Chosen (House of Night, #3) Chosen discussion


148 views
zoey

Comments Showing 51-99 of 99 (99 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of boyfriend issues, but nothin..."

Actually, I think calling her a 'whore' is wrong, cos, well, I would never call ANY girl a whore unless she did something completely unacceptable. And I don't even object to the fact that she's making out with three guys at the same time, I just feel a little erm..how do I put this politely, disgusted? at the fact that she does it when she's 'committed' to Eric. I have friends who randomly make out with people, who sleep around, and that's really not a big thing!
For me it's more about the emotional commitment. Cheating is not OK, whether you're sleeping with the other guy or just 'making out' with him. That's one of the rules I personally stick to. :D


message 52: by [deleted user] (new)

Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of boyfriend iss..."
Teddy, don't take Shelly's comments to heart. She was being rude to people on another HoN thread and kept telling this one girl to F off and insulted her parents.
http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...


Shelly Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of boyfriend iss..."

She lost her virginity at 17. How the fuck does that make her a whore? Cause she kisses other dudes? Grow the fuck up, that's normal fucking teenage behavior.


TeddyBear {HarpyAshe}  **Well You Built Up A World Of Magic, Cause Your Real Life Is Tragic** Well okay then. Im not really. I just dont understand. I was voicing my opinion and here she comes, seeming to me trying to start something.


TeddyBear {HarpyAshe}  **Well You Built Up A World Of Magic, Cause Your Real Life Is Tragic** Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of..."

Yeah and normal teenager of this generation are fucking idiots!! And that is not okay, at least not to me.


Shelly Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of..."

You should just mind your own business and shut the fuck up.
I'm tired of all you pieces of shit coming on here and spreading the message that it's alright to call someone a whore. I'm not the best role model but at least I don't make the young kids reading these posts think it's alright to call other kids at school whores. Good job on promoting bullying. You deserve a fucking award.


Shelly Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. ..."

Of this generation? It's been the same for the last few generations


message 58: by [deleted user] (new)

Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of boyfriend iss..."

I agree. My problem with Zoey isn't that she is sexually active- people can make out/sleep with anyone they want- it's thier life. But Zoey was supposed to be commited and she knew that cheating would hurt everyone involved.


TeddyBear {HarpyAshe}  **Well You Built Up A World Of Magic, Cause Your Real Life Is Tragic** Who are YOU to try to tell someone to mind their own business?!?! I'm voicing my opinion about a book and here YOU come, starting something with ME!! YOU need to mind YOUR own business XD Cause this is fucking ridiculous.


TeddyBear {HarpyAshe}  **Well You Built Up A World Of Magic, Cause Your Real Life Is Tragic** Hello wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. A little bit of b..."

Yeah I totally agree with you. Zoey just needs to learn to calm the fuck down, like I said XD


Shelly Teddy wrote: "Who are YOU to try to tell someone to mind their own business?!?! I'm voicing my opinion about a book and here YOU come, starting something with ME!! YOU need to mind YOUR own business XD Cause thi..."

I wasn't saying that to you, learn to read


TeddyBear {HarpyAshe}  **Well You Built Up A World Of Magic, Cause Your Real Life Is Tragic** Obviously I know how to read, considering I read these books. I said some of my comment, so I thought you were talking to me again.


message 63: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. ..."

Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great none-the-less. ..."

Woah, you clearly need to chill a little bit. And as I said before, it's never OK to call somebody a whore (I would never do that myself) but I still think for someone as judgmental as Zoey is, she could be a little more restricted in her actions. I mean, it only makes sense. Or if she embraces her behavior, she would be a little more understanding of characters and their flaws ( instead of repeatedly calling Aphrodite a whore)
And sorry, I don't think that having a code of conduct makes me a judgmental bitch. I'm all for doing what you want to do, just that you don't judge others by it.


Shelly To everyone calling her a whore. Good job on making it seem okay for the young kids reading these post to call other young kids whores. Congratulations on contributing to bullying and teenage suicide. Pat yourselves on the back. Good job.


message 65: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "To everyone calling her a whore. Good job on making it seem okay for the young kids reading these post to call other young kids whores. Congratulations on contributing to bullying and teenage suici..."

We're not saying it's OK to call ANYBODY a whore! Honestly, the topic is whether it's OK to cheat on your boyfriend? And hands up, everybody, who says it's OK.

And Shelly, are you a high school teacher/ volunteer at a hotline (that's a genuine query, I swear, not sarcastic, cos you seem to be reiterating the issue of teenage suicide. A sincere qn, don't take offense )
And I can't believe I'm debating about this crap. I don't even like the bloody books. :/


Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great ..."

Giving someone a blow job in the hallway is a little different than being seduced into losing your virginity.


Shi'Asia Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think I stopped around book 7 because I just couldn't handle how horrib..."

That's the reason I've almost given up the series. My friends just seem to ooh and aah over it, but I can't just can't get past the fact that this girl is just easy and selfish.


Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "To everyone calling her a whore. Good job on making it seem okay for the young kids reading these post to call other young kids whores. Congratulations on contributing to bullying an..."

"We're not saying it's OK to call ANYBODY a whore! Honestly, the topic is whether it's OK to cheat on your boyfriend?"

Have you read all the comments? Everyone is saying they don't like her cause shes a whore. Not a very good message to send young kids.


message 69: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books sh..."

Exactly my point.

And secondly, seduced or not, it's her decision to have sex with Lauren. I mean, just because she was overtaken with lust or whatever it's called in the book to make it more appealing, does not mean that she was not consenting. It was still her decision, and just because she was 'seduced' doesn't mean she was 'unaware'.


Shelly Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think I stopped around book 7 because I just couldn't h..."

Easy? Really? Losing your virginity at 17 is easy?


Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the fir..."

Like I said in a previous comment. She fucked up. She thought dude liked her and lost her virginity to him. Doesn't make her a whore. Poor judgment yes, whore no


message 72: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey THe comments are calling her a 'whore' (and again, that's a strong word) BECAUSE she was cheating on Eric.

And I'm exhausted with this debate. Am gonna go comment on something else now.

Since I did put 'Chosen' on my 'so-bad-should-be-illegal' shelf, after all. I'm spending more time commenting than I did reading the book. :D


message 73: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I m..."

Yes, she fucked up. Poor judgment, undoubtedly. And I'm saying that she should pay for it. And not think that it's her God given right to get away with it. Has anybody else noticed that Eric's character gets wayyy more creepier after they break up? And that he's implied a nasty, cheating bastard because he hooked up AFTER he and Zoey broke up?? *pretend shocked gasp* He's a bastard, all right. *snort*

It's simply bad taste, trying to make the reader accept that it's OK to hate Eric, just because he was creepy AFTER he broke up with Zoey, hence somehow making it OK for Zoey to have cheated on him BEFORE.

Does that convoluted argument make sense? :D


Shelly Jey wrote: "THe comments are calling her a 'whore' (and again, that's a strong word) BECAUSE she was cheating on Eric.

And I'm exhausted with this debate. Am gonna go comment on something else now.

Since I d..."


So how does cheating on your boyfriend make you a whore? Wouldn't that be called a cheat, cheater?
A whore is actually someone that get's paid for sexual pleasures. People use that word to describe someone that sleeps around. Now seeing as how she wasn't getting paid or sleeping with anyone else, she is not a whore


message 75: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "THe comments are calling her a 'whore' (and again, that's a strong word) BECAUSE she was cheating on Eric.

And I'm exhausted with this debate. Am gonna go comment on something else now..."


Fine, call her a cheater then. Semantics.


message 76: by Shelly (last edited Mar 20, 2013 03:58PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I reall..."

No Eric was being a possessive jerk before she cheated on him.


message 77: by [deleted user] (new)

Jey wrote: "PS: Read my review of Chosen. ;)"
Ha!


Shi'Asia Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think I stopped around book 7 because ..."

I was just stating how I felt about a certain character in a book. She cheated on her boyfriend (Erik) and hurt her Heath whom she had some type of sexual relationship with also. Mind you, this was alll at the same time. I think if she's suppose to be in high power she should be a little smarter about her life decisions. I never said loosing your virginity at 17 made you easy. I said Zoey was easy and clearly a hypocrite. she calls Aphrodite a ho all the time (that's not very nice) for doing something sexual with her boyfriend in a public place. Nasty, yes. However doesn't Zoey to do it also? Letting Erik feel her up in the courtyard. making out with Heath in the park. Sleeping with Lorent in a place that was easily accessed by anybody. Don't assume.


Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "THe comments are calling her a 'whore' (and again, that's a strong word) BECAUSE she was cheating on Eric.

And I'm exhausted with this debate. Am gonna go comment on som..."


Semantics? Really? Whore and cheat are two very different things.


message 80: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be hon..."

*tries to recall* No, I honestly can't. I read the books ages ago, and my brain has a habit of letting go of stupid shit.

Still, the fact remains that I would not recommend these books to anybody, not only because of the lead character and the debate about her morals, but mostly because it's a series of badly written books, held together with a flimsy plot, and a new hero every book.

Amen.


Shelly Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think I stopped around ..."

Wow, really? Do you even know what you write? Have you even read the books?
Eric was not Aphrodites boyfriend when she gave him head in the hallway.


Shi'Asia Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think ..."

Well Lorent certainly wasn't Zoey's boyfriend and she gave her virginity to him. Either way they've done the same things.


Shelly Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey......"

I never said they are good books. They actually are poorly written.


message 84: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irresponsible. I think ..."

And by your logic, you think that's not OK? Going by your comments, you think sexual freedom is great, boyfriend or not ( ANd I'm there with you on that... but still, pick a side. :D)


Shelly Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and vain and irrespon..."

