Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil discussion


138 views
Discussion Questions I found online...

Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

Jessica
1. Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil begins with a portrait of Jim Williams, the man around whom the book's "plot" revolves. Yet the author sweeps Williams offstage after one chapter and we do not encounter him again until the end of Chapter 11, when we learn that he shot Danny Hansford. What does Berendt accomplish by doing this? Is Midnight truly Williams's story, and if not, who is its real protagonist?

2. Do you come away from this book believing that Williams is guilty of murder? How does the evidence that surfaces during his trials reinforce or contradict the impression that Berendt conveys elsewhere in the book? How do Williams's friends view him? Is it possible to believe in Williams's guilt yet still feel sympathy for him? Where else does the author elicit sympathy for characters who are morally flawed and perhaps genuinely evil?

3. In short order it becomes clear that Savannah is full of mysterious characters, from the man with the invisible dog to the salesman who makes up his left eye with purple eyeshadow while leaving the other unadorned for the benefit of his boss. How much do we end up knowing about the people in this book? Is it Berendt's intention to reveal his characters or to draw our attention to their eccentricities, the inconsistencies in the selves that they present to the world? How different would these characters be if they lived in a city like New York or Los Angeles?

4. As elaborate as these façades are, Berendt suggests that they are also transparent. The salesman's boss knows that he wears makeup on one eye, just as none of Lee Adler's old associates buy his altruistic pretensions. Why, then, might the characters in this book maintain their various masquerades? Is Berendt saying anything about the façades that all of us adopt in order to survive?

5. How does the transvestite Chablis embody contradictions that Berendt explores elsewhere in the book? Is Chablis Midnight's most deceitful character or its most honest one? What distinction does the author make between the Lady Chablis's "act" and the social masquerades of Lee Adler, Joe Odom, or Jim Williams?

6. Do you think of Chablis as male or female? Why has she chosen not to undergo sex-change surgery? By what logic can she say that her boyfriend--who knows her true gender--is "straight" [p. 102:]? For that matter, can Chablis be said to have a "true" gender? How would you compare Chablis's brand of femininity to Serena Dawes's or Mandy Nichols's? What vision of gender does this book impart to us?

7. Alongside his human characters, Berendt gives us detailed histories and descriptions of several houses. To what extent are his characters defined by the homes they live in and the objects they use to furnish them? Moreover, what role does geography, from the location of Joe Odom's latest apartment to Savannah's position on the Georgia coast, play in this book?

8. Danny Hansford is only one of the many people whose violent deaths we learn about in the course of Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. Judging by their stories, what does Savannah (or Savannah society) deem grounds for murder? Why are so few of Jim Williams's friends disturbed by the charges against him? Given the casualness with which Savannahians greet the Hansford case, why are they so shocked by the news [p. 333:] that their city has been declared the murder capital of the United States?

9. Although Williams behaves as though he were innocent of any wrongdoing, he also goes to elaborate lengths to conceal the fact of his imprisonment from his clients. How do you account for this? In what ways are the contradictions in his conduct typical of his city?

10. It is almost immediately obvious that Jim Williams is gay and that Danny is his gigolo, but no one comments on this until the first murder trial. Williams's greatest fear seems to be that his mother will learn the truth about his sexual orientation. Chablis claims that "the South is one big drag show" [p. 101:], but if so, it is one where four men can be acquitted of a brutal killing when the victim turns out to be homosexual [p. 205:]. What roles do homosexuality and homophobia play in this book? How do Berendt's Savannahians--both gay and straight--variously conceal, deny, or accommodate their sexuality?

11. "We don't do black-on-white in Savannah," Joe Odom tells Berendt. "A lot may have changed here in the last twenty years, but not that" [p. 54:]. What role does race--and the elaborate restrictions that surround it--play in this book? How would you characterize the relations between Berendt's white and black characters? What artifices have various Savannahians devised to cross the color line--or tunnel under it? What institutions have black Savannahians evolved on their side of that line?

