Harry Potter discussion

777 views
Games > If you had to choose.....

Comments Showing 101-150 of 1,215 (1215 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by Crystal (last edited Aug 25, 2016 02:18PM) (new)

Crystal (jamessangel) | 18 comments definitely the hippogriff.

Would you rather have Snape or Peeves upset at you?


message 102: by Allie (last edited Aug 25, 2016 02:19PM) (new)

Allie Peeves he couldn't do any real damge but Snape on the other hand could make your life suck....
Would you rather...
be luna or ollivander at the malfloy's?


message 103: by [deleted user] (new)

Luna - she seems healthier than Ollivander :)
Would you rather...
Have to perform the Cruciatis Curse on a friend or have a friend perform it on you?


message 104: by Jenna (new)

Jenna (jentobox) | 16 comments I'd perform it... so that it would be good practice if I should ever encounter Death Eaters haha

Would you rather find out whats behind the curtain Sirius fell behind or find out what Dumbledore saw in the mirror of Erised


message 105: by Peng (new)

Peng | 317 comments i was really curious about that veil that i was actually egging harry to take a peek when i was reading it more than the image that dumbledore might've seen in the mirror.


would you have snape as a DADA teacher or have percy working as minister for magic?


message 106: by Zoab (new)

Zoab Kapoor Probably Percy as minister. Would you rather fall into a marsh of Venomous Tentacula without your wand(P.S. you can die) or have your ear cursed off like George did?


message 107: by Allie (new)

Allie my ear cursed off...people say stupid things anyway
would you rather be able to see thestrals or be Malfloy as deatheater?



message 108: by Peng (new)

Peng | 317 comments see thestrals. people die anyway and honestly, i;d like to be there in their final moment. it hasn't happened though....


would you use the time-turner to save dobby or hedwig?


message 109: by Kidz (new)

Kidz | 33 comments dobby, he probably has a longer life span anyway.

would you rather...
be bellatrix listrange or severus snape?



message 110: by Crystal (new)

Crystal (jamessangel) | 18 comments Snape. Looney fanatics like Bella are a dime a dozen, while the mind of Severus is a uniquely still pool inviting exploration.

Would you rather know the details of Riddle's missing years or Dumbledore's?


message 111: by Peng (new)

Peng | 317 comments dumbledore's! he is soooo mysterious and he has this air of nobody can question him....


who do you think are better mates? ron & harry or james & sirius?


message 112: by Jenna (new)

Jenna (jentobox) | 16 comments That's a toughy one. I'd say both are equal?? Well, I guess all I'd have to say is that I don't think Sirius would wuss out on James the way Ron tends to do with Harry. I wish J.K would write a prequel about James, Sirius, and Lupin!

Would you rather date Hagrid or Dobby?


message 113: by Allie (new)

Allie ...Tough one...I don't know probably no one but I have to choose, so Dobby....

Would you rather be Neville or luna?


message 114: by [deleted user] (new)

Wow... that's really hard.

Probably Neville, because he "improves" somewhat as time progresses, verses Luna...

would you rather...

Have to spill out your darkest secrets (veritaserum...) or find out a HORRIBLE secret about you?


message 115: by Kidz (new)

Kidz | 33 comments basilisk, as long as i don't look at it i have a chance.

would you rather...
come back as a ghost or go on (whatever that means)?


message 116: by Meghan (new)

Meghan | 686 comments Go on!

My speculations about this would be life after death. You, know, like in a better world.

would you rather tell umbridge she is a fat old told or tell voldemort he needs a bit of you-know-poo.


message 117: by [deleted user] (new)

Voldemort - he'd kill me regardless, so the repercussions would not be too different from the fate I would face anyway

would you rather die in azkaban or go mad from the cruciatis curse?


message 118: by Kenzie (new)

Kenzie Hmm... tough choices. I don't think that I would get sent to Azkaban, but dying seems better than ending up like Neville's parents.

Would you rather...

be killed in a battle or killed by a loved one on accident


message 119: by Lynn (new)

Lynn (dwell_ondreams) | 25 comments I'd rather be killed in battle. I'd hate to have a loved one feel guilt for killing me, that'd suck.

Would you rather:

Have Lucius Malfoy as your enemy or have Severus Snape as your friend? (I choose Snape, because he's an amazing character & I love him, but I know a lot of people hate him)


message 120: by ★Lalita ❤︎ (new)

★Lalita ❤︎ (lalita) I'd pick Snape too, not sure why though:)

Would you rather:

Be the HeadMaster of Hogwarts or HeadMaster of your own school?


message 121: by Maya (new)

Maya (numerounochewylover) | 270 comments The headmaster of Hogwarts; I could never come up with a better idea for a school.
Would you rather:
swim with an angry giant squid or with grindylows?


message 122: by Kaitlyn (new)

Kaitlyn | 1 comments Grindylows -- because even if Fleur couldn't take them, I think I could ...

Would you rather:
be captured by Bellatrix, who likes to "play with her food," or Fenrir, who will actually treat you like food?


message 123: by TempOcean (new)

TempOcean (mountainsage) | 16 comments either or. both of them are pretty sweet.

Who would you rather have as president?
Mccain or Obama?


message 124: by Rachel (last edited Feb 22, 2008 10:51PM) (new)

Rachel Alexandria (rachelvidmar) | 20 comments Obama!! what does that do with Harry Potter again?

would you rather be a member of the DA and get in trouble, or be handpicked for the Inquisitorial Squad and get special priveleges?


message 125: by Saybaar (new)

Saybaar | 6 comments Totally the Inquisitorial Squad, I'm such a teacher's pet. That's not to say I might not betray them once I'm in, though.

Would you rather be friends with Draco or school-age Lucius?


message 126: by Snowendy (new)

Snowendy | 8 comments Draco. Lucius is totally a jerk! I don't know but I think Draco will be a little bit better.

If one of the houselves MUST die, would you rather it be Kreacher, Winky or Dobby?




message 127: by Rainy (new)

Rainy Tell ron he has an emotional range of a teaspoon


message 128: by Rainy (new)

Rainy i would pick Hermione because she is smart but i would also choose ginny because she is sweet and kind as am i. So i would choose both.


message 129: by Tess (last edited Feb 25, 2008 07:09AM) (new)

Tess | 134 comments Um alright. I will just ask a question...
If you were a creature in Harry Potter's world, would you be a vampire, werewolf, ghost, or hippogriff?

And becuase i didnt get to answer a question, i would be a hippogiriff.

Next person answer that question.


message 130: by TempOcean (new)

TempOcean (mountainsage) | 16 comments I'd want to be the Headmaster. Hogwarts is pretty sweet, and there'd probably be more things like the Room of Requirement to find, because Dumbledore said that even he didn't know all of Hogwarts' secrets, and neither did Tom Riddle.

Out of Harry and all of his friends, which would be the best Minister of Magic?


message 131: by Tess (new)

Tess | 134 comments Hermione. She's smart and caring.

If you had an unlimited gift card to one of the wizarding stores, which would it be? DONT MAKE UP ANY.


message 132: by TempOcean (new)

TempOcean (mountainsage) | 16 comments Weasley's Wizard Wheezes!!!!!!!!!1

If you had to choose (for guys) between Ginny and Luna, who would you go out with?

If you had to choose (for girls) between Ron and Harry, who would you go out with?


message 133: by [deleted user] (last edited Feb 27, 2008 01:44PM) (new)

Harry, because he's so brave and awesome. Plus, I'm part of a big family, so that would be nice for him!

would u rather dance with hagrid or dumbledore in the yule ball? (if dumbledore wasn't dead)


message 134: by Keertana (new)

Keertana (phoenix_magyk) | 4 comments Definitly Dumbledore. What would you rather do. Be Snape's assisstant or Proffessor Umbridge's assisstant?


message 135: by Tess (new)

Tess | 134 comments Snape!
Would you rather have a pet owl, or a pet rat?


message 136: by Joanie (new)

Joanie | 7 comments Owl, definitely.

Would you rather have to be roommates with Moaning Myrtle or Peeves?


message 137: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 I'd be attacked by inferi. I'd hate to live without a soul, being just an empty case. Plus, Patronuses are hard to perform, whereas the spell used to ward off inferi would be a lot easier to perform.

Would you rather...
Befriend Rita Skeeter or Umbridge?


message 138: by Allie (new)

Allie Rita skeeter because I would find out that she was an animaguis and bust here out on the other hand umbredge. . .
Would you rather be snape or dumbledore?


message 139: by Sanskriti (new)

Sanskriti horace slughorn..he wasnt of much use anyway after he gave the memory to harry!


would you..
go to the 'three broomsticks' for the butterbeer or to catch madam rosmerta's eye?




message 140: by Katie (new)

Katie | 67 comments cough cough. butterbeer.

Would you rather have the Marauder's Map or the invisibility cloak?


message 141: by Lilmargarita (new)

Lilmargarita | 98 comments marauder's map......if someone is coming, i can usually hide or come up with an excuse for being there.


message 142: by Sella (new)

Sella Malin you forgot a question...anyway...

would you rather...
prevent dumbledore's death or prevent sirius's death?


message 143: by Sella (new)

Sella Malin apparation license!! much faster, and I would love to appear and disappear!!

would you rather...
have dobby as a house-elf or kreacher (the nicer version- like when he was towards the end of Harry Potter 7)?


message 144: by Sasha (new)

Sasha | 4 comments DOBBY!!!

Would you rather...
Meet Albus Potter or Scorpius Malfoy?
(personally, I'd meet Scorpy... JK says he's different from Draco...)


message 145: by Katie (new)

Katie | 67 comments Nagini. I'd prefer being able to look at my pet even if does house part of an evil person's soul.

Hogwarts headmaster or Minister of Magic?


message 146: by TempOcean (new)

TempOcean (mountainsage) | 16 comments Hogwarts Headmaster becuase you'd be able to check out all the undiscovered secrets that are still in the castle.

How would you prefer to die in HP - Avada Kedavra or a basilisk's stare? (Both are painless, as far as I know).


message 147: by Sean (new)

Sean | 17 comments avada kedabra, i think.

would you rather teach transfigeration or charms?


message 148: by Natalie (last edited Mar 26, 2008 09:03AM) (new)

Natalie (volleyballfreak24) | 2 comments Transfigurations cuz that would b so kool 2 turn stuff into other stuffff!!

would you rather.... meet Ron or Hermione


message 149: by Maya (new)

Maya (numerounochewylover) | 270 comments Hermione cuz we have similar personalities and she's so awesome!!!
would you rather... go to the three broomsticks or to the hogwarts kitchens?


message 150: by Sella (new)

Sella Malin dudley..he was nice at the end. Vernon, however...no need for words.

would you rather...
have harry get back with Cho Chang or have him go out with Romilda Vane?


back to top