The Mortal Instruments Series LOVERS! :P discussion

City of Bones (The Mortal Instruments, #1)
This topic is about City of Bones
85 views
Logan Lerman as Simon?

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

HSLFP | 45 comments He would be perfect :)
And it's really great that he already is playing opposite Lily Collins in the Writer. So I really hope she can convince him to at least audition for the part ^.^


message 2: by Laerke (new)

Laerke (laerken_s) | 9 comments Oh, he would be great!


Elisabeth | 1 comments He would be the perfect Simon!


Hannah (hannah109) I agree.


Chels (sheathings) | 2 comments Aw he would be a PERFECT Simon. :)


juuree I don't think I'd mind too much if he was Simon :)
Innocent and sweet :)


Nika | 23 comments I think he could be Simon :) I love his eyes! (Logan's')


T.J. | 77 comments yeah . . . I could see him as a good Simon. Although if the movie is a success and they decide to make a second one (City of Ashes) then he'll need to buff up.


HSLFP | 45 comments More on Logan Lerman as Simon. It doesn't sound promising :(

Q: Hello, Cassie! With all the thing going on about Alec and stuff, I was wondering if anyone had auditioned for Simon and, maybe, even just a hint, may you please tell me who that is. I am very much in love with this character and I want you to know that I would be eternally grateful to you if Logan Lerman would be casted for this lovable role. I hope that you would be able to reply to this. Please and Thank You! P.S I LOVE YOU!!! :)

A: Many, many MANY people have auditioned for Simon.
I cannot tell you, like I said earlier who has auditioned for any of the roles due to union laws. Because Logan is so enormously busy, and already leads a franchise, I can say that even though we all love him (Robert, my producer, worked with him before on Three Musketeers) it would be very very very difficult to make that work. See: Fancasting, Dangers of. I’m not saying never, because I don’t have the authority or even the knowledge to say never; I’m saying if I were in a betting pool it’s not where I’d put my money. You never know, though.

I have watched many a fantasy movie be made over the years. Only once have I ever seen the fan choice for a part cast. (Alan Rickman, Snape.) It’s never made any discernable difference to a movie’s success or failure. The movie has to be a good movie and the actors chosen have to do a good job — that’s the actual important thing, in the end. That’s what we should all have our fingers crossed for. :)

http://cassandraclare.tumblr.com/post...


Flora  (shipitlikefedex) Logan is... kind of amused looking. And Simon aint amused looking. So, not a good choice. But... that's just my opinion...


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments He would be PERFECT!! I hope lerman does good in The Perks of Being a Wallflower.. (I know...random...but his character is nerdy too)


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Mary wrote: "amused looking? What do you mean he's funny looking because I have no clue what amused looking means unless he's alway happy or something"

Hahaha I read that comment like 5 times wondering what amused looking meant...


Flora  (shipitlikefedex) Means. He... Ugh. Watch The Three Musketeers. You'll understand. -,-


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Ha I'll watch the trailer...


Josey | 4 comments Please be Logan, please be Logan, lol. I really think they kill'd Jace with jMAIE cAMPBELL bOWER, SO ITS LIKE please DON'T RUIN sIMON, TOO!!! MAKE IT LOGAN!!!!!


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

i thought simon was black?


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Dhiya wrote: "i thought simon was black?"

What??


Belle2908 | 29 comments Dhiya wrote: "i thought simon was black?"

OMG, WHAT?!?! O.O *dies*




message 19: by T.J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

T.J. | 77 comments No he's not. Is he? No.


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Shadowhunter Girl wrote: "No he's not. Is he? No."

That would be...weird. Not bad...just super weird. All this time I was imagining some skinny white guy. Black is...super weird.


message 21: by T.J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

T.J. | 77 comments Bianca wrote: "Shadowhunter Girl wrote: "No he's not. Is he? No."

That would be...weird. Not bad...just super weird. All this time I was imagining some skinny white guy. Black is...super weird."


I was just imagining him the same way and after almost a year of thinking of him with a lighter skin tone, now it's harder to imagine him darker. If he is then I am surprised that he did not get more girls. Either way, I still picture him as that nerdy white kid who eventually vamps it up, just cuz I'm used to him like that.


message 22: by Kate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kate | 18 comments logan would be absolute perfection for clary's nerdy best friend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Shadowhunter Girl wrote: "Bianca wrote: "Shadowhunter Girl wrote: "No he's not. Is he? No."

That would be...weird. Not bad...just super weird. All this time I was imagining some skinny white guy. Black is...super weird."

..."


Right?? But I think if he was he'd be cuter than Jace.. And then I would be heartbroken.


message 24: by Kate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kate | 18 comments exactly


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Did u see the Jace they casted??


message 26: by Kate (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kate | 18 comments yes!!!! a twilight character, are you kidding me?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments indivia wrote: "yes!!!! a twilight character, are you kidding me?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!"

I know!! I actually don't mind any of the characters... Except for Clary. Lily Collins?! Really?!


message 28: by T.J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

T.J. | 77 comments I like twilight! But Bella just needs to learn how to shut up.


Bianca (natgarbia) | 10 comments Bianca wrote: "indivia wrote: "yes!!!! a twilight character, are you kidding me?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!"

I know!! I actually don't mind any of the characters... Except for Clary. Lily Collins?! Really?!"


And Jace... But Isabelle is okay...


message 30: by T.J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

T.J. | 77 comments And Lily Collins is a pretty good actress. Yeah, Clary needs to be short but I think we might be surprised (in a positive way...) regarding her performance.


message 31: by T.J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

T.J. | 77 comments Bianca wrote: "Bianca wrote: "indivia wrote: "yes!!!! a twilight character, are you kidding me?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!"

I know!! I actually don't mind any of the characters... Except for Clary. Lily Collin..."


Isabelle annoyed me for awhile...I don't like girls who think they're all that and she kind of came across that way to me. But I like her now and I just want her to swallow her fear and pride and just admit how much she likes Simon. Then Simon can forget Clary.


Inês (nesborges) | 74 comments Josey wrote: "Please be Logan, please be Logan, lol. I really think they kill'd Jace with jMAIE cAMPBELL bOWER, SO ITS LIKE please DON'T RUIN sIMON, TOO!!! MAKE IT LOGAN!!!!!"

I agree :C Please they have Ruin jace in my opinion ALEX P IS but he IS Jace :C i hope they put Logan as simon


Inês (nesborges) | 74 comments Bianca wrote: "He would be PERFECT!! I hope lerman does good in The Perks of Being a Wallflower.. (I know...random...but his character is nerdy too)"
me too :)


Christina | 3 comments Simon has been cast as Robert Sheehan...
http://cassandraclare.tumblr.com/post...


Inês (nesborges) | 74 comments yes that true Simon has been casted as Robert Sheehan and i like him and i think they finally choose someone who fits in the role ^^ although i like more logan for simon :)


Christina | 6 comments I could see Logan Lerman as Simon but I think that Robert Sheehan is closer to the role....He could also be nice as Raphael...


Charlotte  (charlottep) I think Logan is too good looking. Not that Simon isn't good looking, but he's supposed to be kinda nerdy and quirky in the beginning, and i don't think Logan could pull that off.


HSLFP | 45 comments Charlotte*My new name is KT Tunstall* wrote: "I think Logan is too good looking. Not that Simon isn't good looking, but he's supposed to be kinda nerdy and quirky in the beginning, and i don't think Logan could pull that off."

I disagree. You should watch him in Perks of being a Wallflower! He can pull off every kind of roll ;)

But I am so happy with Robert Sheehan too! Love that guy!


back to top