Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (Harry Potter, #2) Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets discussion


1045 views
Would You Rather?

Comments Showing 101-150 of 597 (597 new)    post a comment »

Nati^^the insane, laughing  panda^^ A. I'd rather be the teachers pet

Q. Would you rather have James and Lily as your parents or have them as your best friends?
or
Q. Would you rather be important to Harry personally but actually be a Death Eater or not be important to Harry but be on his side?


Kallie~ Can'tLive-WithOrWithoutYou Hadley ・I LOVE HARRY POTTER!!!・ wrote: "Zino wrote: "A: Definitely Cedric

Q: Would you rather remain at Hogwarts or go looking for Horcruxes?"

A. Remain at Hogwarts! Definitely! Unless I was Hermione, then I would go with Harry looking..."


A:Prof McGonagall... I think Voldemort would still be scary no matter what! Lol-
Q: Would you rather- Win the Quidditch World Cup, or win the Tri-Wizard Tornament?


message 103: by MJ (last edited May 20, 2012 01:00PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

MJ A: The Quidditch World Cup!

Q: Which animal would be you rather have as your patronus: stag, snake, weasel, rabbit, wolf?


Kallie~ Can'tLive-WithOrWithoutYou MJ wrote: "A: The Quidditch World Cup!

Q: Which animal would be you rather have as your patronus: stag, snake, weasel, rabbit, wolf?"


A:Wolf (you can play this more than once right?!!)hehe
Q:Would you rather: be able to talk to snakes, or have the mental link with Voldemort?


message 105: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne A: I'd love to talk to snakes.

Q: Be in the picture with Sirius's mother but, you cant talk or scream back, and you cant do anything bad to her, or be Umbridge's least favorite student?


Justece Be in the pic with Sirius's mother.

Would you rather date:
If ur a guy- Ginny or Hermoine?
If ur a girl- Dean Thomas or Ron?


message 107: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne A: Dean Thomas even though I dont remember what he looks like.

Q:be married to Wormtail or Snape


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Snape, I'm not marrying a rat!

Q. If you had one chance to use a spell before the ministry of magic took your wand away, Would you rather use a forgetting spell on him, or use the avada-kadabra?

(I can't spell it :)


Kallie~ Can'tLive-WithOrWithoutYou A:Oblivate! (however you spell it)the forgetting spell
Q:WYR- Take potions with Snape, or Dyvination with Prof. Trawlayne?(sorry about the spelling!)


Justece Divination.

WYR have Harry hate you forever or be expelled from Hogwarts?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Oh, Definitely have Harry Hate me forever,I love the rivalry between him and Draco!

Q. Would you Rather Die in the forbidden forest, (a long death by spiders) or stay at Hogwarts in Harrys' year 7 and be tortured?


Georgie A: I'd stay at Hogwarts. I'm worse than Ron when it comes to spiders ;)

Q: Would you rather have Pansy Parkinson or Millicent Bulstrode as a roommate (if you're female)?
OR
Would you rather have Vincent Crabbe or Cormac McLaggen as a roommate (if you're male)?


message 113: by Kendra (last edited May 22, 2012 12:29PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kendra Smolen I'd have to go with Millicent. I'd probably wind up in a headlock alarmingly frequently, but Pansy seems like she'd be the type of roommate that eats your food and uses your shampoo.

Would you rather have to walk down a busy city street in Ron's Yule Ball robes for three hours or wear that same outfit to brunch with the Dursleys?


message 114: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne A: Brunch with the Dursley's, at least they wouldnt say it was improper, it is A DRESS ROBE FOR GODS SAKE!

Q: Be killed by Centaurs or be killed by Grawp (Hagrid's Giant Bro)


message 115: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne A: Brunch with the Dursley's, at least they wouldnt say it was improper, it is A DRESS ROBE FOR GODS SAKE!

