Are You A Hunger Games Fanatic? discussion
Hunger Games Fun!
>
Hunger Games and Twilight... fude!?
message 1:
by
Faith Noelle
(new)
Mar 18, 2012 09:04AM
What do you all think? Is there a fude bettween the stars of The Hunger Games and Twilight movies? Are they the same? Is one better than the other? Share your voice here! :)
reply
|
flag
I sincerely believe that the Hunger Games has a much better story line that Twilight. Twilight is more for people that have a passion for romance.
Okay, yes that is tue, but some people are saying they are based off eachother, oppion?
I don't think they are. One, Twilight is about vampires and werewolves, whereas the Hunger Games is a dystopian style writing featuring people fighting to the death. Two, many books have love triangles, so people cannot say that one author copied a love triangle from the Hunger Games or Twilight.
Very true. It's kind of earatating(sp) cause, yeah they both have love triangles, but they both are kinda of different. What do you think about the different plots? Or Character's?
irritating. The characters in HG are more well developed and distinct. twilight is more a romance and isn't as actiony. HG is a love triangle but that isn't the main thing. The main thing is the rebellion and the hunger games. in twilight its all romance with a hint of actual adventure etc. Twilight is NOTHING LIKE THE HUNGER GAMES. at all.
(Really, Come on! Again, Irritating. The characters in HG are more well developed and distinct. Twilight is more a romance and isn't as actiony. HG is a love triangle but that isn't the main thing. The main thing is the rebellion and the hunger games. In Twilight it's all romance with a hint of actual adventure etc. Twilight is NOTHING LIKE THE HUNGER GAMES. At all.(Okay, get it?) Now an anwser, well I kind of agree, they are differnt but to alot of people they are the same, but thoese people are only loooking at the small detail's, like the love triangle, and in some way the same polt. Oppion's?
I agree. Twilight and The Hunger Games are nothing alike. People compare their love triangles, but it seems that these days, every YA book has a love triangle in it. Does that mean that every YA book is the same? No.People like to compare Twilight and The Hunger Games because they are both popular YA novels. I just listened to an interview with Jennifer Lawrence and she said that some people were purposely starting a war between the two books and they were making up things about what she said.
Yeah,I read that interviwe too. I mean, yes that's true,but wouldn't you say its annoying? To alwaus have the book be comepared to eachother when there nothing alike??
Hunger Games and Twilight should never be compared. Pfft- there aren't many similarities between a book about vampires and werewolves vs. a book in dystopian style.
It is very annoying to have them compared. Twilight is pretty bad, in my opinion, while The Hunger Games is AMAZING.
:) Thank you, thank you.I think that people are degrading THG by saying its like Twilight.
Yes, but I jusst read a report, and people have started saying how the characters are the same, agree? Disagree?
Disagree! Twilight:
Main character: Bella. Whiny, annoying cant support herself without a man.
Love triangle option 1: Edward: odd sparkly vampire who is somehow perfect in every way
Love triangle option 2: Jacob: odd smelly werewolf who is somehow super hot too.
THG:
Main character: Katniss: awesome great with a bow and arrow, totally kick-butt
Love triangle option 1: Peeta: bakers boy who is very sweet but always npseems to need Katniss's saving
Love triangle option 2: Gale: awesome best friend who mostly wants to stop evil Capitol.
Does anyone see any similarities at all?
NO! I don't. People are making WAY to big a deal by comparing THG and Twilight. And this is just an opinion, but truthfully, I think THG is alot better than Twilight. I'm reading Matched right now, and it's also a love triangle. Alot of stories have love triangles. Get over it!!!!
((Jasmine, did you post the link yet?))
Okay but think of it this way, you got what one million people on Twitter or Facebook saying that ohhhh these book's are so silimar, and you have the other cast memebers from both THG and Twilight reading this, what do you think they think?
Charlie I luv Gale Hawthorne wrote: "Disagree! Twilight:
Main character: Bella. Whiny, annoying cant support herself without a man.
Love triangle option 1: Edward: odd sparkly vampire who is somehow perfect in every way
Love triangl..."
[cries tears of joy] you know exactly what you're talking about. Edward reminds me of Ke$Ha XD [throws glitter around] make it rain make it rain throw soe glitter make it rain..
ஐ•●๋•Aero•●๋• ஐ wrote: "Charlie I luv Gale Hawthorne wrote: "Disagree! Twilight:
Main character: Bella. Whiny, annoying cant support herself without a man.
Love triangle option 1: Edward: odd sparkly vampire who is someh..."
Lol very true very true.
I have NO CLUE why everyone thinks Twilight and THG are similar.
Charlie I luv Gale Hawthorne wrote: "Disagree! Twilight:
Main character: Bella. Whiny, annoying cant support herself without a man.
Love triangle option 1: Edward: odd sparkly vampire who is somehow perfect in every way
Love triangl..."
