Goodreads Librarians Group discussion
Book Issues
>
same book but 2 different titles
date
newest »


Admittedly, I tend to "over-combine" in general, giving borderline cases the benefit of the doubt.

Well, since I do not have a copy of one of the books, I cannot be 100% sure.
I always double check my combinations, and in the case of these two books, I found reviewers on uk amazon complaining about how they felt they had been fooled into buying the same book they had already read.
I'm going to keep them separate for now, and if anyone decides otherwise please do let me know for the future.

(I actually think the 4 editions, 2 of each, should be combined.)
Given that official policy is to combine translations and revised editions, combining different countries' editions strikes me as the same thing. But I'm like John -- I tend to err in the direction of over-combining.


Elizabeth Ferrars: 52) Skeleton in Search of a Cupboard (US Title: Skeleton in Search of a Closet)
The Anonymous Venetian, by Donna Leon, for example, was released as Dressed for Death in the US. Should I combine such entries?