of Tim Burton movies and Helena is in a relationship with Tim Burton and is t..."

Kristin wrote: "Johnny Depp could have played ANYONE.

Johnny Depp = Harry
Johnny Depp = Snape
Johnny Depp = Dumbledore
Johnny Depp = Any of the Weasleys
Johnny Depp = Hermione

Obviously, I am kidding. But Depp d..."


Ryan wrote: "As many of you may have noticed, Johnny Depp and Bellitrix (not sure of her real name) typically end up in the same movie. Which HP character would he play in the movies if you could put him in the..."
He should be Moody.


message 75: by Erin (new) - rated it 5 stars

Erin I think he would have been a good Barty Crouch Jr.!!


Soccer.10 he should be moody or snape. maybe malfoy


Pranshu deleted user wrote: "2 words. Sirius.Black. Sirius would be the perfect role for him! I can even imagine him with the hair! That said though I do love the Sirius Black who was cast. I cried so much when he died. But if..."

Yeah but I liked the guy they picked for Sirius in the movies.


message 78: by Ai (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ai Sari Sirius black!


message 79: by Robert (new)

Robert Either Hagrid or Mundingus


Halle Johnny Depp should have been the second choice for Sirius Black. Second because I love the first so much.


Halle Or Xeno Lovegood.


Colleen Stitch johnny depp is an amazing actor. he can and has played everyone from a crazy pirate to the mad hatter. put him with tim burton and you have movie magic. but not in harry potter. i was actually surprised to see helene bonham carter in something that wasnt directed by tim burton. she was amazing, she should branch out more. she doesnt need to ride the coat tails of burton to be a success. harry potter proved that. cant wait to see her in les mis!


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top