Indeed.
Jasmine wrote: "NO! I don't. People are making WAY to big a deal by comparing THG and Twilight. And this is just an opinion, but truthfully, I think THG is alot better than Twilight. I'm reading Matched right now,..."
OMG I love Matched!!!!
OMG I love Matched!!!!
Guy's come on, actually talk about the topic please. Thank you.
Sorry. HUNGER GAMes is awesome! Bella is not as awesome as Katniss.
Okay, to compare them, I imagined them all in their own, personal Hunger Games. Here's how it turned out in my mind:Katniss: Chilled in a tree eating delicious lamb stew and shot people with arrows
Bella: Ran into a Tracker Jacker nest, was hungry and thought she could get some honey from it, and died a very painful and long death
Peeta: Camouflaged himself as a tree until somebody walked past, and choked them to death
Edward: He all ready died. If not by Peeta, then Katniss shot him, or Gale made a human snare
Gale: Walked around making snares until someone got stuck in one
Jacob: The tribute mutts decided that he was one of them and decided to "play fight" with him, resulting in his death due to a torn out throat
In the end, THG totally comes out on the top.
HUNGER GAMES ALL THE WAY, BABY!!!!!!!!! ;p
Joe (The orange, pie, and Mori lover) wrote: "Okay, to compare them, I imagined them all in their own, personal Hunger Games. Here's how it turned out in my mind:Katniss: Chilled in a tree eating delicious lamb stew and shot people with arro..."
Hahaha, very accurate, I think that would definitely be what would happen.
I dont read twilight or watch them. I mean seriesly its vampires! Its so the hunger games!katness over rules bela, then peeta & gale beat edward & jacob
I absoloutly love the Hunger Games! Katniss totally is better than Bella!
Bella like NEEDS DESPERATELY a man to support her. Katniss is total kick-butt!
Joe (The orange, pie, and Mori lover) wrote: "Okay, to compare them, I imagined them all in their own, personal Hunger Games. Here's how it turned out in my mind:
Katniss: Chilled in a tree eating delicious lamb stew and shot people with arro..."
haha. Edward would survive though.
Katniss: Chilled in a tree eating delicious lamb stew and shot people with arro..."
haha. Edward would survive though.
I thibnk the fude is stupid and people should get over it and realize that a love triangle is common in books.
iIcan't find any comparison between the two, I'm being bias, but I see moral in THG whereas Twilight doesn't seem to show me any. Don't get me wrong I'm a fan of Romance novels but Twilight just give me goosebumps. Anyway, the truce is probably between the movies since Lionsgate said their aim was to make more ticket sales than Twilight did.
I think Twilight is incredibly stupid. It doesn't even have a good moral! It has a bad one! It's nothing like the HG! That's like saying, what's that really dumb show for kids on Disney...oh yeah! Hannah Montana! That's like saying that HG is like HM because there is a love triangle in HM! That's a really pathetic excuse to compare books. HG rules!
This is off topic, but: What's the love triabgle in HM?
oh I used to watch it when I was younger and there is this one guy ( I think his name was jake?) and another (Jessie?) guy. Miley just couldn't decide who she liked better. It was REALLY stupid :)
((Oh yeah! I remember that! Wow I haven't seen that show since I was like 8.))
I like both books and both movies...but if I had to pick a favorite. It would definintely be HUNGER GAMES!!!
Twilight is a series of supernatural raging teenager hormones. In the Twilight series, they survive because of their stupidity. In the Hunger Games, they have to survive because of their rebellion. See the difference? Hunger games has a WAY better story line!
((Alright people. please stay on topic. About hafe the stuf y'all are talking about belongs in CHAT. Or if you want to talk about Catching Fire, go to the Catching Fire topic. Its not that hard people. Stop Spaming. And Also Nummy, you need to take the THG quiz or you will be kicked out. That goes for everyone who hasn't taken it yet...))
Numey wrote: "Hey, its been rumored that Robert Pattison is going to be Finnick in Catching Fire Movie!"
NOOOOO!!!!!!!!!
NOOOOO!!!!!!!!!
((Guys. I said stop! Would you like me to put both of y'all on porbation?))
((Alright, alll the spam is gone. Time to start fresh in this topic. DONT SPAM. Thanks.Your mods))
In my opinion I think people go out of their way to find things to nit pick at. They did it between Harry Potter and Twilight and neither had anything to do with each other besides the fact that they are both fantastical and considered young adult. As like the HG, it falls into that genre too.But, I like all three and I dont really see why people get so freak about it. Twilight was an easy read. Quick fast and non-intellectual. Harry Potter was the series I grew up with. And the hunger Games is the new hot series.
I really loved the HG books. They are my personal favorites :)
Thank you, Rachel, for summing up everything I was trying to say.
Snickerdoodle wrote: "Thank you, Rachel, for summing up everything I was trying to say.":)
Glad we agree :)
