Harry Potter discussion
Characters
>
If you could make one dead character to live. Who would you choose?
Does Dumbledore still have a curse if he comes back to life? If so, Dumbledore… If not, Fred.
God this is so hard!
@BookOwl, if no, Dumbledore and if so, Fred*** 🙈😂🤦🏼♀️
Oh and Regulus! He could have been a huge help throughout the series
Remus and Tonks. They just had a kid and then their kid became an orphan. 😢
My fav characters are Remus and Sirius but I don’t think that Remus would want to be alive without any of his friends or Tonks. Sirius also would probably find life hard without the Marauders. So that makes Fred the obvious choice as he is a lovable character and his death had such a big impact on his family and friends.
Emily wrote: "My fav characters are Remus and Sirius but I don’t think that Remus would want to be alive without any of his friends or Tonks. Sirius also would probably find life hard without the Marauders. So t..."you're so right😭
If Black came back he would end up dead again trying to help Harry
It's a tie between Lupin and Tonks for me, Teddy deserved to have at least one parent.:(
Farah wrote: "Sirius, Fred, Snape, Lupin and Tonks."I know, a lot.
Personally if I were to make any of the characters alive I’d have to say Remus Lupin. He had a son Teddy and then he just died 😢 but that would be my pick. (I’m new here so hi)
Fred; As said before there is no George without Fred!!But I'm also a big fan of Tonks
Tom Riddle Sr. His was the saddest story in HP.
Uhhhh i would like to go with lavender although its such a weird pick i think she is someone that would done good in her future, it was sad to see her go, even if she was a dimbo to everyone but ron. she was still my favourite just a little bit though.
FRED FRIGGIN WEASLEY FOR SURE
YES I FORGOT HE DIED- You can't separate the twins!
Samara wrote: "YES I FORGOT HE DIED- You can't separate the twins!"Don't twins get separated all the time in fiction? They get separated even in HP.
:O u read the fanfic? i listen to it lol
Remus Lupin! All the way! He is my pookie, ngl…
It's sooooo hard to choose just one 😭 but I think it would be Sirius. I love this character and I think Harry deserved at least one family presence who truly appreciated him. The Weasley family was wonderful to him and took him in, but Sirius was the closest thing he had to a real family (apart from the Dursleys).
It's between Fred and Sirius. I'd say Merope, but I need the series and I don't think Tom Riddle would be Voldemort. Fred: What will George do without him? I literally sobbed for like 30 minutes when he died. Sirius: He was a father to Harry which he never really got to have. He is also just great in general.
Severus Snape and Lily Potter.
But not James, after all he did to Snape...
I have to say either Fred, becuase he had such a future, or Dobby, becuase he hd finally found happiness and deseved much more.Dumbledore i think was ready to go, and i never like Snape that much.
I would bring back Fred and Snape. Fred and George literally are the best together. Even when George got his ear blasted off they managed to crack up about it together.
Snape was just such a misunderstood character, and I feel like there was more to his story. He was......mysterious.
I would love to have him back :)
Dobby I really liked him. But it worked for the story whereas Lupin and Tonks felt like' oh its been a few pages since I killed someone, better do it again'
Dobby🥺 I miss him💕
Snape, Fred, or Sirius. Maybe even Lupin or Tonks. They all were just too young to die…
Everyone is saying Snape and Sirius but honestly the way he died was perfect for the story and it would feel strange if he had lived. And Sirius was kind of obviously going to die and couldn't have really served much of a purpose other than sacrificing himself for Harry in the order of the phoenix. I think Tonks should have lived.
Even though a lot of deaths are heartbreaking and are of my favourite characters like Snape, Sirius and Lupin, I would vite for Fred because I can’t imagine the twins separated. It was the most useless death, with the only goal of cutting our hearts in pieces.
In books 2-4, Dobby was B-Tier.
Book 5 made him better when he saved more Dumbledore's Army kids flee before Umbridge arrived giving him A-Tier.
Book 6-7: In his final moments, he rescued so many people from the Malfoy's, Bellatrix, Pettigrew, and Voldemort before he kicked the bucket. S-Tier!
#dobbyisafreeelf #elfrightsmatter