Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Nagini.... I did not know this... Read to find out...
Wrong they are two different snakes.-Boa's aren't poisonous and in the book they describe it differently.
-There is no known species of venomous snake matching Nagini's description.
Also, a fan made it to trick all those Harry Potter fans. Also, it The Boa was bred in captivity and the one in the Zoo was a male not a female.
but the snake didnt attack harry and it seemed nice compared to Nagini....I dont think so...
definitely NOT Nagini
I laughed at how many people came in, saying "Oh, yeah, I already knew that." Really? People need to read the most recent posts before posting at all... -_____-
I repeat what everyone's already said: Nagini IS NOT the snake Harry released in the first book.
nagini's on a plane.
Julia wrote: "Lol, yeah I knew that.J.K. Rowling is honestly- and I'm not just saying this because I love Harry Potter- a freaking genius!!! She has so many unspoken little hints hidden throughout the entire se..."
lol u kneew that lol its not tru
Amanda wrote: "Samantha wrote: "Based on the difference in breed I'm inclined to agree with the naysayers (the polite ones) but to those naysayers I'd like to say that I don't remember knowing how long Voldemorte..."
Jane wrote: "nagini's on a plane."Yes. This is the truth.
Shatha wrote: "Nikki wrote: "http://harrypotterismylife.tumblr.com..."according to this; nagini is NOT who you (Nasra) are saying she is."
Thank you.
Nasra wrote: "I just found out that the snake Harry released in book 1 turned out to be Nagini. Did anybody else know this!?"Lies.
Those are two different snakes... I thought.... It doesn't really make sense that they are both Nagini...
@Shelby...you're right there are two different snakes....this conversation is just going on and on because people who come across it haven't been reading some of the other posts
Ashley wrote: "I knew this after hearing it somewhere.
The reason Harry was able to talk to it was because the snake was a Horcrux and so was Harry(even though he didn't know yet, much less us)and we don't exact..."
Hahahaha...that's all total fabrication and utter bull!!Harry can talk to any snake...did you actually read the books? he talks to the one that was conjured in the dual...or was that Nagini too...i guess it must have been seeing as there can only possibly be one snake in the entire world!! He speaks Parsel toungue...therefore he can speak to ANY snake, that's also how he gets in to the chamber of secrets...duh.
The reason Harry was able to talk to it was because the snake was a Horcrux and so was Harry(even though he didn't know yet, much less us)and we don't exact..."
Hahahaha...that's all total fabrication and utter bull!!Harry can talk to any snake...did you actually read the books? he talks to the one that was conjured in the dual...or was that Nagini too...i guess it must have been seeing as there can only possibly be one snake in the entire world!! He speaks Parsel toungue...therefore he can speak to ANY snake, that's also how he gets in to the chamber of secrets...duh.
I agree with Nikki
Steph wrote: "Ashley wrote: "I knew this after hearing it somewhere. The reason Harry was able to talk to it was because the snake was a Horcrux and so was Harry(even though he didn't know yet, much less us)an..."
Are you human or you do you think people can't make mistakes? A theory is a theory. IF it was the same snake that is how it would have happened. So there. By the way, I would think someone your age would know better how to communicate without being rude and immature, aparently you can't. By the way I have read every hp book- but i haven't read them lately because I need a new set because mine are so worn out :P
Ashley wrote: "Steph wrote: "Ashley wrote: "I knew this after hearing it somewhere.
The reason Harry was able to talk to it was because the snake was a Horcrux and so was Harry(even though he didn't know yet, mu..."
Yes I am human, your theory doesn't make sense and you were not passing it off as a theory you stated it as truth...this entire thread shows it as wrong but your reading skills didn't stretch to seeing that did they. 'so there'
The reason Harry was able to talk to it was because the snake was a Horcrux and so was Harry(even though he didn't know yet, mu..."
Yes I am human, your theory doesn't make sense and you were not passing it off as a theory you stated it as truth...this entire thread shows it as wrong but your reading skills didn't stretch to seeing that did they. 'so there'
the snake in the first book was a boa. anybody who dares argue that fact need to read the first book all over again. there's even a sign next to its display in the movie specifying what type of snake it is. seriously, I'd check my sources before posting something as stupid and idiotic as this.
also, has anybody thought of googling this?
ana just to catch you up...most of us have already agreed that nagini isn't the snake from the first one...and commenting about how it isn't from the first movie is just proving to be pointless since everyone agrees with each other
Sela wrote: "ana just to catch you up...most of us have already agreed that nagini isn't the snake from the first one...and commenting about how it isn't from the first movie is just proving to be pointless sin..."you dont have to be so mean about it lol i just wanted to make my point
As others have said...Nagini was a horcrux created during Voldemorts first reign. She was also a giant viper.The snake in the zoo that Harry freed was "Bred in captivity". he was also a regular sized boa constrictor.
