The Hunger Games
discussion
How old were you when you read this?
message 51:
by
Andrea
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 20, 2012 08:03PM

reply
|
flag


I was nine.


http://divaliciouzbookreviews.blogspo...
9. I started reading harry potter in kindergarten, so its not that suprising.

13.. though if i had heard of it before, i could have handled it at a younger age..
Rachael wrote: "I just read it and am 24. LOVED the book. unimpressed by the movie."
Same here.. the movie should not be related to the book
Same here.. the movie should not be related to the book

And as for letting your kids read these books. I actually dont see any harm with letting your kids read them if they want to read them. Im pretty sensitive to any animal deaths in books (usually dont finish the book when it happens) but i think in the context of the book everything works well together. Even the brutal deaths don't have too much of an impact as you know they are part of the game, and it's a fictional story! but i dont have kids so perhaps i'm not the best person to judge.

Same here.. the movie should not be related to the book"
the flames were a HUGE let down to me....did you feel the same?
Yeah, most of i was.. Rues death, haymitch and katnisses relationship, haymitch's actor, the flames, i could go on..

I don't think it's ok for anyone under 11. My brother read it in the 4th grade, but he was pretty mature for that age.









I hope no one hates me for my opinion - honestly, this is SUCH a subjective question, and people mature at different rates, so we can't pick one age for everyone, but coming from my own life, background, and feelings on the subject, here goes:
While I think the writing can be easily appreciated by younger audiences (10-12 ish), I think the content is a little mature. I realize that kids are growing up faster now-a-days, but I personally would rather see kids wait until they're a little older - middle school or even high school - for some of this content.
I saw a strong theme in this book against desensitization to violence (all those in the Capitol who watched the gore for entertainment), and I feel that the sad irony is when younger and younger children are subjected to violent books and movies.
I think the content of this book is brilliant, and I very much enjoyed it. And the maturity level of a child is something to be decided by the child and the parent. Knowing where I was as a 12 year old, I know I wasn't ready for such material. And I just strongly believe that a child shouldn't "grow up" too quickly, but should be allowed to mature and appreciate these topics in their own time.



We saw the movie on Friday night and it fell a bit flat for us because the characters couldn't be developed well enough in the short amount of time the movie had to do so.

Wow, I completely agree with you on twilight but that harry potter comment was a bit harsh ...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Redwall (other topics)
Redwall (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Redwall (other topics)Redwall (other topics)
Redwall (other topics)
The Hunger Games (other topics)