Q: Be killed by Centaurs or be killed by Grawp (Hagrid's Giant Bro)


message 116: by Jordan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jordan A: Grawp because it'll be over in an instant. He sits on you your dead. If a centaur attacks you than your going to be suffering.

Q: Would you rather be cursed with the crusiades curse or the imperium curse?


message 117: by Darcie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Darcie A: Crusiades curse i'd rather be torchered than be under someone elses control where they could potentially make me kill someone i love.

Q: If you were Lilly and had to choose between being with James Potter or Snape who would you rather be with?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. I HATTTTTTE!!!!! Snakes, so id have to go with being stuck in a jar :)

Q. If you were controlled and had to kill one person of your choice Would you rather Kill Professor Snape or Professor McGonagal?


message 119: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne A: Snape I <3 McGonagall, and she would <3 me 2!

Q: Would you rather Baby Sit Dudley and his friends and his parents died so basically your the mom, but he hates you and he is 15 4EVER or Be put in the grave yard with Voldemort where his father died.


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Baby Sit Dudley, he deserves a slap and I wont hesitate to give it to him.......

Q. Would you rather have to spend a night with Nagini staring at you, threatening to strike or be locked up with Professor Snape digging through your mind for the same amount of time?


Mas5thgrade2012 Voldemort

Q. Would you rather have Albus Severus as your cousin or Ron?


message 122: by Kendra (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kendra Smolen Albus Severus.

Would you rather eat 20 cockroach clusters or 20 puking pastilles?


JazzyCat Cockroache clusters.

Q. Would you rather go to the Yule Ball with Fred or George?


message 124: by [deleted user] (new)

Fred

Q. Would you rather ride on a hippogriff or a dragon?


Georgie A: Hippogriff. Any day of the week.
Q: Would you rather be given the very last Time-Turner in existence, or Dumbledore's Pensieve?


Kimberlee Dumbledore's Pensieve I think.


Katherine A: Prof. McGonagall- She is freaky and gets on my nerves, but she won't kill me

Q: Would you rather kill Harry or Hermione-by accident?


Katherine A: A time-turner, so I could change the horrible past


message 129: by Brynne (new) - rated it 5 stars

Brynne Mas5thgrade2012 wrote: "Voldemort

Q. Would you rather have Albus Severus as your cousin or Ron?"


WHO IS ALBUS SEVERUS ARE YOU KIDDING ME GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT ITS ALBUS DUMBLEDORE!


message 130: by mercy (new) - rated it 5 stars

mercy No, Albus Severus is Harry's kid. Take a chill pill, okay? No need to freak out!


message 131: by Kate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kate Agreed.


Madeline Prof. McGonagall when angry.

Q. Would you rather watch only the HP movies for the rest of your life or only read the HP books for the rest of you life.


message 133: by Alya (last edited May 26, 2012 12:27PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alya A: Read the Harry Potter books for the rest of my life.

Q: Would you rather have a tarnished and practically destroyed version of HP7 with J.K Rowlings autograph, or a brand new one without her autograph?


message 134: by Kat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kat K. A: Most definitely practically destroyed copy WITH her autograph.

Q:Would you rather attend the Yule Ball or Bill and Fleur's wedding?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. A broomstick means nothing compared to a Therstral (Depends if I could see them :)

Q. would you rather spend a week in Dracos' houses' dungeon or die at voldemorts hand?


Georgie A: I'd really rather not be killed by Voldemort, so I'll spend a week at Malfoy Manor.

