Ancient & Medieval Historical Fiction discussion
General Discussions
>
What Are You Reading Right Now? ( Hwæt béon ðu bocrædung?)
message 3051:
by
Bruce
(new)
Sep 07, 2013 07:05PM

reply
|
flag


PB"
Thanks for saying that, Paul
Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker and the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History




I love this book. One of those stories that stays in my memory even long after reading it.
That's good to hear Lia.:) I've always been fascinated by the story of Quanah Parker & his mother, so I was thrilled to find this at the library.

Enjoy your read. A lot of very touching chapters in there. :)

This is my least favorite book by Mr. Rutherford to date. Jumping backward and forward in time style was tiresome after awhile. This writing style required total concentrations, which was difficult when the book is about 800 pages.
The story line was good in certain part, boring in certain part and melodramatic in certain part.
When the story was telling historical context, it was told in a very interesting way. However, when the topic was romance it was annoyingly soapy.

I have thought of reading this but never have done so.

Can't wait to see what you think of The Road to Jerusalem, Troy. Seeing people's opinions so far has been very interesting. Opinions on translations are always fun to observe.

That is one binge we wholeheartedly support around here. ;)

This is my least favorite book by Mr. Rutherford to date. Jumping backward and forward in time style was tiresome after awhi..."
Thanks for sharing. I have not seen much feedback on that one yet.

excellent book, and a darned good read - it has my whole hearated recommendation. Be warned it's not politically correct - it gives reasons for why "Save the last bullet for yourself" was an axiom of Indian warfare.
Since you live in Ok, have you visited Quanah's home?
happy wrote: "Derek wrote: "Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker and the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History[bookcover:Empire of the Summer Moon: Quanah Parker ..."
It is a very interesting read so far, happy. :) I don't want a PC book...I want the truth, and so far this book seems to deliver on that front.
I have visited the Star House in Cache, OK. I have Kiowa roots on my mothers side, so I didn't have any choice lol. I need to go back though. I think I would appreciate it much more now. I've also been to Quanah, Texas..not much to see there, though.
Did you see his house while you were at Ft. Sill?
It is a very interesting read so far, happy. :) I don't want a PC book...I want the truth, and so far this book seems to deliver on that front.
I have visited the Star House in Cache, OK. I have Kiowa roots on my mothers side, so I didn't have any choice lol. I need to go back though. I think I would appreciate it much more now. I've also been to Quanah, Texas..not much to see there, though.
Did you see his house while you were at Ft. Sill?



I read quite a lot of Westerns (as many as my grubby hands can get a hold of in Canada) and it wasn't until recently that I found out Elmore Leonard wrote them. I'm used to his more urban tales. Then again, I wouldn't know anything about him if it weren't for his non-Westerns being turned into films.

Yep
The Ft. Sill muesem has a pretty good Indian War exihibt ( or did more years ago than I care to remember:) )



That's an interesting thought, Darcy. He's fictitious, though, so the author could have given him a totally different name if any real Sir Benedicts are to appear later on in the story.


The most likely explanation is that the author made a mistake, thinking the usage for knights was the same as for lords. But "Sir Palmer" might also be a kind of running joke (palmer was another word for pilgrim), in the way that people said "Sir Knight."
It would bother me, too.

I am pretty sure that the 1100's had something similar, even for the 'sir' which related to knighthood rather than birth precedence.

Interesting. Do you mean that knights referred to as Sir Palmer were higher (or lower) status than knights referred to as Sir Benedict?
I've never seen that usage before, but 12th-century England is not my specialty.



The flora descriptions do upset me a bit though. I live next to the sea and try as I might, I can't smell anything from thrift - unlike Raven apparently.


Its a fascinating non-fiction history of 17th Century witchcraft shenanigans on the place I moved to last year.

I have been in that place before. many times. Reader's block is as bad as writer's block. It is hard to get passed them.

I had no idea he wrote a bit of poetry in the tribal languages? I have a novel on Ovid in exile (The Last World) and have seen others. Want to explore them now. Does 'Tristia' talk about the locals, do you know?
PS. Just bought a Kindle book of "Ovid's Poems from Exile: Tristia, Ex Ponto & Ibis" 99c




It has been two or three years since I last read these books. It is the right time to do it again. For anyone in the group, I recommend this series which starts with Genghis and ends with Kublai. Read them in order.

It has been two or three years since I last read these books. It is the right time to do it again. For anyone in the grou..."
Hi Linda, have to say I loved the first three books with Genghis & to an extent the 4th book as his empire evolved, if thats the right word, without his Iron fist but was really turned of part way through Conqueror & felt it was a book to far.

http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/62...
& give it a go.

Am also rereading Strategos - Born in the Borderlands. Am picking up more on the prejudice theme this time. Apion's learning there are good and bad on both sides.

I'm sure you'll like Ship of Rome Andy. It's a great story on the first Punic war.

I began The Last World. Ovid at the Black Sea. Gorgeous description (even in translation) but it's avant-garde stuff, with a film projectionist in the 1st century. The film was one of the stories from the Metamorphoses, and more characters from Metamorphoses are in the audience. We'll see.


I began The Last World. Ovid at the Black Sea. Gorgeous description (even in translation) but it's ..."
I think I five starred it, maybe it was 4 star. The bed hopping exhausted me. :) But I did really like the book. nearly loved it.

I'm sure you'll like Ship of Rome Andy. It's a great story on the first Punic war."
1st chapters a good hook! Nowt like a good sea chase Arrrrrr :)
Books mentioned in this topic
M*A*S*H: A Novel About Three Army Doctors (other topics)A Court of Betrayal (other topics)
Imperium (other topics)
The Handfasted Wife (other topics)
The Swan-Daughter (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Harris (other topics)Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Carol McGrath (other topics)
Ken Follett (other topics)
More...