Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (Harry Potter, #2) Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets discussion


1045 views
Would You Rather?

Comments Showing 51-100 of 597 (597 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Kate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kate A. Listen to Mrs. Black's portrait. At least you could scream back.

Q. Would you rather be stuck in the Forbidden Forest with Aragog's children or the hostile centaurs?


Biancka A. Prof. McGonagall deffs, she;s less likely to kill me :)

Q. Would you rather go out with neville long bottom or dudley?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Neville!

Q. Would You Rather Have The Hungarian Horntail or the Chinese Fireball to fight in the triwizard tournament?


Sophie A. The Chinese Fireball - the Hungarian Horntail's vicious!

Q. Would you rather be best friends with Luna or Ginny?


message 55: by Zino (new) - rated it 4 stars

Zino A: Luna

Q: Would you rather be a house elf or goblin?


Brynne You guys need to quit making questions when another is already going through! If you are answering a question someone else already answered and put a questions, then out what you would do with NO question!


Vymletoza A: goblin. who would like to be a house elf?

Q: would you rather be seeker or a beater?


message 58: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna A: Beater. I'm pretty strong and not at all fast.

Q: Would you rather be a pureblood or a half-blood?


Brynne Ah-bviously pure...


message 60: by Vymletoza (last edited May 16, 2012 02:49AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Vymletoza really? I would rather be half-blood. that way I would know everything about both worlds. and muggle studies will be too easy for me.... but I think muggle born would be better. just imagine if someone told you when you were 11 that there is magic... incredible.

Q: would you rather kill Umbridge or Wormtail?


Brynne Ooh...tough, I'd say...Bellatrix, because if you broke out of Azkaban, everyone would be on the lookout for you, and I'd say Umbridge, because Wormtail is only doing what Voldemort says because he doesnt want to die.

Q: Would you rather live with the Dursleys, or live at Sirius's house? I forgot what it was called.


Brynne Nawang wrote: "Midnight wrote: "A:I would rather live with the Dursleys.


Q:Would you rather use the avada kedavra on Snape or Malfoy?"

That is one difficult question."


No, because since Malfoy's father was acught deatheater, he cant do anything bad to you well he can but you get the point, anyways, Snape can so you would kill Snape. Comment if you agree!




Brynne Sophie-Lousie wrote: "A. The Chinese Fireball - the Hungarian Horntail's vicious!

Q. Would you rather be best friends with Luna or Ginny?"




Ginny! Shes awesome!


Kim Ray A. Ginny, she's cute. haha

Q. Would you rather have ron or hermione doing another entire book/movie series dedicated to him/her?


Barbara Murray McGonagall--at least she's just.
Q: WYR date Dudley Dursley or Gregory Goyle? (if you're a boy, Pansy Parkinson or Marietta Edgecomb?)


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A: How long do we have to date them for?

Q: Would you rather have Sirius or Remus as a godfather, (Saying, as if, they were both still alive.)


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Live at Hogwarts? or do you mean attend? Because if it was live, live than I would choose the burrow (Weasly's House) but if it was 'live at the Burrow or Attend Hogwarts' I'd have to say Hogwarts.

Q. Would you rather date Bill Weasly or Charlie Weasly? (If Bill wasn't Married with kids :)


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A: Voldemort, I want to change what he did. changing the world for good, not evil.
(By the way, I have to agree about Charlie working with dragons- being hot, I mean.)

Q. would you rather attempt to eat a Bertie every flavour bean or take your chances with the monster book of monsters?


message 69: by Raheena (last edited May 17, 2012 01:13AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Raheena Actually a hard choice but i'd take my chances with bertie botts every flavour bean

Would you rather take your chances against a rogue bludger or become best friends with professor lockhart???


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Professor Lockhart, he wont remember me after second-grade :P

Q. Would you rather be framed by Gildroy Lockhart or Face Voldemort?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Butter Beer, Definitely!

Q. If you could, Would you rather bring back, Tonks or Sirius from the Dead?


message 72: by Zino (last edited May 17, 2012 04:18AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Zino A: I love them both! but I think I'd bring back Tonks, she'd be so cool to have around

Q: Would you rather be the child of Harry & Ginny or Ron & Hermione?


message 73: by Raheena (last edited May 17, 2012 07:47AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Raheena Harry and ginny definitely :)

Would you rather have a lifetime illness of coughing up slugs or marry snape???


Loony A: Voldemort. McGonagall is absoulutly terrifing when she's angry.

Q: Would you rather fight your way through the Tri Wizard Cup or duel with Prof. Dumbledor?


message 75: by Anna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna A: fight in the Tri. That way, I could say, "Hey, I fought a dragon today. What did you do?"

Q: Would you rather have to clean every single brick of the Hogwarts School or have detention for a day with Umbridge?


Tjala Anna wrote: "A: fight in the Tri. That way, I could say, "Hey, I fought a dragon today. What did you do?"

Q: Would you rather have to clean every single brick of the Hogwarts School or have detention for a day..."


A: Have a detention with Umbridge, cleaning doesn't bode well with me!

Q: Would you rather have potions or defence against the dark arts if Snape was your teacher in both cases?


