Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4) Breaking Dawn discussion


125 views
Edward? Jacob? Or BOTH?

Comments Showing 51-69 of 69 (69 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by [deleted user] (new)

You all just don't get it do you. Edward is so amazing, and Jacob is just stupid.


message 52: by Mafatima (new) - added it

Mafatima bandola BOTH!!!!!!!!! imagine edward and jacob fighting in front of bella???? haha... i'm pretty sure she will be completely devastated!!!!!!!!!!!


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ So the scores are in, and here's how many people chose each character:
Both: 8
Jacob: 11
Edward: 14
Seth: 5
Emmett: 5
Jasper: 4
Quil: 1
Rosalie: 2
Carlisle: 3
Alice: 2
Esme: 1
Paul: 1
James: 1
Bree: 1

What happened to Team Edward and Team Jacob?


PostCardashian Kim Jacob is way cooller. edwards a weirdo imagine if you met him in real life.
but yeah, emmett is the hottest


PostCardashian Kim Black Queen wrote: "Jacob is hotter then edward, but sexiest guys in twilight movies are emmett and paul!:)"

COMPELTELY


message 56: by Rula (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rula Drew wrote: "Rula wrote: "why would you say that? do you have a vivid imagination or am i the only who has that?"

My imagination is plenty vivid. Stephenie Meyer's writing is not."


stephanie meyer is a legend in her own right. i don't know why i said, but i am sorry. it's just what i think.


message 57: by [deleted user] (new)

EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Alisha Taylor To answer this I'd Say Jacob.
When it comes to vampires Emmett is my choice, i just didn't like edward very much in both the books or movies


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ So the scores have updated, and here's how many people chose each character:
Both: 8
Jacob: 14..........+1
Edward: 15.........+1
Seth: 5
Emmett: 5
Jasper: 4
Quil: 1
Rosalie: 2
Carlisle: 3
Alice: 2
Esme: 1
Paul: 1
James: 1
Bree: 1

What happened to Team Edward and Team Jacob?


message 60: by [deleted user] (new)

I think everyone should switch to Team Edward.


message 62: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah-YES!!!!!!!!


Cheryl Wallace The answer to this question depends on the type of book one likes to read and how they relate to the characters. If a person really gets into those steamy sex novels then a book like twilight, in most cases, is probably not going to appeal to them. I am a romantic looking to make my boring uneventful like melt away. I like to put myself in place of the characters. I like to feel the story. Non-emotional type people don't like sticky emotional drama. Stephanie Meyer did an excellent jot with all the books, though there were a few spots that left me wanting, like her depression in the second book. Not to say that a person wouldn't go through something like that, but that it lasted a bit too long. I didn't appreciate Jacobs narration in the fourth book either. As to my preference of Edward or Jacob...I have always had an obsession with vamps, I don't know why so if it came down to it, and I really didn't care about the whole afterlife thing, I would so choose Eddie, but Jacob is the one I would choose hands down in the mortal sense. He's real and tangible where as Edward seems unreachable. The third movie was awesome, the rest were nuggets.


Cheryl Wallace Ally *Nerdy, Awkward, Amazing* wrote: "Black Queen wrote: "Jacob is hotter then edward, but sexiest guys in twilight movies are emmett and paul!:)"

So true!!!! But I prefer Seth more than Paul! :)"


But who did you think was the "hottest" before you saw the movies?


message 66: by [deleted user] (new)

Before I was the Movies Robert was pretty freaking sexy.


Martina Edward. He's better for Bella!


Kaida-lynn its between Jacob and Embry for me


message 69: by [deleted user] (new)

"I am a neutral country. I am Switzerland." ~Bella
"I would have been healthier for you. I would have been the air, the sun." ~Jacob
I agree with both of them.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top