ROBUST discussion

This topic is about
Edgar Rice Burroughs
Book Talk & Exchange of Views
>
John Carter by E. R. B.
date
newest »

I propose that literature which has survived a century has long since outgrown its pulp status.
One definition of literature is simply: Writing which has stood the test of time.
One definition of literature is simply: Writing which has stood the test of time.

One definition of literature is simply: Writing which has stood the test of time."
That's probably one of the most succinct and useful definitions I've seen of literature.

One definition of literature is simply: Writing which has stood the test of time."
SO TRUE!
I think this could get me reading Sci Fi again. Well, ERB and Andre Norton. I love her dreamy/dangerous worlds.

I already know there will be major diferences, but I don't know if it will ruin the movie.
It well might ruin the movie. I am going to see it on Saterday with a friend. I think with the amount of CGI it will not be remotely the same as the book. The movies never are. I have yet to read the Mars books by Burroughs. I read his Tarzan series but missed this.

Great stuff.
I downloaded Princess of Mars from Project Guttenberg today. They have 4 of the 11 books. I didn't see the others on Amazon.

One definition of literature is simply: Writing which has stood the test of tim..."
Andre Norton was one of my very first Sci-fi authors. A couple of years ago I bought the first one I read, The Stars Are Ours, on Amazon to see if it see read well. It did!
Andre Norton, Asimov, McCaffrey, Marion Zimmer Bradley, Poul Anderson....I started out reading them and never looked back.
Glad to know Norton reads well - was that on a Kindle?
Glad to know Norton reads well - was that on a Kindle?

Glad to know Norton reads well - was that on a Kindle?"
No, I ordered the paperback. I think it was used ... (surely out of print now). My other early favs where Starship Trooper by Heinlein and The Last Castle, by Jack Vance. I reread Vance a couple of months ago; excellent writing by any standard.

Got back about an hour ago from seeing it. I really enjoyed it. There was no swearing, no slang, no bad language usage. It was infinitely pleasurable watching a film where the English was good English. and without a struggle to understand what was being said.
Brian wrote: "Claudine wrote: "I just bought Starship Trooper."
Yay!!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Jhk5M..."
If you are a fan then you must have an opinion on Trevor Rabin...
Yay!!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Jhk5M..."
If you are a fan then you must have an opinion on Trevor Rabin...
And how many people had their first introduction to formal ethics in the laws governing the behaviour of robots as laid out by Isaac Asimov?

Claudine - YES! The movie was GREAT!
Pure entertainment, updated just a little bit. My husband said it was the best movie he'd seen in years - and he watches movies ALL the time.
Disney at it's finest...clean, family oriented and great fun to watch. They also did very well with the updated story line. The princess wasn't just a pawn, but a scientist and a warrior.
William Defoe made a good 9 foot tall Green Martian.
I was very pleased with the result. If they make sequeals, I'll see them, too.
Me too, will definately be reading the books. In this instance I am glad to be reading the books afterwards.
Andre, as Kat says, the 3 laws are already integrated in robotics. I consider Asimov to be one of the most influential authors of his time as far as reality and fantasy impacting on real life is concerned. Brilliant man.
Andre, as Kat says, the 3 laws are already integrated in robotics. I consider Asimov to be one of the most influential authors of his time as far as reality and fantasy impacting on real life is concerned. Brilliant man.


At one timee I had EVERYTHING she EVER wrote. My sister knew her and would get Xmas cards from her.

Her Abassinian (sp) cats ruled the house. Jain said there were books and papers all over the large Victorian house.
She never married, was a spinster librarian type.
I'm thoroughly enjoying these books. Much more than I ever liked 'Tarzan' - these stories are holding up very, very well for their age - over 100 years old.
Pulp Fiction rules!