Dumbledore's Army discussion

97 views
Would You Rather? > Would you rather... the hunger games or harry potter?

Comments Showing 51-100 of 199 (199 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by rayken (new)

rayken (raykenful) | 8 comments Dystopian or Magical? obviously Harry Potter


message 52: by Beatrice (new)

Beatrice (beatricemasalunga) Harry Potter will be part of our lives forever, though there's Hunger Games.


message 53: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments i love hunger games so don't think this is one sided, but i still rank Harry Potter my number 1. Hunger games is a cloe 2nd but my first love will always be harry potter


message 54: by Grouphug (new)

Grouphug | 4 comments but hunger games is just terrible


message 55: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Kayley wrote: "i love hunger games so don't think this is one sided, but i still rank Harry Potter my number 1. Hunger games is a cloe 2nd but my first love will always be harry potter"

EXACTLY. i love Hunger Games but it will NEVER EVER match up to Harry Potter


message 56: by Sunny (new)

Sunny (ILuvTheHungerGames) | 1 comments While I love both The Hunger Games and Harry potter I grew up with Harry potter and it's been a big part of my life and for that reason i'll always love it first but the hunger games is a very very close second.


message 57: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
YAY!


message 58: by [deleted user] (new)

yeah Harry Potter has been part of my life since the first movie came out. and that was definitely before kindergarten for me. i think i was 2 or 3. so i've grown up with it and its nearly impossible for anything to be better than it in my mind.


message 59: by [Coco] (new)

[Coco] (mattyhealy) Jamesdean wrote: "but hunger games is just terrible"

What do you mean by terrible? Badly written or bad plotline?

Definitely The Hunger Games. <3 Best book/trilogy ever!!! I've read and reread it since I was in sixth grade. =)


message 60: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
meow :(


message 61: by Cassidy (new)

Cassidy | 2 comments harry potter i will always love harry


message 62: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments Coco wrote: "Jamesdean wrote: "but hunger games is just terrible"

What do you mean by terrible? Badly written or bad plotline?

Definitely The Hunger Games. <3 Best book/trilogy ever!!! I've read and reread it..."


I have reread it too but i must ask, team PEETA or gale


message 63: by Zahra (new)

Zahra Khan | 10 comments for me its that harry potter and hunger games are really different and i cant choose because i love both of them so much
also hunger games is newer than hunger games
so I'm interested in hunger games more right now
and as for team peeta or gale
TEAM PEETA ALL THE WAY


message 64: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments Zahra wrote: "for me its that harry potter and hunger games are really different and i cant choose because i love both of them so much
also hunger games is newer than hunger games
so I'm interested in hunger g..."


OH YEAH!!!!!!!!!! GO TEAM PEETA!!!!!!!!!!!


message 65: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Kayley wrote: "Coco wrote: "Jamesdean wrote: "but hunger games is just terrible"

What do you mean by terrible? Badly written or bad plotline?

Definitely The Hunger Games.

I have reread it too but i must..."


TEAM PEETA. WHy would anyone choose Gale when he left Katniss for District 2?


message 66: by [Coco] (last edited Apr 02, 2012 02:30PM) (new)

[Coco] (mattyhealy) Kayley wrote: "I have reread it too but i must ask, Team PEETA or gale"

I LOVE PEETA!!!


message 67: by Zahra (new)

Zahra Khan | 10 comments Arti wrote: "Kayley wrote: "Coco wrote: "Jamesdean wrote: "but hunger games is just terrible"

What do you mean by terrible? Badly written or bad plotline?

Definitely The Hunger Games.

I have reread it too b..."


i agree about the Gale thing, he may not have completely caused Prim;s death, but leaving Katniss, unforgivable


message 68: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
IKR. I MEAN. Sure, even though we all knew Peeta and Katniss were going to end up together, she COULD have been Gale. MAYBE.


message 69: by Zahra (new)

Zahra Khan | 10 comments yep i agree, now she had even a better reason to hate him


message 70: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments peeta is the perfect guy


message 71: by [deleted user] (new)

TEAM GALE! cause i've only read the first book. most people are team Gale for the first book, right? then...stuff happens...


message 72: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments Nikos~The Elves of Mirkwood wrote: "TEAM GALE! cause i've only read the first book. most people are team Gale for the first book, right? then...stuff happens..."

