City of Bones

[Brooke]

I'm about 1/2 way through and so far I really like it. I read ID first, so I had the background. The story line is similar, but I still like it a lot!

[Karina]

:D Yay! Both series are great!

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

I like this better than ID but both are great!

[Madeleine]

so if we took will from ID and put him against Jace...who wold win?

[Karina]

What is up with you always asking hard questions!

I say Jace?...I just like him better lol

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Jace!!!

[Madeleine]

I'm an elder soul :)

you sure? will is pretty beast

[Karina]

Lol hmm..what will they fighting for?

[Madeleine]

......

ultimate awesomeness? Supreme sarcasm master? Best fighter ever?

[Karina]

JACE! Hands Down!!

[Madeleine]

Yeah, your right. Will's nicer though.

[Courtney]

Karina wrote: "JACE! Hands Down!!"

I'm afraid I've become a traitor and now like Will more than Jace.

[Madeleine]

Will is cooler than Jace, I must say, but Jace would beat will in a fight.

[Karina]

Hahaha

What about Jace vs Simon? Lets say in CoLS Jace tries to hurt Clary while he is being mind controlled by Sebastian aNd Simon tries to fight him off to protect her. who would win?

[Madeleine]

Jace unfortunately

[Karina]

Courtney wrote: "Karina wrote: "JACE! Hands Down!!"

I'm afraid I've become a traitor and now like Will more than Jace."

WHAT?! :O
how did this happen?

[Karina]

But Simon is awesome and a vampire! Plus a part of Jace would be trying to fight off the mid control

[Madeleine]

Will. Rules.

Thats how.

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Simon is a boss but I think Jace could hands tied behind his back defeat Simon.

[Madeleine]

And Jace has who knows how many years of fighting training up his sleeve, Simon has....nothing.

[Karina]

Sorry I disagree im Team Jem!

Haha maybe you two are right about Jace beating Simon!

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Simon is a vampire he should should get some points for that!!

[Karina]

OHHH what would happen if Jace ad Clary had to battle each other!?

[Madeleine]

But Tessa loves will more....

[Karina]

Simon does get major points for that!

But Jem is a sweetheart..

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Karina wrote: "OHHH what would happen if Jace ad Clary had to battle each other!?"
that would be epic.. I hope clary kicks his butt.

[Madeleine]

Jem is a sweetheart, and I love him for that, but he's more like a brother to Tessa....

[Madeleine]

Karina wrote: "OHHH what would happen if Jace ad Clary had to battle each other!?"

What are the conditions?

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

What if Jace is put under Sebastians control could Magnus reverse the control??

[Madeleine]

maybe....Clary's rune power seems more likely though

[Karina]

Well maybe they can work together! I mean Magnus is a warlock afterall!

[Madeleine]

good point.

Ok, Clary vs. Tessa. who wins?

[Courtney]

Madeleine wrote: "Will. Rules.

Thats how."

Yes! He's just...he put himself through all of that and acted like a jerk just because he cared about his friends...I don't know. He's just better.

[Madeleine]

and then he takes the fact that Tessa will marry Jem (worse idea ever btw) and doesn't complain...just accepts it.

[Karina]

what about Jace! He gives Simon his blood to save him even though he doesn't like him! and rescues him again in CoG..

Clary would win! no doubt about that one

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

What if in CoLS there was a wedding who should get married?

[Madeleine]

Ok, but he also doesn't act on the fact he's getting strange dreams about killing his gf. Wouldn't you tell someone of that happened to you?

[Madeleine]

joyclyn and luke

[Karina]

Madeleine wrote: "Ok, but he also doesn't act on the fact he's getting strange dreams about killing his gf. Wouldn't you tell someone of that happened to you?"

I would be scared to tell anyone that!

[Karina]

There will be a huge wedding!

[Madeleine]

Something tell me that Clary's sudden disappearance to save Jace will postpone it until the end of CoHF

[Karina]

Yeah they deserve tpo get married and start a life together!

[Madeleine]

Karina wrote: "Madeleine wrote: "Ok, but he also doesn't act on the fact he's getting strange dreams about killing his gf. Wouldn't you tell someone of that happened to you?"

I would be scared to tell anyone that!"

Precisely why you have to talk!!! It would freak me out!!! If I were him, I would have at least told alec

[Madeleine]

Karina wrote: "Yeah they deserve to get married and start a life together!"

they can't do it while they worry about Clary though. I think their wedding would make for a good ending to the series with a possible proposal from somebody to someone else thrown in.

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Madeleine wrote: "Karina wrote: "Madeleine wrote: "Ok, but he also doesn't act on the fact he's getting strange dreams about killing his gf. Wouldn't you tell someone of that happened to you?"

I would be scared to ..."

it's hard to express yourself sometimes..
Plus I think there should be a triple wedding:
Simon+Isabelle
Luke+Jocelyn
Clary+Jace

[Karina]

Haha okay well im still on Jaces team :P

Oh Luke ad Joycelyns wedding as the ending i CoHF would be perfect!

[Jon, The Paperback Prince]

Here's another question..
Is the Shadowhunter World becoming too long? Many are saying that MI should have been a trilogy and that the Dark Artifices is stupid..

[Courtney]

Madeleine wrote: "and then he takes the fact that Tessa will marry Jem (worse idea ever btw) and doesn't complain...just accepts it."

Exactly! And that shows how loyal a parabatai he is.

[Madeleine]

Ok, i cant see jocelyn letting clary and jace get married that young. Here where i think:

1. Jace proposes
2. They get married in secret
3. The epilouge is a skip ahead to their wedding

[Courtney]

Don't Shadowhunters get married younger though?