End. Of. Discussion. Lol :)
I seem to recall JK once saying she thought it would have been cool if the two were linked in some way, but she hadn't thought of it when she was writing the books so no, they weren't. I don't recall when or where I heard that though so I am unable to give a source :(
That's not true. They are not the same species. Also, it's not true that the baby who played 1 year old Harry played Albus Severus Potter in The Deathly Hallows Part 2. That's another rumour that's just not true.
ow was nagini in a zoo? How were they able to captivate a dark wizards horcrux?
Gracieface wrote: "ow was nagini in a zoo? How were they able to captivate a dark wizards horcrux?"nagini wasn't in a zoo, they weren't able to captivate a dark wizard's horcrux
Nasra wrote: "I just found out that the snake Harry released in book 1 turned out to be Nagini. Did anybody else know this!?"Didn't the snake that Harry freed talk in a male voice? Nagini is female, not male, plus Nagini is bigger than the snake Harry freed (I'm going by what I saw in the movie, not the book). That's obviously a rumor.
Nasra wrote: "I just found out that the snake Harry released in book 1 turned out to be Nagini. Did anybody else know this!?"
i did not know that!
i did not know that!
Neesh_satsumaXD wrote: "Nasra wrote: "I just found out that the snake Harry released in book 1 turned out to be Nagini. Did anybody else know this!?"i did not know that!"
And it's not true.
i did not know that because it was not true!
Neesh_satsumaXD wrote: "i did not know that because it was not true!"Precisely. XD
Anna wrote: "rayful wrote: "Nasra wrote: "I just found out that the snake Harry released in book 1 turned out to be Nagini. Did anybody else know this!?"Uh, this isn't true, and Rowling never actually said th..."
they dont have snake actors...its just special effects.if you bought the last hp movie and looked on the deleted scenes or something like that. (maybe it was the making of the movie idk) but i remember seeing the snake not looking real but looking like she was made with the computer.of course you cant tell in the movie because of the editing and special effects which makes it look real.
Marisa wrote: "Yes everyone knows this already."Not me! lol...
Lucy wrote: "the snake in the first book was bred in captivity it cant be nagini"No, or else how would Voldemort turn her into a horcrux? And yeah, like Uditi said, boas are not poisonous and the snake Harry released was a boa.
i'm not saying i think its true, but i'm not saying it couldn't be either,maybe she had a spell cast on her by a death eater to make her look like a different breed of snake or different sex of snake even? maybe she was a young snake when she got put in the zoo after voldemort died the first time when Harry was little to keep her safe? Maybe she didn't kill Harry because she knew they needed him alive to free her master?
Bee wrote: "i'm not saying i think its true, but i'm not saying it couldn't be either,maybe she had a spell cast on her by a death eater to make her look like a different breed of snake or different sex of s..."
Except, the problem with that is it's pure speculation and not cannon. And also...that would be silly. It's not as though she needs to disguise herself from anyone and Voldemort doesn't leave his horcruxes lying around... so actually it would be foolish.
ok so my only question is....why are we still talking about this? i mean, we all agree that nagini wasn't the snake in the first movie, right?
I believe it is mentioned in the books where Voldemort finds Nagini. If I'm not mistaken he is in a forest, not in England, very very weak and he 'jumps' from animal to animal consuming them. Living in their bodies. He does this to a snake and ends up keeping her and that is Nagini.
Cláudia wrote: "I believe it is mentioned in the books where Voldemort finds Nagini. If I'm not mistaken he is in a forest, not in England, very very weak and he 'jumps' from animal to animal consuming them. Livin..."
forgot about that *hangs head down in shame*
forgot about that *hangs head down in shame*
I believe JKR actually specified in an interview that the snake WASN'T Nagini.
Sela wrote: "ok so my only question is....why are we still talking about this? i mean, we all agree that nagini wasn't the snake in the first movie, right?"Because so many people new to the thread are just reading the first statements and not the most recent ones.
Brandon wrote: "It does not make sense at all. This is false information."
True. None of this makes sense.
Trix wrote: "I believe JKR actually specified in an interview that the snake WASN'T Nagini."
I thought not.
True. None of this makes sense.
Trix wrote: "I believe JKR actually specified in an interview that the snake WASN'T Nagini."
I thought not.
huh, never thought about that. I even forgot he'd released a snake. I'd believe it.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Also, the snake was raised in the zoo (previously mentioned by others).
Finally... Why would Rowling do that? Doesn't make sense to me, that snake was just to show Harry's magic abilities & that he had a connection to Voldemort long before he even knew it--foreshadowing.