Smile
discussion
smile vs. diary of wimpy kid
message 101:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
May 17, 2013 06:30PM
BTW smile has two books, the second one is called Drama. And also, smile would SO win.
reply
|
flag
Smile and Drama are unrelated but are both really great. :)
Yes I just read drama it was great!
I met the author of this book. I rather like Smile then diary of the wimpy kid.
Oooh that's really cool! Where did you meet her?
Its was a excursion. In our school we have a Book Club. So we went to this excursion at the Melbourne Central. I actually got a signature of her on the smile book.
Oh wow that's great!!! Wish I could've been there, haha :) I got Fairest signed by Gail Carson Levine at a bookstore near my house a long time ago. It was pretty amazing.
Meg wrote: "Oh wow that's great!!! Wish I could've been there, haha :) I got Fairest signed by Gail Carson Levine at a bookstore near my house a long time ago. It was pretty amazing."Awesome.
Everyone should read her drama book.
Smile. I like Diary of a Wimpy Kid, but Smile was reeeally good. I got to chat online with the author!
Smile was written more...realistic, I guess. In my opinion, even COMPARING these two is a crime on Smile.
Smile because its in color and just a better story. LOVE BOTH BOOKS....BUT SMILE WINS!!!!
Olivia ur correct
Smile by Raina T. is such a good book. I even bought one I just enjoy reading it over and over again.D.W.K was kind of boring if you ask me. SMILE FTW!!!!
I liked smile better because it has more girl drama that I can relate to and diary of a wimpy kid I am a girl so I have no idea what it might be like so I don't now if the author was just making it up.
I liked smile better, mostly because I could relate to it better. although maybe if I was male, I would relate to DWK better... I dunno.Plus its getting to be one of those series that just keeps dragging on and on. I wish the author would just let it end... some books are like that.
SMILE, OF COURSE! I have never been a fan of Diary of a Wimpy Kid. It was so immature and. . . wimpy. I just loved Smile! ;D
SMILE FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I personally like smile more because to me, it has ore of a story
Smile was so good! So much better than DOAWK. It was so much more mature than Wimpy Kid.
it was WAY better than DOAWK becuse it was more mature and kinda of shows how an actual middle school girl would act but DOAWK is just like a book for laghs while smile is more funny and still in reality!
Smile Loved it:)
Smile is WAY better than Diary of a Wimpy Kid
Both Smile and Diary of a wimpy kid have negatives and positives. I think that Smile is more appropriate for the 6th grade because, smile has many pages. You could read it for one night or a day to get away from your book, or to take a break from it. Diary of the wimpy kid has lots of words and a good amount of pictures, I think it would be a good book for a 5th grader not a 6th grader. Now for the negatives, Smile has not that many words and many pictures,( I personally like picture books more thank chapter books.) and you will get done with it fast. When ever I read the book I feel like i'm reading fast but i'm not. Diary of a wimpy kid has multiple books in a series so when you read almost all of the books maybe you will get sick and tired of the books, and not really finish them. I personally think that both of the books are good, but since I have to chose witch one is better I have to say I pick SMILE.
I thought smile personally was better. Smile was funny, sweet and told a real life problem. I use to love diary of a wimpy kid, but I feel like he's made way too many books about it and none of them really connected or anything.
I've also read Drama
Smile!!!! Diary of a wimpy kid is boring
Meg wrote: "SMILE!!!! I hated Diary of a Wimpy Kid. It was just so immature and boyish."I know, right!!!!!!!!!!
SMILE is the best nothin is better
It's one of my favorite graphic novels ever!!!!!
SMILE is much better! I hate Diary of Wimpy Kid.
Well... U know... That's my personal opinion. I'm not trying to make DWK's fans upset.
I love Smile sooo much it is isn't even funny.
Basically, everybody totally likes smile way more but I get what your saying.
Isn't it cool how a lot of people like Raina Telgemeier! I knew a lot of people liked her but not this much! It's crazy!!!!
I know! I still doesn't know about her a lot. Stil, she is my younger sister's favorite author.
Yeah! Smile is awesome!
Isn't it! I just love it so much!!!!
they both are very good but in my opinion i think diary of a wimpy kid im not saying smile isnt good but diary of a wimpy kid is BETTER
ITS MADE OF SMALL COMICS!!!!!!!!!!!!
Smile is so popular
I love Smile!!!!!!!!!!
