New Moon (The Twilight Saga, #2) New Moon discussion


239 views
Team Edward, Team Jacob

Comments Showing 51-100 of 120 (120 new)    post a comment »

Nya Tomlinson-Horan-Malik-Payne-Styles JACOB IS AWESOME! but edward and bella can go on and live their mysterious, awkward lives


Malak Silmi Team Jacob!!!!!!!!!!!❤


Pamela Nya wrote: "JACOB IS AWESOME! but edward and bella can go on and live their mysterious, awkward lives"

ha ha thats funny. I love Jacob.


Carlita Villagra I'm team Jacob... because I understand him always... he's nice...


Sammi Team Jacob!!! Not jus because he is sooo hot, its just because I love the chemistry they have in the book. I love the fact that Jacob doesn't try and hide things from Bella and just tells her how it is. And as Jacon said in a different world they were meant to b together.


message 56: by [deleted user] (new)

Jacob he's super sexy!!!!!!!! :)


Missy I don't even know why there is teams we all know who she winds up with and it would never work with Jacob anyway he would break Bella's heart worse then Edward ever could b/c of the whole imprinting thing Jacob would break her heart and be with someone else that he imprints on b/c he can do no other once he imprints and we all know he DOES NOT imprint on Bella so this whole team thing is pointless.


Cocoa Jacob duhhh..... he is so hot


Malak Silmi Melissa wrote: "I don't even know why there is teams we all know who she winds up with and it would never work with Jacob anyway he would break Bella's heart worse then Edward ever could b/c of the whole imprintin..."

Umm... u know this is for choosing which guy is better Jacob or Edward. its your opinion and everyone knows who bella ended up with..:/ if u dont like this then dont comment .... Team Jacob!!!!!!! <3


LaShawnda Roberts Team Jacob. Jacob respects Bella's choices a lot more than Edward. Edward is too controlling.


Pamela LaShawnda wrote: "Team Jacob. Jacob respects Bella's choices a lot more than Edward. Edward is too controlling."
I agree.

I find that Jacob will do anything for Bella. Edward is just there and makes Bella do everything for him.


Nichole Team Carlisle. lol.


Pamela That's new?!!!


Allie Neither!!!!! TEAM SETH!!!!!!! <3<3<3


Pamela Ally wrote: "Neither!!!!! TEAM SETH!!!!!!! <3<3<3"

Ha ha That's funny!!! Everyone is changing the subject of this discussion.


Malak Silmi Ally wrote: "Neither!!!!! TEAM SETH!!!!!!! <3<3<3"

LOl i LOVE seth!!!! but JACOB MORE!!!! WAy MOREE <3


message 67: by Pamela (last edited Mar 12, 2012 01:25PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pamela Hellokitty101 wrote: "Ally wrote: "Neither!!!!! TEAM SETH!!!!!!!

LOl i LOVE seth!!!! but JACOB MORE!!!! WAy MOREE <3"


Agreed!!!!!!

Everyone likes Jacob,But Bella HAD to go with Edward.


Allie if i had to choose between JUST Edward and Jake if would choose Jake!!! love him 2!!!!!! But still i love Seth ALOT ALOT ALOT more. Go team Seth! <3 lol


hanpanparker TEAM JACOB!! He was sooooooo nice to Bella in New Moon. I mean, Edward dumped her in the woods! Then he wanted her back! Well, he shouldn't have dumped her in the first place if he wanted her. So I'm totally Team Jacob.


Malak Silmi Zanna wrote: "TEAM JACOB!! He was sooooooo nice to Bella in New Moon. I mean, Edward dumped her in the woods! Then he wanted her back! Well, he shouldn't have dumped her in the first place if he wanted her. So I..."

YEA i know sooooo true jacob would have never done that!! Edward's a JERK A BIG ONE WITH FANGS!!!


Nahirannette Team Jacob :] He loves Belle more then Edward to me.


Tassneem I would never choose Edward Upon Jacob . He's nice , handsome and so cool . I love his charachter and I'm not convinced with the way the story made him live because his happiness was too late .


Maria Team EDWARD!!!


Maraiabelle Team Jacob totally! Edward is weird and ugly! Edward will make Bella more in danger than Jacob and who wouldn't want a buff werewolf?


message 75: by [deleted user] (new)

Maraiabelle wrote: "Team Jacob totally! Edward is weird and ugly! Edward will make Bella more in danger than Jacob and who wouldn't want a buff werewolf?"

