Mockingjay
discussion
In the end, who do you think suffered the most?
message 51:
by
Samantha
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 23, 2012 07:54AM

reply
|
flag




He was so over her and all into the cause by the end of the book... in the begining yeah I would say he suffered but by the end he had let it consume who he was..
i think peeta did. though everyone obviously suffered i think he suffered a tiny bit more. peeta had a sweet sense of faith in the good in people i think. in people's strength against adversity and in his own strength. i reckon through his experience that was shaken and that would be enough to screw anyone over. that and he would've had this whole internal struggle and that would be crap. Plus he totally lost everyone he loved except katniss of course but his entire family and his home and stuff.

Prim was the only reason she made those whole things on three books, in the end it was nothing. The only positive result is just there is no Hunger Games anymore. I was realy shocked when I knew Prim died :(

But everyone suffered.





I totally agree, possibly one of the most depressing endings ever. It's right up their with the Nightshade series book Bloodrose.



How common.
What make this book so strong , that at the end all the characters you get to know and love were lost or suffer so much, that even the big change at the end didn’t matter anymore, you feel for the characters and all their lost.


Totally agreed!

Johanna- Lost everything and was tortured and
Peeta- lost everything as well, tortured for a long time, mind controlled

Agree !

that's a terrible thing to say. different people have different priorities. that's perfectly fine that these are yours, but I think that a large portion of people would rather suffer every imaginable indignity and trauma than lose their loved ones (you know, sorta the premise of the hunger games)...and some perhaps would even say that "if you argue otherwise, you're probably an awful person."

Samuel wrote: "Me."
definitely true!!! xD
i felt all the pain the characters had. 0.o
definitely true!!! xD
i felt all the pain the characters had. 0.o

definitely true!!! xD
i felt all the pain the characters had. 0.o"
I think that everyone would agree the readers suffered the most :)! I mean, forget about Katniss.


For instance, I see a lot of people who say that Katniss's mom suffers the most. Because she did not grow and change as a result of her circumstances, (at least not for the better), I feel NOTHING for Katniss's mom.
On the other hand, Haymitch, Katniss, Peeta, and Gale all make changes and grow as a result of their ordeals.


I agree !
![[Coco]](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1446446786p1/1089930.jpg)
So true.
Katniss suffered because she lost Peeta and Prim, Gale suffered because he lost Katniss, and Peeta suffered because he lost his mind. Haymitch lost his family. Watching the Games was awful for the families and friends of the kids. And even winning the Games you were scarred forever. Everyone suffered.



Katniss suffered the most if you add together everything that happened in the books (going into the games, losing Gale then prim) PLUS her fathers death and mother reaction to the death.
But in the series itself I think Peeta suffered the most (going into the games, loving a girl who didnt love him back, being hijacked, losing him family). but he also experianced the most joy and was the only person who was consistently happy through out the series, other than when he has hijacked.
Then there is Johanna, Prim, Finnick, Haymich, Cinna, the Prep team, Mrs everdean, Gale, Rue, and just about every one else in the whole series! including President Snow (yes, he did suffer even if every one hates to much to see it).
so anyways, I think it all depends on the perspective.


I would never have said Haymitch but after reading this argument I agree. The character saw nothing but death and loss in the cruelest ways; years before Katiss or Peeta were even involved.
Yep, good shout with that one.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic