Feeling Lost On What to Read Next

[Dawn]

I loved The Magician King, I gave it five stars. Just saying :)

[Nicole]

Apologies. Just double-checked. I meant The Magicians. THAT was the worst book I have ever read. I've heard The Magician King is much better but can't bring myself to read it.

[Chris]

I gave 'em both 4-stars. Excellent stuff.

[Stan]

The Magicians is fantastic. The Magician King is less so.

[Dawn]

I'm completely opposite. The Magicians is great... The Magician King is even better.

[Chris]

And as a Libra, I'll balance it by saying that I liked them equally.

[colleen the convivial curmudgeon]

As a Scorpio I'll say they both sucked!

(Though as I've never read the second, I'm half joking... )

[Stan]

Colleen, who'd have guessed we're both Scorpios?

[[deleted user]]

Match made in heaven hell the unspeakable realms beyond knowing.

[Jeff]

Ala wrote: "Match made in heaven hell the unspeakable realms beyond knowing."

So these realms would most resemble:

a) middle school
b) a cubicle farm at a call center
c) the paranormal romance shelves in a Borders
d) none of the above

?

[[deleted user]]

E) all of the above

[Reginac1]

Dawn wrote: "I'm completely opposite. The Magicians is great... The Magician King is even better."

Agree with Stan. the first book is great. The second, meh.

[Dawn]

I just loved the second book. It was so funny. The Teletubbies lines killed me. I have an immature sense of humor sometimes ;)

[Robert]

Who'd have guessed you both have an eery sense of humor? I kid, but seriously, chill. In all seriousness, I seriously take all of your opinions somewhat seriously in all seriousness.