Sign of the Moon
discussion
Hollyleaf-dead or alive?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Amy
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 22, 2011 08:01PM
I think that Hollyeaf survives when she jumps into the tunnels, but I'm not positive..........what do you guys think?
reply
|
flag
No, all the evidence that is being surfaced...She has to be alive. Its just contemplatable whether or not Erin Hunter will introduce her into the books again or not.
Well, just wait for The Last Hope.
You'll find out then.
You'll find out more in The Forgotten Warrior... :D
I think she's dead but then there is the book Hollyleafs story (short story) which shows evidence that she's alive.
It never said straight out that Hollyleaf had died in Sunrise.
Claire wrote: "You'll find out more in The Forgotten Warrior... :D"Well, yes you do find out then, but.... there's more in The Last Hope
Yep...I think she may be very important in that book. :)
Not in the way you think.
Idk because I haven't gotten that book yet.
You should. Just have a box of Kleenex on hand at the end.
But how can she survive in the tunnels?
I don't know, I suppose she must have found a way out for when she needed to hunt and when the tunnels flooded.
I'm planning on getting it, probably tomorrow if I can. :D
I'm planning on getting it, probably tomorrow if I can. :D
Missy wrote: "But how can she survive in the tunnels?"There's a short story that Erin Hunter published called Hollyleaf's Story. It explains everything.
Claire wrote: "I don't know, I suppose she must have found a way out for when she needed to hunt and when the tunnels flooded. I'm planning on getting it, probably tomorrow if I can. :D"
One word: Kleenex.
I have a lot of that around the house right now, (everyone's sick around here!) I have a Kindle, so I hope to get Hollyleaf's Story as well. :D
Agh... not fun.
Well, same here with Kindle. I live in Japan, so I wasn't sure if I was going to be able to get The Last Hope because I'm 13 hours ahead here. But around 4pm, it finally said "Buy" instead of "Pre-order". And so from 4pm-9:30pm I read The Last Hope. And finished it.
@ Claire: Hey wait a second, I just realized. If it's 10:40 am here, what time is it for u?
9:39. That's awesome, hope you enjoy the book. :D
Claire wrote: "9:39. That's awesome, hope you enjoy the book. :D"Really sad though.
P.M. Yeah, I heard The Last Hope was going to be sad. :|
Now you would know, if you've read all the books that she's made! ;) You'll be surprised. =D
I read all the books that are out so far so I know the answer. It won't turn out so good.
Hadley Star •Don't let the Muggles get you down!• wrote: "... I-I-I'm not going to say... [spoilers removed]"yeah.....
Yeah, she is alive as of this book.
that awkward moment when you forget you didn't read this book yet and you see all the spoilers... but it was obvious she was alive so
So, who cried?
When you've read the whole series it's not so sad anymore. You get used to it, it's like a normal thing. Cat: Hey, did that cat die?Other cat: Yep.
Cat: Oh. You want go eat something?
Other cat: Sure.
That's actually kind of sad now that I think about it...
It's not sad, in the words of Santa Claus, "It's jolly!"
Judging from the fur that was left, Hollyleaf`s alive. If she was dead, her body would have been discovered by Ivypool and Blossomfall.
I don't know what to believe! There is evidence to show that she is alive, but how does she eat? She can't escape! Does prey fall through other passages? And how does she not drown when it rains? In previous books that is how many other cats died. Through the flooding of the tunnels.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
