Vaginal Fantasy Book Club discussion

The Iron Duke (Iron Seas, #1)
This topic is about The Iron Duke
299 views
2012 Archives > Apr 2012: I think I missed something.

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Madison (madison1964) | 8 comments First off, I have to admit I wasn't looking forward to this book. While I love the Steampunk aesthetic, I haven't been impressed by the literature. My first impression was corroborated by the cute, male librarian who checked the book out for me. He took one look at the cover and said, "What's with his abs? Is he supposed to be a robot?" Dear boy, if you only knew...

Anyway.

Turns out I liked this book. Read it in one day. I'm sure I missed something. My big question is: Why in the world did they drop the body on the Iron Duke's doorstep? Was that explained? Why bring yourself to the attention of someone like Rhys? Seems like a doofus thing to do (like waking the dragon) if you're trying to keep your plans secret.


Becky (audthryth) | 33 comments Well the Dame Sawtooth and all of her crew were hurt by the weapons demonstration. I saw it as her way of getting the Iron Duke on the Black Guard's trail. She didn't owe them any favors at that point.


Coral (coralm) | 58 comments She hated Rhys because he killed her honey a while back. Killing the Admiral's grandson and dumping him on Rhys's doorstep was just a way to hurt him before she died.


message 4: by Madison (last edited Apr 15, 2012 03:55AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Madison (madison1964) | 8 comments Becky wrote: "Well the Dame Sawtooth and all of her crew were hurt by the weapons demonstration. I saw it as her way of getting the Iron Duke on the Black Guard's trail. She didn't owe them any favors at that ..."

You could be right. Is there anything in the book that states Dame Sawtooth did it? Looking for page numbers. I don't think the mystery that began everything was explicitly solved. It shouldn't have been left to conjecture.


Madison (madison1964) | 8 comments Coral wrote: "She hated Rhys because he killed her honey a while back. Killing the Admiral's grandson and dumping him on Rhys's doorstep was just a way to hurt him before she died."

Same question. Is it written in the book? I wonder if Dame Sawtooth would have thought Rhys knew the new captain of his ship since he'd given it to the navy and wasn't involved with staffing it. How would Sawtooth know that Rhys knew the Admiral's grandson. I'm willing to admit I might have missed it while I was reading but I couldn't find anything specific as I was looking back either.


Coral (coralm) | 58 comments Madison wrote: "Same question. Is it written in the book?"

Yup. The guy that's taking care of Dame Sawtooth when they find her (can't remember his name just now) tells them the whole story straight out. She knew she was dying and she wanted to do something to get back at Rhys.

And Rhys didn't know the Admiral's grandson on sight, but either she didn't know that or I suppose she imagined that he could figure it out.


Becky (audthryth) | 33 comments You'll have to forgive me because I can't give page numbers. On the Kindle at 2355 there's this exchange (that's 36% of the way into the book):

"Who dropped Haynes in London?"
"I did, for her. She was already sick and wanted it done." Evans's face seemed to crumple. "We used almost all of our ice on him."

Now that I re-read that section I have to kind of agree. Why waste ice to preserve a dead man would it could have saved your life and the life of some of your crew? Admittedly the naval bombing starts at that point and the conversation gets cut off. It never really does get resolved.


Madison (madison1964) | 8 comments Thanks Becky. It seems really weird and kind of thrown together at the last minute.


Tara I don't get the impression that Dame Sawtooth was all that terribly sane and logical even before the bug fever. :)


message 10: by Saoirse (new)

Saoirse Did she not do it to let Rhys know that she had the Marco's Terror? That is what drove her mad in the first place, that Rhys had settled down and given her dead beloveds ship to the Navy


Coral (coralm) | 58 comments Saoirse wrote: "Did she not do it to let Rhys know that she had the Marco's Terror? That is what drove her mad in the first place, that Rhys had settled down and given her dead beloveds ship to the Navy"

Right! He'd basically given up the ship in the hopes that he wouldn't have to kill her.


Jessica (gingasaurus) | 5 comments I think I had more of an issue that they used all their ice on a dead guy when it could have saved at the very least the Dame from bug fever if not other crew members. If Evans cared about her that much wouldn't he have lied to his delirious lover and helped her recuperate?


message 13: by Marian (new) - added it

Marian (mariankrick) I'm glad I stumbled upon this post, because I was missing that information too. Now it makes more sense. :)


back to top