Mockingjay
discussion
The Most Unnecessary Death
date
newest »
newest »
message 351:
by
Jamie (The Kansan Reader)
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
May 01, 2015 09:37AM
I don't think there was an unnecessary death in the book. Collins may have showed that death takes who it takes an there is no fairness in it.
reply
|
flag
Alma Coin. It's like Julianne said once: the fact the books are in Katniss view- so we are captured in her mind, view, opinion and so on. Bc of that we are catched and manipulated by her. I definitely enjoy reading the passage with Alma. And it is not that I see a different person in Alma, bc I really adore and love Julianne. Her intentions and ideas how to play and embody Alma in the movies are definitely my real idea of Alma and so her death is so unnecessary.
Cinna maybe?His death was a threat to Katniss but was it necessary...
I think Prim could've lived and definitely Finnick should've lived.
Finnick and although I didn't want Prim too die i think it WAS a necessary for her too die. Sorry, I just think it made the plot better.
Don't' you this topic ought to have spoiler warnings?
No because its based on the last book in the series. If it was the first or second, then yes, there would need to be spoiler warnings.
Finnick. Although, Prim's death was sad, too. I hated it when Rue, Boggs, Madge and Maggs died, though. But I still cry when I think of Finnick, he and Katniss are my favorite characters.
Oh and Cinna! I keep mourning Finnick, though.
Finnick in the book was heart breaking, he just got his true love back and little did he know a baby on the way, it was just like...not fair!
Haley wrote: "F I N N I C K"Yup. Why did he have to die! NO! I refuse to believe it.
Finnick... but I was the saddest about Rue and Prim.
The story actually starts with Katniss trying to protect Prim by taking her place in the games.....So I guess the motive is all lost after her death
KhanMunaza wrote: "The story actually starts with Katniss trying to protect Prim by taking her place in the games.....So I guess the motive is all lost after her death"Yeah. Prim and Finnick. Rue and Cinna.
Finnick. In both the books and the movies his death was pointless. The characters didn't mourn over the loss of there friend! to me, finnick was proof of what the capital does to victors and that they don't let the victors really win. they just let them survive (which still is awful because they then have to become mentors). his death made the book mockingjay less enjoyable. i see where Collins is coming from but it would have been better if finnick lived to see the ending of the rebellion and was left alive as proof of the past and what the capital used to be. he should have at least had a better and more emotional death that contributed to the cause.
KhanMunaza wrote: "The story actually starts with Katniss trying to protect Prim by taking her place in the games.....So I guess the motive is all lost after her death"not necessarily. i agree with prim's death only because it was katniss's last straw against coin. prim's death stopped the uprising of coin and helped the districts become a democracy. her motive was actually increased after her sisters death because she saw what the coin was willing to do to rule.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Mockingjay (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Serial Games (other topics)Mockingjay (other topics)
