Around the World discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
2012-2024 Discussions
>
Where in the World Have You Been?!?! (Book Finished and Review Linked)

In an interview with Achebe printed after the text, he even said that he thought Africa "gained a lot" from the colonial period and that he thought the pre-colonial Ibo society had a "cruel" side to it. So, yes, I do think Achebe is a lot more complex in his view than his reputation--or what I'd heard of it. Or even than a lot of reviewers of the book admit who seem determined to put a "Dances With Wolves" gloss on it no matter what.

I find that too, Chrissie.


http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
I find Ancient Egypt fascinating, and Mahfouz is a Nobel Prize winning author, so I expected to love this, but merely liked it. It's a very short, quick read, so not a huge investment if the subject interests you--I read it in little more than two hours.

I hope that you escape the lingering memory of "A Fine Balance", a book whose scenes and rationale still reoccur to me after a few years. It's getting better.

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
I find Ancient Egypt fascinating, and..."
I did not read that one , my favorite in this area for him is Khufu's Wisdom , but I read it about 15 years ago .
*****
I finished Love in the Time of Cholera , I did not like it as I expected to (big deal of that was the protagonist ) . Yet I admit that I enjoyed the era and the historical atmosphere of colombia by the end of the 19th Century and the beginning of the 20th . I did not write a review .


*****
I finished Love in the Time of Cholera , I did not like it as I expected to (big deal of that was the protagonist ) ."
Even though I didn't adore the Akhenaten book, I liked Mahfouz just enough I'd be interested in trying that some day.
Gabriel Garcia Marquez is on my list for Columbia--One Hundred Years of Solitude--I hope I'll like him more than you did--even though I think I'm almost dreading it as much as anticipating. Don't always adore magical realism--and boy that puppy is long

My review is here!
Now onto Australia!

Gabriel Garcia Marquez is on my list for Columbia--One Hundred Years of Solitude--I hope I'll like him more than you did--even though I think I'm almost dreading it as much as anticipating. Don't always adore magical realism--and boy that puppy is long..."
For Mahfouz , that is good to hear :) I read so many books for him .BTW if Ancient Egypt is not your only target , you can consider The Cairo Trilogy: Palace Walk / Palace of Desire / Sugar Street
For my list ,I will be reading The Harafish with some members here in April.
For Marquez , same happened to me as you with Mahfouz ,so I liked the way he writes , so this will not be my last read for him ,also I started "One Hundred Years of Solitude" before in a bad timing and stopped , but I am planning to get back to it (not soon) good luck with it :)

I've started to call it "immersive reading." If you add music and food, wow, what an experience.


My review"
Great review, Barry. Looks like you had a great time on the second leg of your journey. Wiped out the memory of the book that shall not be mentioned. :)

I gave the book 5 stars, my first of 2012.


I gave the book 5 stars, my first of 2012."
Thanks for the review ! I have read it a year ago , here is my review ,(Sigheh) was an important issue for me as well to think about and write.

I gave the book 5 stars, my first of 2012."
I'm glad you enjoyed it Janice, it was a couple of years ago that I read it, but I really liked it

I've got this one to read too Sue, glad to hear it lived up to the hype!




I also baked up some po'e, so come on over....




The first isn't on my 52 books list, but I mention it if anyone's interested in choosing a book for Tanzania. Fossey's book was on my list and my review can be found here:
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
Both women were recruited to study great apes in the wild by legendary anthropologist Louis Leakey.
I wasn't crazy about either book. With Goodall, I could have wished much more about the chimpanzees, and a lot less about her political and spiritual beliefs. With Fossey, I found a lot of the material about the gorillas too detailed and dry--more a scientific paper than a tale about nature and adventure. Both books have moving moments though.
My response to the two women was very different. I disagree a lot with Goodall's world view--but at the end, I felt for her a lot of liking, respect, even admiration. It was very different with Fossey--given how she herself described how she treated those around her, I wound up not much liking her at all, and fairly or not, that's reflected in my rating.
I can't do it. I can't read My Year in Oman: An American Experience in Arabia During the War on Terror. Maybe in the future, but not now, when there are well-written books to enjoy. I've ordered Oman, Under Arabian Skies from Book Depository.

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

@Harmonybites, I like your analysis of the two books. Fossey was certainly a far less palatable character than Goodall, and having read Gorillas in the Mist you do wonder which parts of her story are left untold. However, I preferred it to Goodall's memoir. I think that the dry, spare writing, which is very matter of fact, appealed to me more than Goodall's style, which was very self-analytical.

Sharon, is there any hope in it at all? I'..."
I did not see anything in the book that spoke of hope for either India or humanity. Others in my bookclub disagreed, but I think they read hope into the book because they really wanted to see it. Reviewers tend to say that it is a hard read because of all that happens to the characters but they also say it is well written. I don't find that to be true. And it's not that I'm averse to difficult subject matter: I loved Fall on Your Knees, for example. But I found MacDonald's book provided a more in-depth exploration of the characters, giving the reader a similarly rich understanding of why and how they did the things they did and reacted the ways they did. I felt that richness and depth was lacking in A Fine Balance. Our book club did agree there was a curious emotional detachment in Mistry's book, but most of the others were glad it was there as it provided a kind of buffer between the reader and the events in the book.
Given that most people disagree with my review of A Fine Balance, I would not want you to decide to read or not read the book on the basis of my opinion. It does present a very realistic view of the Emergency in India, and, unfortunately, much of what happened then still happens today. In that way, it is an important read. Please do look around, see what others think before you decide! If you do read it, please let me know what you think!


I haven't done my review yet. I'll link it when I do.

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...

No. It's without the wind chill.

No. It's without the wind chill."
BBRRRR! I thought I had it bad.



No. It's without the wind chill."
Wow, that is seriously cold, Janice! it's been -18 (-32 with wind chill) in Montreal, but we've been having yo-yo weather. We're going to -2 today, and it's snowing which means freezing rain.... ugh.

I understand feeling that way. Both books disappointed me frankly, because I do find anthropology fascinating, even took classes and considered it for a major. With Fossey though, by the end I found it hard to trust her--which is a major issue in a memoir. There really were moving parts even so--those wild orphans--and if you are interested in gorillas, a lot of information!

So glad to hear that! It's on my list, so it's nice to know that others are enjoying it!




No. It's without the wind chill."
Wow, that is seriously cold, Janice! it's been -18 (-32 with win..."
Okay I feel bad. Yesterday I was complaining that its freezing because it was in the 40's. That would be a heatwave to you ladies right now.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Orphan Master's Son (other topics)Kino: A Novel (other topics)
True: A Novel (other topics)
Secretum (other topics)
Secretum (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Eduardo Galeano (other topics)Coleridge Cook (other topics)
Tomas Tranströmer (other topics)
Gloria Whelan (other topics)
Michael Morpurgo (other topics)
More...
I liked that book alot, especially as it was an early example of an African viewpoint of the colonial era by a native African author and it is more nuanced than the publicity it gets.