Breaking Dawn
discussion
what should have been?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Zanaija
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 27, 2012 07:48PM
WARNING IF HAVE NOT READ THIS BOOK THE BEWARE OF SPOILERS! do you think Bella should have chosen Jacob instead of Edward
reply
|
flag
No, Edward was the love of her life, he was her air she couldn't live without. Jacob was her best friend who she loved, there is a difference. On a personal note, after seeing the movies, I would have picked Jacob ;0)
Leah should have had a happy ending.
This is the conversation I had with my ittle bro after seeing BDAmy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going out, duh
Bro: *Runs away screaming* EEEEEEEWWWWWWW!
Amy Lee wrote: "This is the conversation I had with my ittle bro after seeing BDAmy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going o..."
Aww how cute :)
She was never going to choose JAcob. She never loved him like Edward. And if she had chosen to be with him she would never truly be happy as she'd always be thinking of Edward & that would be unfair on everyone.
In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one. Jacob was meant to imprint on Renesmee from day one. That's just the way it was going to be from the beginning.
On a personal note, I think Edward was the right choice for a husband. Jacob was the best choice for a friend. I could have done without the imprinting on a baby...it's creepy.
well, in a perfect world, yes. but that wouldnt happen because jacob's soul mate is bella's daughter, awkward.
Shanna wrote: "Leah should have had a happy ending."I agree!
i think edward was perfect for her, but to answer the question "what should've been?" i think jacob really shouldn't have imprinted on Renesmee, it was way too weard. and yeah, i really wanted Leah to have a happy ending, but it gets really silly when everybody in whatever story gets their happy ending. and one more think about the whole sequel, i really hated the thing about how Edward glitters in the sun, it's absurd. and i wasn't exactly diggin the fact of how many times Bella had described him as beautiful in every book..
Well perhaps not a happy ending but at least the beginning of one, which I guess she sort kinda got, not being linked directly to Sam any more she could move on.
I don't hate Edward and Bella, but I think it should have been Jacob and Bella in the end. I think that they understand each other a little more than Edward understands Bella. As for the imprinting, I don't care, it put Jacob out of his heartbreak. Plus, imprinting is involuntary... Jacob couldn't help it.
Amy Lee wrote: "This is the conversation I had with my ittle bro after seeing BDAmy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going o..."
that's hilarious
Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one. Jacob was ..."
no i think bella should have been with jacob all along.
soemthing should have happened with Leah But i am so glad that Bella picked Eddie (no, that just sounds wrong. Ed? Icklewickledonkey? Okay... just, NO! I'll just stick with Edward.)
Zanaija wrote: "Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one..."
I disagree and so did the author, apparently. The point of my post was that from the beginning of the series, Bella was always going to be with Edward.
Nicole wrote: "Zanaija wrote: "Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with E..."
oh okay
Bella had two futures.both were perfect,at the same time time both was impossible.since she had gone mad already,it didn't matter really which future she would choose(i.e, it was obvious)
Amy Lee wrote: "This is the conversation I had with my ittle bro after seeing BDAmy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going o..."
thats hilarious!!!
i'm happy with edward and bella being together, they are meant to be together. Though i am team jacob, if that makes sense
I mean, imagine what would have happened if she had chosen Jacob:1. She wouldn't have a baby that was eating her from the inside out
2. She wouldn't be a vampire
3. She could live more of a normal life
4. Her dad would be happy
5. She wouldn't have to continuously move from place to place
6. She wouldn't be a vampire
7. She wouldn't be a vampire
8. She wouldn't be a vampire
Oooh, what could have been.....
But then again, Edward is the love of her life, she can't live without him, etc.
Nicole wrote: "Heck yeah! I mean, imagine what would have happened if she had chosen Jacob:1. She wouldn't have a baby that was eating her from the inside out
2. She wouldn't be a vampire
3. She could live more ..."
lol
Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one. Jacob was ..."
