Harry Potter discussion
Characters
>
If you could make one dead character to live. Who would you choose?
message 151:
by
Addison
(new)
Feb 12, 2022 09:53AM
I’d say Dobby, but i feel like Lupin and Tonks need to live for their son
reply
|
flag
Sirius or fred or tonks cuz she seemed so cool in the start...its a pity she had to die in the end
yeah i'd have to say fred, lupin, tonks and/or sirius. they were such good characters.
Remus Lupin, Fred Weasley, Sirius Black and probably Harry's parent but that won't happen cause that's all part of the plot isn't it?
For sure Remus, or Sirius, Sirius was really the closets thing to a father figure Harry had.
If I could only choose one, I would choose Fred, because the thought of George without Fred makes me sad. Plus, I feel like most of the deaths were necessary. Except for Cedric. And Sirius... and hedwig. So maybe J.K Rowling just killed off random people for no reason.
I would say either Fred, Snape, or Remus.
Either Sirius, Fred, Snape, or Lupin.
lily and James, fred, sirius, lupin and hedwig, DOBBY.
Sirius and Dumbledore... I hated Sirius's death. It wasn't at all fair. And as for Dumbledore, I just thought he needed a more peaceful life.
Duks wrote: "Merope Gaunt. I would love to see how Voldemort would've turned out if his mother lived."Oooh! I love that perspective!
Definitely Remus dead and James and Lily alive so they could have seen how Harry turned out.
FRED its not the same with only 1 twin...
Snape. The guy was shat on for nearly eight years and then died before anyone could recognize or thank him for his selflessness. I know it was all for dramatic effect but a nice alternative is that he lived and was seen for the hero he was.
Oh god this one has me conflicted. My instinctive answer would be “Sirius all the way” because I cried the most when he died. But also Remus or Snape…. I truly can’t decide
Fred, although I would also bring back all the marauders era characters minus Peter and snape but George without Fred just isn't right but with the maurdeurs you couldn't bring one back without bringing back all of them
James potter?? i might be biased bcuz of the fancast but… I feel like he would be such an awesome dad to harry. I NEED to watch their interaction
sirius.. or remus. or james. i have no idea but sirius came first to mind
Sirius black . He was so good to Harry
I think I would choose Tonks and Lupin just because they have a son and I think they deserve to watch him grow up. I was really sad when I found out they died right after having a baby.
Sirius because he was the only family that Harry has and also because I love him so much. Also I would like Snape tu return from death because he is the bes teacher ever
Sirius for sure. I always think about the life he could have had with Harry and how they never got a chance.
Lupin, Tonks, Sirius, Lily and Snape.
I think i would have to choose snape. Iconic! The most complex character in the series in my opinion.
ngl Fred, because I love him and George so much and they need each other! Harry's good a toughing it out, but I fell like the twins are such softies under their joking nature, and I miss that so much!
This is really tough, so many great people died throughout the series! I think I would probably go with Fred Weasley, because I feel really bad for George after Fred's death, and the rest of the Weasleys too. So, I would choose Fred because George without Fred is just too sad.
Harry's father. All boys need their fathers. Lily was a wonderful woman, but at least James would be around to protect Harry from Snape, Draco, Voldemort, and those horrible Dursleys!
probably have to be Snape or Sirious
I cried so hard when Sirius was killed. Definitely him, as well as Lupin, Tonks, Snape, and Fred. And of course Dobby!!! I feel like these are the most common ones too.
Oh and oh my god HEDWIG!!!I cried so. Freakin. Hard. I thought she was gonna come back to life or something. 10 year old me was sorely disappointed. And extremely sad. :(
DUDE FRED 10000000% I FELT SO BAD FOR GEORGE, HE DIDNT JUST LOOSE HIS TWIN HE LOST HIS BEST FRIEND, OTHER HALF, AND PARTNER IN CRIME!! FRED DESERVES THE WORLD!!
I need Fred Weasley back, and Sirius.I wonder what it would be like for Sirius to actually witness Harry killing voldemort.
What would have he done to help>
Fred, he never deserved to die, he had so much to live for, his family, friends, and career.
I'd definitely bring back Lupin and Tonks. They had a kid!