Q: Would you rather be a Metamorphmagus or be the brightest witch/wizard of your age?


message 137: by Kelli (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kelli -I would rather attend the Quidditch World Cup. Go Bulgarian National Quidditch team!
-I would rather have Snape breathing down my neck. What a heart of stone. I feel a challenge to melt it.
-I would rather confront Dumbledore. I would feel I would have a chance to apologize and beg for forgiveness before it was too late.
-The Monster Book of Monsters, by Edwardus Lima FTW!
-I would rather confront a Basilisk as long as I was in the chamber of secrets. All those tunnels give a girl places to hide!
-Race through the Maze even though Barty Crouch Jr is helping Harry.
-If I can't join in on the fun then Muggle.
-I would rather make out with Harry Potter. HOT!
-I would rather be an animagus. Dragon!
-Gamekeeper for Hogwarts.
-Hermoine to watch my back in a duel against Death Eaters.
-Both are ick...Burp up Slugs.
-I dont want to expelled or go to Azkaban.
-I would rather live at 12 Grimmauld Place as long as I can redecorate and get rid of the hag.
-If I went to the Yuel Ball I would want to go with Harry.
-I would travel by Thestral. Not every house has a fireplace. Who wants soot on your face, clothes, hair.
-Hedwig as she is not only a companion but a mail carrier.
-Forbidden Forest since I am the gamekeeper (wink)
-I would go on a date with Victor Krum. He is hot.
-I would rather watch Snape die so that I might be able to talk to him before he dies.
-The school for me is Hogwarts! FTW.
-Detention with Snape in the Forbidden Forest.
-I would leave the school to look for Horcruxes.
-Slughorn. I would learn potions better under praise.
-24hrs in the chamber of secrets. More room to run.
-5000 galleons at Madam Malkin's Robes for All Occasions.
-I would rather fight a dragon.

Q. If you had to mirror a characters death in the Harry Potter series would you rather die like Dumbledore- killed by Snape -or- would you rather die like Regulus Arcturus Black killed by the inferi.


message 138: by Shaney (new) - rated it 5 stars

Shaney A: I would be the brightest witch of my age cause knowledge is my life line.

Q: Would you rather be in Gryffindor or Slytherin?


message 139: by Nataly (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nataly Kendyl wrote: "Voldemort if he grows his nose back

Q. Would you rather make out with Ron or with Harry? If you are a boy, Hermonie or Ginny?"

RON :)


message 140: by Nataly (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nataly Zino wrote: "A: Definitely Cedric

Q: Would you rather remain at Hogwarts or go looking for Horcruxes?"


This is a hard question but i think id rather go looking fpr the horcruxes


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ Shaney wrote: "A: I would be the brightest witch of my age cause knowledge is my life line.

Q: Would you rather be in Gryffindor or Slytherin?"


A. Ohhh, hard question....slytherin. I don't know why.

Q. would you rather win 5,000,000 Galleons or fight against Voldemort and win (In front of everyone!)?


 Sarah☺ A:Fight against Voldemort and win.

Q: would you rather be known as the worst witch or wizard, or be McGonnagall's teacher's pet and everyone knew?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. McGonnagall's teachers pet, (I'd have to be her pet for a reason, and if anyone teased me-I'd turn them into a slug!)

Q. Would you rather be turned into a slug for a day-or turned into a spider for half a day, while being kept in ajar?


message 144: by Karlee (last edited Jun 02, 2012 08:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karlee A I'd definitely be a spider for aday because slugs are gross and slow.

Q. Would you rather be stuck with Peeves or moaning myrtle for a day?


message 145: by ♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ (last edited May 29, 2012 12:37AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Peeves-By Miles!

Q. Would You Rather Take a Fever Fudge or a ton-tongue toffee (from Weasly Wizard wheezes!)?


message 146: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana I would take the fever fudge.

Would rather own the ressurection stone or the elder wand?


message 147: by Tjala (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tjala Elder Wand
Would you rather die fighting for what you believed really really horribly or join Voldermort if he promised not to kill you?


Micaela Die fighting for what I believe

Would you rather want to be throwing up slugs or have your teeth grow rapidly?


message 149: by Tjala (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tjala Have my teeth grow quickly.
Would you rather meet Ron or Harry?


message 150: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana I would meet Harry!

Would you rather go for a swim in the lake (where all the the grindylows, merpeople and giant squid live) or get lost in the forbidden forest?


back to top