So true :) I don't know who wouldn't agree with that


Steph TEAM JACOB!No doubt about it! Edward LEFT her, if he really loved her he should have seen that leaving would make her miserable! Jacob would never do that!


message 77: by Rula (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rula Sable wrote: "Can someone please explain to me the whole Team Edward vs Team Jacob thing? I've read the books but I never understood the need for Teams for the two characters."

edward is a vampire
jacob is a werewolf

there is nothing hard to choose between.


message 78: by Rula (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rula for me it has to be Jacob - he's hot, gorgeous and sexy, if you like the werewolf kind.
edward is sweet though - not the kind of guy for me.


message 79: by [deleted user] (new)

TEAM EDWARD!


DiAnn Team Edward...forever though I finally liked Jacob in Breaking Dawn Part 1.


Meeeriams Fleep OhmyGOSH. This discussion is so old. Jacob is clearly a paedo and Edward and Bella are clearly warped and they shall get sick of living forever soon


Ascel Kadhem Team VICTORIA!! Shame she wasn't able to kill bella x(


Hailey Team Edward all the way.


brooke1994 Team Jacob, for the WOLF part, not for the who's better for who part. Although I did like the imprinting scene, hopefully Renesmee is smarter than her mom and chooses him more.


Julia Team Edward! Jacob is stupid in the books. :)


JAYDAWG1000 Team Jacob. Jacob actually tried really hard to win bella's heart but Edward had her heart from the beginning.


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ the teams are there because it's actually who YOU think is better for BELLA. TEAM JACOB!


brooke1994 Team Jacob, but I chose my team from the books. Jacob Black is way more sophisticated than Taylor Lautner. They picked lousy actors to play the characters. So go Bella Edward and Jacob BUT NOT the actors.


message 89: by Rula (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rula Hellokitty101 wrote: "Zanna wrote: "TEAM JACOB!! He was sooooooo nice to Bella in New Moon. I mean, Edward dumped her in the woods! Then he wanted her back! Well, he shouldn't have dumped her in the first place if he wa..."

i disagree with that because he only did that so bella would find it easier to live her life without him. bella loved him so much and she made the right choice to not be without him.


message 90: by [deleted user] (new)

I just can't believe all of you like Jacob. He is so stupid. He's just jealous of what Edward and Bella have. The only reason he like Bella was that he was or going to imprint on Nessie. I did find it cute when him mad Leah decide that if either of them imprint that would be together. Jacob was just a comfort for Bella she never really like him. Jacob just made her like him. Jacob just wanted Bella for himself. He didn't care that Bella wanted to be with Edward. This is why Edward is better for her. Edward just wanted her to have a happy human life. So he thought that if he left she could have a normally. It turn out that that was the worst thing he could have done. Edward cares so much for her that he would die for her. But when she ask Jacob to stay and not fight in Eclipse he went to fight. If Jacob really love Bella he would have stayed. Jacob and Bella have a best friend chemistry where as Edward and Bella have a chemistry that can move mountains. Every girl wants a guy like Edward not Jacob. Edward's also just more mature than Jacob. Edward's lived longer so he understands life more. This is why Edward is by far so much better than Jacob will ever be.


Rachel Zafia wrote: "In my opinion there are no teams. The wolves imprints on their partner and seeing as there was no imprinting going on with jacob/bella theres no team. Otherwise its just gonna turn into another sap..."

Good point. Yep he never did imprint on Bella, he just loved her.


Rachel Jennifer wrote: "Spoilers alert

Good question. Love triangles are commonplace in paranormal romances, and often the reader finds themselves being torn between the two choices just as the main character does (othe..."


Yeah the imprinting on the baby was kinda odd. But he suppose to be there for her and protect her. Im wondering when the author wrote this, did she actually have in mind a lovers idea or more of a big brother kinda love.


Jackie Team Edward all the way!!!!


Annemarien Faraminan If you go into who to choose I would like to say that:
Team Jacob is exciting, warm and true that I more logical choice.
Team Edward is romantic, dangerous, and risky and not the first choice people would take.
Now I am a true vampire lover, so to it would be Team Edward a logical choice.


message 95: by [deleted user] (new)

jacob


Phoebe Fitz-Gerald TEAM EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 97: by Megan (new) - rated it 1 star

Megan Jacob!


Scarlet TEAM JACOOOBBBBBB!!!!!

she shouts from the top of her lung from the top of a great canyon! Bent at the waist,arms back, wild curls being tosseled in the air.

I LOVE YOU!!!!!


Emily Team Jacob!!!!!!!!!


He's way cuter than Edward.


Eugenia9 **LS9** Team Edward definitely! but I like TEAM CARLISLE more.... =D Jasper is cool too...


back to top