Yeah then he turns into a crybaby anda jerk


message 73: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Nikos~The Elves of Mirkwood wrote: "TEAM GALE! cause i've only read the first book. most people are team Gale for the first book, right? then...stuff happens..."

+GASP+ finsh the serires and you'll change your mind


message 74: by Kayley (new)

Kayley (sportsgirl5) | 89 comments I concur :)


message 75: by [deleted user] (new)

Harry potter defiantly.


message 76: by Cassidy (new)

Cassidy | 2 comments Kayley wrote: "peeta is the perfect guy"

he is hot


message 77: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Jessica wrote: "Harry potter defiantly."

Oh yeah, go Harry


message 78: by [deleted user] (new)

I SHALL SOMEDAY! i just have this growing pile of books...its kinda frightening. it wont stop growing. and its not exactly getting smaller quickly.


message 79: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
haha, i get all my books from goodreads. and i love almost all of them


message 80: by Beatrice (new)

Beatrice (beatricemasalunga) Someone asked me,
would you rather join Hunger Games or Triwizard tournament?

what's your answer and why? :)


message 81: by Zahra (new)

Zahra Khan | 10 comments ugh thats sounds depressing
but obviously i would choose triwizard tournament becuae you dont have to kill or be the last one alive to win


message 82: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Triwizard! because you dont have to join and you can stay alive


message 83: by Shanmukh (new)

Shanmukh K. (Raptor01) | 7 comments Hunger Games all the way


message 84: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
BOO


message 85: by [deleted user] (new)

Bob!!
Ha Ha HA
Not Funny!!!


message 86: by Shanmukh (new)

Shanmukh K. (Raptor01) | 7 comments Hey, if you play, you must fight to the very end. HUNGER GAMES


message 87: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
yeah, but u can come out alive in the Triwizard Tournament. In HG, U GOTTA DIE or kill everyone else


message 88: by Shanmukh (last edited Apr 07, 2012 03:58PM) (new)

Shanmukh K. (Raptor01) | 7 comments Exactly why I would to be in the Hunger Games if I had a choice between both. I will win ( maybe).


message 89: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
in Triwizard it doesnt even matter! u can lose and survive


message 90: by [Coco] (new)

[Coco] (mattyhealy) I like THG books better, but I'd rather live. Triwizard.


message 91: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
YEAH well kinda


message 92: by Shanmukh (new)

Shanmukh K. (Raptor01) | 7 comments I would rather die than have a person triumph over me in such a huge competition.


message 93: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
i wouldnt


message 94: by Jacelover (new)

Jacelover (TheWizard) | 455 comments Would you rather marry Peeta or Harry?


message 95: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Oh god THAT'S a hard one....


message 96: by [deleted user] (new)

i think i'd rather be in the Hunger Games. i'd like to see how i do. With the training before it, i might not do too bad. i would wanna be in the top 10 though. so later than the 14th to die. but if i last that long, i wouldnt mind.


message 97: by Shanmukh (new)

Shanmukh K. (Raptor01) | 7 comments yeah Nikos!


message 98: by Beatrice (new)

Beatrice (beatricemasalunga) If i were to choose, I'll choose Triwizard tournament.. if I die, atleast I couldn't feel pain in Avada Kedavra. instant kill. I will just turn pale..

but to be honest, you can't compare Hunger Games and Harry Potter.


message 99: by Arti, ready to bring back the action (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 4234 comments Mod
Nikos~The Silence are everywhere wrote: "i think i'd rather be in the Hunger Games. i'd like to see how i do. With the training before it, i might not do too bad. i would wanna be in the top 10 though. so later than the 14th to die. but i..."

BUT YOU WOULD DIE!!! Well i guess thats opinion. I personally want to be able to drive a car so :)


message 100: by Jacelover (new)

Jacelover (TheWizard) | 455 comments Instead of driving a car, I'd like to meet Josh Ramsay while wearing a pink ninja suit with a wizard hat, drinking coke zero and talking about horrible life decisions


back to top