Catching Fire (The Hunger Games, #2) Catching Fire discussion


351 views
Robert Pattinson has confirmed he is NOT playing Finnick Odair in Catching Fire.

Comments Showing 1-50 of 69 (69 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

Jessica Some people were really upset when they found out he was going to play Finnick, which is odd because they were just rumours.
Robert said in a recent interview that he heard rumours and called his agent and she was like "um NO" hahahah so yeah, STOP WITH THE HATE! HE WAS NEVER GOING TO PLAY FINNICK SO ENOUGH NOW IT'S ALL OVER! :D IT'S OFFICIAL IT'S NOT ON :D


message 2: by Jo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jo Sadly, he was my first image of Finnick, then I changed my mind. Drastically.


Jessica My first image was Grant Gustin hahaha he would make a perfect Finnick in my eyes!


Caitlyn Wonderful news!


message 5: by Shannon (new) - added it

Shannon I can't believe that anyone would even believe that in the first place, tbh


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

YAY!!!!


C.C. He better not! lol, not hating on Pattinson(I like him) but Im sort of over him. I want a fresh (hot)face to play my favorite Finnick Odair :)


Rachel I agree


♥Day♥ YAY!!!!!


Jessie Jodoin thank goodness. he is a terrible actor, that would ruin the movie.


Danie thank the angels


VG/Allie Wait the guy from Twilight? *barf* (I hate Twilight)

I heard that it might be Sam from Tron: Lagacy... He was actualy the first person that came to mind when i thought of Finn


Danie wait.....how do u know this?


Chelsea Denisse Veggy wrote: "Wait the guy from Twilight? *barf* (I hate Twilight)

I heard that it might be Sam from Tron: Lagacy... He was actualy the first person that came to mind when i thought of Finn"


Yes! I heard that too, though hes not my first choice he would be pretty good


Michelle Herondale I hope Nick Roux get's the part.


Fatimah I hope they choose a 'fresh face' (new actor) to play my Finnick! <3


message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

Whoop whoop!!! RP is not playing Finnick!!!!!!
I seriously cant picture any actor I know playing Finnick maybe we need a newbie/fresh face/ some new actor nobody has ever heard of..but is really good at acting!! IM SO EXCITED!!


Danie ditto


Deanna Thank God... I like RP for some parts, but he is definitely not right for Finnick.


Kalob What a shame, he's such a good actor.


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

Ehmagawd. I hate RPattz.


message 22: by [deleted user] (new)

Yay! No RP:)


message 23: by CM (new) - rated it 5 stars

CM he is a really good actor, but I could not picture him as Finnick Odair


message 24: by [deleted user] (new)

PEOPLE WHO WANT RP AS FINNICK R EITHER A) SERIOUSLY MESSED UP IN THE HEAD OR B) OBSESSED WITH TWILIGHT ( and I like twilight)
if u read my earlier review this would make sense 2 u


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

THE NAME PEOPLE^^^^^^^


message 26: by Kalob (last edited May 29, 2012 06:34PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kalob Kelsey a.k.a. BOOK GODDESS wrote: "PEOPLE WHO WANT RP AS FINNICK R EITHER A) SERIOUSLY MESSED UP IN THE HEAD OR B) OBSESSED WITH TWILIGHT ( and I like twilight)
if u read my earlier review this would make sense 2 u"


Just because the Twilight movies are...kinda bad (popular opinion, some people like it) doesn't mean he's a bad actor. He played a good sparkly vampire, as far a sparkly vampires go. He also was Cedric Diggory in Harry Potter. He was good in that.


message 27: by [deleted user] (new)

I repeat^^^^^^^^^^^^^^


Johns Kalob wrote: "Kelsey a.k.a. BOOK GODDESS wrote: "PEOPLE WHO WANT RP AS FINNICK R EITHER A) SERIOUSLY MESSED UP IN THE HEAD OR B) OBSESSED WITH TWILIGHT ( and I like twilight)
if u read my earlier review this wo..."