Hmmm touche. Still doesn't make her a whore


message 86: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "O..."

Poorly written is a polite way to put it. Yayyy for being politically correct! *high-five * :D


message 87: by Jey (new) - rated it 1 star

Jey Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and ..."

Doesn't make her a whore. Makes her someone who makes mistakes, hence the habit of everybody acting as if she's the Supreme One gets extremely irritating after a while.


message 88: by Shi'Asia (last edited Mar 20, 2013 04:09PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Shi'Asia Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She is shallow and ..."

I never said she was. I just said she was easy. Which she was since she was easily misled by Lorent knowing the darker forces at work it her own school. Whatever she is, I dislike her as a character.


Shelly Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfaithful whore. She ..."

Most people do dislike her as a character. I dislike her as a character. She is not easy though. That's pretty obvious or Eric and Heath would have gotten some.


Shi'Asia Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a whore. An unfai..."

Well it seemed she was easy enough. I explained my theory in my other comment. I'll just leave her as a cheater if that word appeases you.


Shelly Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Shi'Asia wrote: "Chelsea wrote: "I just hate Zoey as a character in general. She is a ..."

Well seeing as how she was in a relationship with Heath for so long and then Eric for a while and neither one of them got any. I'm going to have to say the she is not easy.


message 92: by [deleted user] (new)

Let's all agree to disagree, shall we?


Shi'Asia Hello wrote: "Let's all agree to disagree, shall we?"
Agreed. :D


Daniel I see Shelly is at it again :)

I'm going to have to agree with most of what she says.
Definitely not easy. Every girl that I have ever been with, we had sex the first day we met. Now that makes it seem like they're easy. Maybe they are but it also seems like that is the norm. Almost everyone I know is like that.


EmilyRose I think it's pointless people argueing about whether they think Zoe is a whore or not. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions. I wouldn't say she is a whore but shes definitely a cheat.
And to Daniel's comment above, not every girl is easy. You might know a lot of girls who will have sex with you the first day you meet, but there are a lot of girls who arent like that so dont give that stereotype that every girl is easy. It is definitely not the norm!


Daniel Emily wrote: "I think it's pointless people argueing about whether they think Zoe is a whore or not. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions. I wouldn't say she is a whore but shes definitely a cheat.
And to ..."


Well where i'm from, it is the norm.


message 97: by [deleted user] (new)

Zoey is DEFINITELY a mean, rotten, disgusting cheater. Period.
As for her being a "whore"...what about all those times she drank Heath's blood? 'Cause apparently Imprints and blood drinking are kind of like sex. And THEN she had sex with Loren. So yeah, she's a bit like a whore.
Erik did not become a possessive jerk until Tempted. It felt like the Casts went, "Ok, everyone is getting bored with this love pentagon thing, so let's suddenly make Erik a possessive jerk so Zoey will dump him, and have Kalona kill Heath."


April Jey wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Hello wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Shelly wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Jessica wrote: "Teddy wrote: "Okay. Zoey...Well, to be honest, I really like her. I mean, the first two books she was great ..."

I agree with you on that point. I don't have a problem with Zoey as a character except that the only thing that really bugs me is that Zoey is really judgemental. That's the only big pet peeve I have with her. And the series is too long. I feel like it's a little dragged out and that I'm not as excited to finish the series as I used to be. I started reading the series when I was 14 (that was 4 years ago) and I had recieved the first 4 books in a box set and loved them because they were the second series I've ever read. My favourite characters are: Stevie Rae, Aphrodite, Stark, and Heath. Erik is growning on me, though I don't know what Zoey saw in him in the first few books cuz he was a jerk, but it's her fictional life and she can do what she wants. I don't judge her for it. The only big problem that I have with her is that she's very judgemental. Other than that I think she's a great character.


message 99: by Anna (new) - rated it 1 star

Anna Roth Angelbornfromfire wrote: "I kinda feel sorry for her she has enough on her plate with the whole Evil mentor,Elemental affinities, dead-undead best friend and the whole main attraction of the freak show. Now she has boy issu..."

She's pathetic. She makes her own problems, look at Heath dying. If she'd have told him to go away from the beginning, that would never have happened. Zoey constantly victimises herself- she says it over and over again how she's been through horrible experiences and everyone should feel sorry for her, like she wants to be some kind of martyr. What kind of 'strong' heroine brags about all the 'traumatic' (as she calls it) experiences they've been through? She's selfish, disloyal and arrogant. But what *really* gets to me about Zoey and is that she and every other character in the series think she is some kind of angel. Some perfect, selfless, special angel. Without a doubt the WORST heroine I have ever had the misfortune of reading about.

P.S. Bad experiences or not, cheating on someone is never OK. Yet she can always justify anything to herself, nothing is ever her fault. As I said, she makes her own problems. She is worse than Bella Swan.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top