Well, about the imprinting, it's not so awkward (in my opinion). I mean, of course he was going to imprint on her as a baby. He imprints on her the day he meets her. It's not like she's going to be born as a teenager. Besides, it doesn't mean he has to marry her. It means he's like a protecter. And also, I recall the books saying that he won't grow up as fast as others. So one day they will be the same age. Then it won't be creepy. And once he umm... retires, from being a werewolf, then he will age and they won't be completely off balance.
Nicole wrote: "Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one..."
but nessy will stop aging at a certain point, so jacob should stay a werewolf forever!!!
Nicole wrote: "Nicole wrote: "In the books, Jacob came across as a whinny, little poop. He really pissed me off. It didn't translate the same way in the movies. Bella was meant to be with Edward from day one..."
Agreed. Plus the fact that Renesme grows at a rapid pace.
Shanna wrote: "Leah should have had a happy ending."I thought Jacob would have got together with Leah as they started to get along when she joined his 'pack'. I think that would have been better than him imprinting on 'Nessie'. Plus they both experienced heartbreak, would have made a nice ending?..
well heres how i would of wanted the ending to be bella ends up with Edward they have Renesme Jacob doesn't imprint on her and runs away with Leah
No, the imprinting thing is simply creepy IMO.
Shanna wrote: "Well perhaps not a happy ending but at least the beginning of one, which I guess she sort kinda got, not being linked directly to Sam any more she could move on."i respect your opinion very much, reminds me of the movie Little Black Book, "in a happy ending, it doesn't have to be that the girls gets the boy, or in my case the two boys". made me cry the first time i saw the movie. i've always embraced the idea that the girl doesn't have to get the to live happily and truly embrace life.
Nicole wrote: "I mean, imagine what would have happened if she had chosen Jacob:1. She wouldn't have a baby that was eating her from the inside out
2. She wouldn't be a vampire
3. She could live more of a normal..."
that's hilirious, i was team Edward a long time ago, and now i'm team "twilight is absurd", really, i agree!
Eve wrote: "No, Edward was the love of her life, he was her air she couldn't live without. Jacob was her best friend who she loved, there is a difference. On a personal note, after seeing the movies, I would ..."Same here.
Any one else think that she should have waited before choosing either one? I mean...why would she immediatly decided that Edward was going to be the love of her life? Now that she's a vampire she's going to be stuck with him for a VERY long time...
Sable wrote: "Any one else think that she should have waited before choosing either one? I mean...why would she immediatly decided that Edward was going to be the love of her life? Now that she's a vampire she's..."And not get any sleep at all, for that matter....
Yasmeen wrote: "Shanna wrote: "Well perhaps not a happy ending but at least the beginning of one, which I guess she sort kinda got, not being linked directly to Sam any more she could move on."i respect your opi..."
Thank you I'll have to watch The Little Black Book now.
I agree HEA's don't have include "The One", nice if it can happen, but the HEA shouldn't hinge on it. Though they are Romance novels....
Shanna wrote: "Yasmeen wrote: "Shanna wrote: "Well perhaps not a happy ending but at least the beginning of one, which I guess she sort kinda got, not being linked directly to Sam any more she could move on."i ..."
yeah, you should, really good movie. ancient though! i think it's from the beginning of the new mellinuim. and FYI, i don't know what HEA means so i kind of missed the whole comment. :))
Totally Glee Obsessed wrote: "This is the conversation I had with my ittle bro after seeing BD
Amy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going o..."
THAT IS SOOO FUNNY!
Amy: Wasn't that AWESOME?!!!!?
Bro: Leah should be with Seth
Amy: They're brother and sister, it'd be like you and me going o..."
THAT IS SOOO FUNNY!
Yasmeen wrote: "i don't know what HEA means..."happily ever after, I believe.
Yasmeen wrote: "Shanna wrote: "Yasmeen wrote: "Shanna wrote: "Well perhaps not a happy ending but at least the beginning of one, which I guess she sort kinda got, not being linked directly to Sam any more she coul..."Sorry, yeah what Kirby said, HEA =happily ever after
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