Georgie A: Definitely DAtDA. I'd probably be rubbish at potions, and he'd hate me for it :)

Q: Imagine you're competing in the Triwizard Tournament. Would you rather face a Hungarian Horntail or enter the maze?


message 78: by [deleted user] (new)

Q: would you rather be a Slytherin or a Grryfindor??


Brynne A:I would rather live with the Dursley's. I would have awesome comebacks for the insults they would throw at me, plus, after 17, or was it 16? I could use magic against them! :):):):)

Q: Would you rather be married to Voldemort, or make-out with Snape?


Brynne A:IDK. I am very sly, but I am also brave. I took one of those tests online, and I got tied for each.

Q:Would you rather live with Voldemort(who could kill you at anytime) or be traped by Devil's Snare?


Barbara Murray McGonagall--at least she is just and won't torture me.

Would you rather date Dudley Dursley or Gregory Goyle? (for guys--would you rather date Marietta Edgecomb or Millecent Bullstrode?


message 82: by [deleted user] (new)

A; gregory goyle- dudley is stupid and mean! atleast goyle is a wizard and for him u could always dump him
Q: would u rather date Fred or George Weasly?


message 83: by Lucy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lucy A. George Weasly, I couldn't deal with the loss...

Q. Would you rather be killed in the giant game of chess or face Quirrel? (the sorcerers stone)


Georgie A: Well if I'm definitely going to be killed, I might as well face Quirrel.

Q: You have a voucher offering unlimited spending- but only in one shop, in Hogsmeade. Would you rather spend it in Honeydukes or Zonko's?


Raheena Oh tough choice but.....probably Zonkos cause then I could pull pranks on everyone without them knowing Lol.

Would you rather marry Mr filch or kiss snape on the lips???


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Kiss Snape, Then I would tell him to use a forgetting spell on me :)

Q. Would you rather take potions with Professor Snape or Defence against the Dark Arts with Professor Quirral?


Brynne A:Defense against the Dark Arts with Quirrel. If I was harry, that is. All I'd have to do is touch is face and POOF! Hes gone.

Q:Would you rather live with Voldemort (who could kill you at anytime) or be trapped by Devil's Snare?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Ohhh, Hard one: Devils snare, (Just have to hold still!

Q. If you could live only one year at Hogwarts, would you choose Harry's' fifth year, or sixth Year?


Georgie A: Sixth year. I couldn't live with all of Umbridge's rules. And Umbridge herself, of course. ;)

Q: Would you rather spend the day discussing books with Hermione, or playing quidditch with Harry and Ron?


message 90: by Maggie (last edited May 18, 2012 08:41AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maggie Georgie wrote: "A: Sixth year. I couldn't live with all of Umbridge's rules. And Umbridge herself, of course. ;)

Q: Would you rather spend the day discussing books with Hermione, or playing quidditch with Harry a..."


A: Discussing books with Hermione.

Q: Which would you rather have: the resurrection stone, the invisibility cloak or the elder wand? (I know this isn't a Chamber of Secrets related question, sorry)


Georgie Natalie wrote: "Q: Which would you rather have: the resurrection stone, the invisibility cloak or the elder wand? (I know this isn't a Chamber of Secrets related question, sorry)

A: Neither, I would find no use ..."


A: Do you mean that I could go back in time to change events? If so, then I think I probably would.

Q: Would you rather attend the Yule Ball with Ron or Viktor?


Antica Georgie wrote: Q: Would you rather attend the Yule Ball with Ron or Viktor? ."

A. Victor Hands down ..

Q. Would you rather Play Wizard Chess or Quiddich?


Aoife QUIDDITCH!!!!

Q. If you could be an animagus, would you rather be a dog or a bird?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. Dog

Q. Would you Rather Harry Or Ron to ask you to the Yule Ball? (If you are a boy, Hermiony or Ginny?)


Brynne Q: Would you rather attend the Yule Ball with Ron or Viktor?

A: Viktor, he was so cute, but Ron was cuter when he was little, just not as much now...


Brynne A: Harry, he is adorable in so many ways, and he is brave!

Q: Would you rather be forced into a game of wizard's chess(you are not Ron) and you have to be one of the pieces, or would you rather have to live with quirrell, youre not aloud to kill him, and even is you tries, he got something from Voldemort to keep him alive,AND you have to sleep with him, AHB-viously we're pretending he didnt die here, okay, and he never will either.


P.S Who is that Lilly girl. She is weird check out her picture+she has language...not a good combination...


Willy A: Forced into a game of wizard chess as a piece.

Q: Would you rather vomit slugs for a day, or have your arms and feet glued to yourself for the same amount of time?


Brynne A: Arms and Feet glued.

Q:WYR be knocked off you're broom in front of the whole Slytherin house,and youre Gryffindor, or have to be known for being McGonagall's teacher's pet by everybody BUT the Slytherins, and you are on Ravenclaw?


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ A. McGonagall's Teahers Pet.

Q. Would You Rather Be known as a 'Mudblood' or Vomit slugs?


 Sarah☺ A. Be known as a mudblood.

Q. Would you rather have all of Gideroy Lochart's books signed on display for everyone or be his teacher's pet?


back to top