12. Early in the book, Joe Odom gives the author three rules for surviving in Savannah [p. 48:]. What are these rules and how reliable do they turn out to be? What does Berendt accomplish by making his (and the reader's) principal guide turn out to be a professional con man?

13. The "Garden of Good and Evil" is Bonaventure cemetery, which the author visits at the book's beginning and end. What role do the dead play in Berendt's narrative? How do they influence its action and haunt the living characters? In what way does Savannah's attitude toward its dead seem more pagan than Christian?

14. Frustrated by his attorneys' failure to win an acquittal, Williams hires a conjure woman to work on his behalf. How successful are Minerva's efforts compared to those of more conventional specialists? What beliefs underlie her magic? In what way can the belief systems of the book's other characters be described as magical?

15. How do we end up feeling about the character of "John Berendt"? What does the author accomplish by making himself a character in his book--or, rather, by creating a character who happens to have his name and profession?

16. Was Danny Hansford responsible for his own death? Do you come away from this book believing that he was about to kill Williams or that he was merely what Spencer Lawton says he was: "a pawn in a sick little game of manipulation and exploitation" [p. 229:]? How do you feel on learning that commentators regard Danny as merely "a good time not yet had by all" [p. 178:]? How did Danny fit into Savannah's rigidly stratified society? Why--and at whom--might he be laughing at the book's climax?


Leslie I loved the book and the movie. I wish I could have attended one of his parties! Good questions--could have used them 10 or more years ago.


Vince Lots of good questions, but I'll simply observe that you can almost read the book along with the movie. I believe the movie was expertly done, and it sticks much closer to the book than most book-based movies.


message 4: by Mia (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mia I agree, the movie was a pretty strong adaptation. The only thing I didn't really care for in the movie was the thrown in romance-thing with Mandy. I liked her character in the book, but she lost some of her charm in the movie (I just love it when she says, "I can't miss my soaps" in the book. Hilarious!)

I also thought the wardrobe for the movie should've kept Billy's F You t-shirt. It summed up his character's agressiveness so well.

Those are some great questions.


Carole888 I loved both the book and the movie. I wish I could visit Savannah and the do a Midnight tour. It would be great to visit the place but we are too far away!! I went online and checked out as many places as I could for it added to the whole experience of reading the book. I love the cover, ... Jack Leigh's photograph of the Bird Girl in the Bonaventura cemetry. It has been a while since I read the book but so much has stayed with me. Those characters were fascinating and looking at question 3 ... for me, they belonged in Savannah so I don't think it would be the same to have them in NY or LA


Melissa Rees I went to Savannah and went through the "Jim Williams" home. It's smaller than I thought it would be, but very elegant. It's mysterious and walking around the square was fun. We ate at Paula Deans and strolled along the River Walk. I loved Savannah and enjoyed the visit. It's costly, though...


Phleabas Both the book and the film were brilliant. I really loved the atmosphere they immersed you in, and the songs in the film were exquisitely chosen. I actually read the book after seeing the film expecting to be disappointed, in one or the other, but the opposite was true. While the questions posed are very interesting - from the perspective of the novel and the film - I wouldn't want to know the answers, if indeed a single answer existed to each question! To me, the brilliance of the story lies in the general atmosphere and the mystery that it creates, the way it makes one feel. Knowing the answers to all the questions would unravel the mystery and take away from the eccentricities of the characters in the story. Ultimately, what is really ‘normal’?

Of course as the book has basis in actual events, one must separate between the two and pose another question. How close to reality was the book?


Zilverña I'm curious by your comments...I hope I could see the movie version.:[


Cherie Waggie I was surprised and pleased by this book, because going by the title, I expected a horror story. It wasn't. The book was actually very good, although it was obvious who the killer was. And I liked the movie too.


back to top

all discussions on this book | post a new topic


Books mentioned in this topic

Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil (other topics)