No way! Are you yankin' my chain? You're serious?! Holy Crap! That's awesome! I love Harry Potter! But I'm glad he isn't Finnick.


Johns Nevermind. He looks the same now as he did then. I guess I just didn't remember.


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)

I SO LOVE HARRY POTTER!


message 31: by [deleted user] (new)

Erylla *Anti-Twilight* ProudToBePinay~ wrote: "I SO LOVE HARRY POTTER!"

I never said anything about HArry Potter so " I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!!!!" dont b hating me just cuz i also like Twilight



Atlantic Gem REJOICE!!!!! I just don't see him as Finnick. (He was good as Cedric though.)


Jessica I love Robert, he's an amazing actor and his performance in Remember Me was great. Like any actor, he's good for some roles, not so good for others.
I always pictured Grant Gustin for Finnick, but I think the reason why everyone was so against RP for Finnick was because to people who aren't his fans, he is and will always be 'Edward Cullen' you know?
But I HATE it when people say he's a bad actor when they base it off of Twilight. Twilight was a hard script to give justice to, and after 5 movies even he is sick of it.
If he is such a terrible actor, why is his movie Cosmopolis in the Cannes Film Festival and why does he have 5 other projects coming up?


Rachel Who cares?? I hate twilight anyway. He wouldn't make a good Finnick.


message 35: by Mary (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mary Kalob wrote: "Kelsey a.k.a. BOOK GODDESS wrote: "PEOPLE WHO WANT RP AS FINNICK R EITHER A) SERIOUSLY MESSED UP IN THE HEAD OR B) OBSESSED WITH TWILIGHT ( and I like twilight)
if u read my earlier review this wo..."


LOL... good sparkly vampire.


message 36: by Mary (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mary Jessica wrote: "My first image was Grant Gustin hahaha he would make a perfect Finnick in my eyes!"

I agree with you all the way.


message 37: by Tori (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tori Thank goodness.


message 38: by [deleted user] (new)

THE NAME ^^^^^^^^


Abbie YAY! That so would've ruined the whole thing for me!


Adrianne De Veyra Jessica wrote: "My first image was Grant Gustin hahaha he would make a perfect Finnick in my eyes!"

I totally agree! He actually want the part^^


message 41: by Eva (new)

Eva King I think RP is too skinny to play Finnick, if they had to choose an actor from twilight I think the one that played Emmet (whats his name??). I rember reading somewhere that twilight actors couldnt do HG, cant remember the reasons, maybe because they are both from summit.


message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

Eva wrote: "I think RP is too skinny to play Finnick, if they had to choose an actor from twilight I think the one that played Emmet (whats his name??). I rember reading somewhere that twilight actors couldnt ..."

EMMETT ROCKS!!!


message 43: by Gege (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gege Walter thank god RP isnt playing finnick!! i reckon he would have ruined it if he did..


message 44: by [deleted user] (new)

Haha i was thinking he would. As he played Edward Cullen; bronze hair, green eyes... Ringing a bell, twihards? I'm not a t-light lover in case you're wondering but i have read the books. Edward when he's human has bronze hair and green eyes and was good looking. Isn't that how Finnick was described???
Let's not talk about the sugar cubes... :)
})i({


Kaitlynn Heller Hey if he did play finnick you would of watched him get eaten by dogs.

I don't want him to play Finnick either so phew.

Not offending anyone who has an obsession for him still don't understand why people did.


Maria Jessica wrote: "Some people were really upset when they found out he was going to play Finnick, which is odd because they were just rumours.
Robert said in a recent interview that he heard rumours and called his ..."

What a relief!


Annie Katrin wrote: "Sorry, he'll always be Edward in my eyes <<<333 though i think i couldve gotten used to him as Finnick."

me too, but yeah he will always be Edward in mine too


Jessie -bows down repeatedly- thank god.


message 49: by Amn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amn Thank God!!


message 50: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna Oh Thank you! I would have probably shoot myself if he was playing Finnick! Not that i don't think that Robert Pattinson can't act it's just he's Edward! We need someone new to play Finnick Odair


« previous 1
back to top