Breaking Dawn
discussion
Edward? Jacob? Or BOTH?
message 1:
by
Cat
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 13, 2012 04:09PM
I am Team Switerland. More formally known as Jakward... I loved Edward in Eclipse and Twilight, but in Breaking Dawn, I just COULDN'T decide!
reply
|
flag
BOTH!!! Actually, I dont really care.
Neither. They both suck. What a load of rotten and poorly-written characters fill these books.
Can i say neither?????? I say GO TEAM SETH!!!!!!!!!!!!! <33333333 LOL
Depends what I'm suppose to be choosing one for?
Team Switzerland :)x There characters are ment to be different, its a personal choice I guess :)But personally,
I am TEAM SWITZERLAND :D :D :D xxx
i like edward b/c hes nice and would die for her but i hate him b/c he is part of jakes pain.... i feal bad for jake. TEAM SWITZERLAND!
Forget them both... I want Emmett!!!!
Brittany wrote: "Forget them both... I want Emmett!!!!"yeah or Jasper :)
i love seth from the wolf pack and Quil because they're gorgeousfrom the vampire clan - Rosalie, Edward and Carlisle
team neither. Edward's dull and I can't think of Jacob without thinking of Taylor Lautner's nose.
Andromeda Nicole wrote: "I am Team Switerland. More formally known as Jakward... I loved Edward in Eclipse and Twilight, but in Breaking Dawn, I just COULDN'T decide!"AMEN AMEN!!! SO VERY TRUE!!!!!!!!!!!!
Drew wrote: "Neither. They both suck. What a load of rotten and poorly-written characters fill these books."why would you say that? do you have a vivid imagination or am i the only who has that?
Meg wrote: "team neither. Edward's dull and I can't think of Jacob without thinking of Taylor Lautner's nose."what's wrong with that? jacob was played by Taylor Lautner. it's the same person.
Rula wrote: "why would you say that? do you have a vivid imagination or am i the only who has that?"My imagination is plenty vivid. Stephenie Meyer's writing is not.
EDWARDDD <3 <3 :) :) Then Seth, then Emmett, then Jacob. :P
Team Jacob! But not Taylor Lautner.... sorry, I choose my team from the books. The pack in Breaking Dawn is so awesome
Jacob, not Taylor Lautner.
Id have both if it was legal
I personally don't want either, but while I was a fan of the first movie, I preferred Edward. Now I see more sense as to liking Jacob more because I've realized how weird Edward really is. Though he is romantic. Meh, nether, but if I had to choose between the two (as in was being FORCED to choose between them), I guess I'd go with Jacob. *shrug*
Pre-Werewolf Jacob. Not that I mind him being a Werewolf, but his entire attitude changed (not to mention the creepy child-thing in Breaking Dawn). As for Edward, I take serious issue with him for multiple reasons.
I love Jasper, Alice, Carlisle, Esme, and Seth. Seth is so cute! And did you see his ABS? As for Edward and Jacob, I am staying out of it I have changed my opinion so often. Most of the time I find faults with both of them. Jacob should not have threatened Bella saying he would kill himself if she didn't kiss him and Edward should not have left Bella. I really find Edward's depressing attitude to be really annoying. I am kind of mad at both of them for putting Bella through so much.
Edward; I never liked Jacob for Bella.
EDWARD IS THE ONE HE IS AS HOT AS FIRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ILOVEHIM! WHO DOESNT THINK THAT WHEN JACOB HAD LONG HAIR THAT IT WAS TOATALLY A WIG!ANYWAY HE DIDNT TAKE OFF HIS SHIRT WITH LONG HAIR SO ITS BETTER WITH SHORT BUT I WILL ALWAYS BE TEAM EDWARD!!!!!! EDWARD FOREVA!
Why do we have to pick teams based on who was good for Bella or not? I chose mine because the pack is epic. You can choose for different reasons.
Jacob, BTW someone should count how many people chose which team, i would be interested to know!
Jessie wrote: "Andromeda Nicole wrote: "I am Team Switerland. More formally known as Jakward... I loved Edward in Eclipse and Twilight, but in Breaking Dawn, I just COULDN'T decide!"AMEN AMEN!!! SO VERY TRUE!!..."
<3!!!!!!!!
Gabrielle wrote: "EDWARD IS THE ONE HE IS AS HOT AS FIRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ILOVEHIM! WHO DOESNT THINK THAT WHEN JACOB HAD LONG HAIR THAT IT WAS TOATALLY A WIG!ANYWAY HE DIDNT TAKE OFF HIS SHIRT WITH L..."I feel he same way now. I WAS Team Switzerand before...but now...EDWARD YES!!!!And Carlisle, Jasper, Bree, Alice, Rose (Rosalie) and everyone except JACOB! Even James...
Edward all the way. Someone needs to explain to me why you like Jacob becUse I can't think of a single reason why.
Jacob! I love him...I don't understand why it's always jacob and edward. Why it can't be Team Emmett or Team Paul. Now that's what I'm talking about, there both juicy and hot.
Black Queen wrote: "Jacob! I love him...I don't understand why it's always jacob and edward. Why it can't be Team Emmett or Team Paul. Now that's what I'm talking about, there both juicy and hot."Emmett is married and Paul imprinted! LOL But you're right...Emmett is juicy and hot!
I like the book version of Jacob better.... I thought it would have been awesome if he and bella (because in the end both the werewolves and the vampires are against the Voluturi) would use bows and arrows (archery) together to fight off the volturi. It would have worked if vampires didn't live forever >:(
Really people! What do you see Jacob?
Jacob is hotter then edward, but sexiest guys in twilight movies are emmett and paul!:)
Black Queen wrote: "Jacob is hotter then edward, but sexiest guys in twilight movies are emmett and paul!:)"So true!!!! But I prefer Seth more than Paul! :)
Jacob maybe hotter than Edward, but Edward is just so much better.
I loved the wolf forms in the movies.
team JACOB for me....he is so sweet....
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
