TWILIGHT HATERS discussion

301 views
Twilight: Characters of Shame > Who is worse: Edward or Jacob?

Comments Showing 151-200 of 271 (271 new)    post a comment »

message 151: by [deleted user] (new)

Yeah.what's so good about bella?


*gags *


message 152: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) Or Renesmee, their freaky mutant baby?


message 153: by [deleted user] (new)

HAha


Yeah



Renesmee is stupid




And Bella thinks her sheild power is is helpful


She's a show off



message 154: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) Your slash is on the wrong side of the i.

Yeah, it's a pretty useless thing. Only worked for a minute anyways.


message 155: by [deleted user] (new)

Oh.italisizimg on itouches are complicated



Useless
powers.so helpful




And vampires don't sparkle


message 156: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) :) I know, right?


message 157: by [deleted user] (new)


message 158: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) ROFLMFAO! Awesome!


message 159: by [deleted user] (new)

I know right?


I should put that as meh profile pic


message 160: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) *LOL* You totally should!


message 161: by [deleted user] (new)

that would be hilarious!


message 162: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy stab! stab!!


message 163: by Abby (new)

Abby (toxicsunshine) | 150 comments I don't really like Jacob, but that's because apparently Smeyer said that he doesn't have any flaws... and I just hate characters like that.


message 164: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments of course he has flaws... he was created by SM. thats about as bad as it can get :)


message 165: by Abby (new)

Abby (toxicsunshine) | 150 comments Laura wrote: "of course he has flaws... he was created by SM. thats about as bad as it can get :)"

Well, that's very true. xD But you have to consider the fact that Bella and Edward are the leaders of the Mary-Sure army...


message 166: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments don't get me started on them! it would take me all night at least to list their flaws! :) what do you mean by mary-sure?


message 167: by Nichole. (new)

Nichole. (nicole-50) i dont know but wholey crap!!!! Bellas the wosrt.She sucks major @$$ no joke


message 168: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments tell me about it. i think its disgusting how their whole relationship is based on looks (and smell). what is there that edward sees in bella's personality and vice versa?


message 169: by Nichole. (new)

Nichole. (nicole-50) 1)Shes self/Edward centered
2)shes obbsive
3)She took avantive of jacob
4)Shes a flat charter
5)She is a mentel charcter
6)HELLO her only friends sparkle
7)she wants to harm anamails and have munnet kids


message 170: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments that really explains why edward likes her (my sarcasm hand is raised). no seriously- why do they like each other? anyone...?


message 171: by Nichole. (new)

Nichole. (nicole-50) i have no idea


message 172: by [deleted user] (new)

mmmm they both are idiots and like sparkly guys/clingy unfaithful crazies?


message 173: by Keara (new)

Keara (kearachristine) Mary Sue means that they're plain and they don't develop at all in the story.


message 174: by Nightshade (last edited Apr 25, 2010 09:22PM) (new)

Nightshade | 1257 comments It also means that they're perfect and really clichéd. Like... hang on, I'll explain.

Exhibit A: Isabella Swan
~First symptom of Sue-ness: Her NAME. I mean, really. "Isabella Swan"? I didn't think names could be cliché, but apparently I was wrong.
~Second symptom: All the guys want her, even though she claims to be "plain" and "ugly" and "not pretty at all" and all that crap. But oh, of course ALL the guys just fall at her feet, but oh nooo, she doesn't WANT them.
~Third symptom: Lack of character flaws. Clichéd clumsiness IS NOT A CHARACTER FLAW.

Exhibit B: Edward Cullen
~First symptom: Perfect physical appearance. This is self-explanatory, since Bellaphant goes into rambling detail about every single one of his body parts on every single freaking page. (Wait, that sounded dirty.)
~Second symptom: Perfect personality. He plays piano, is super smart, speaks a million languages, is devoted to Bella, loves her more than anything... it's like Mr. Disgustingly Perfect in character form.
~Third symptom: Lack of character flaws. Blind devotion to a complete moron Bella IS NOT A CHARACTER FLAW. It's just really, really pathetic.


message 175: by [deleted user] (new)

*claps hands* BRAVO BRAVO! XD very nicely put (like the exhibit A and B stuff very nice)


message 176: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments i get it.
nightshade wrote: "Her NAME. I mean, really. "Isabella Swan"? I didn't think names could be cliché, but apparently I was wrong."
her name basically means beautiful swan.
oh, how subtle you are SM (sarcasm hand almost touching the ceiling)


message 177: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments lol. does SM have any strong points?


message 178: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments lol, not in my book. although strong point doesn't have to mean good point... or does it?


message 179: by Abby (new)

Abby (toxicsunshine) | 150 comments Alexa wrote: "Laura wrote: "of course he has flaws... he was created by SM. thats about as bad as it can get :)"

Well, that's very true. xD But you have to consider the fact that Bella and Edward are the lead..."


***Mary-Sue.*** My bad, I accidentally hit the R key. xD


message 180: by Abby (new)

Abby (toxicsunshine) | 150 comments Nightshade wrote: "It also means that they're perfect and really clichéd. Like... hang on, I'll explain.

Exhibit A: Isabella Swan
~First symptom of Sue-ness: Her NAME. I mean, really. "Isabella Swan"? I didn't think..."


Here's another thing: according to Google, a Mary-Sue is usually a character created by amatuer (I don't know if that's spelled right, but oh well xP) fanfiction writers. I mean, with Twilight, she WAS a beginner, but this is not fanfiction. Well, it should be, but it's in book stores, so apparently people don't think of it that way.


message 181: by Nichole. (new)

Nichole. (nicole-50) I read the 4th book after that i tried to claw my eyes out


message 182: by Nightshade (new)

Nightshade | 1257 comments Laura wrote: "i get it.
nightshade wrote: "Her NAME. I mean, really. "Isabella Swan"? I didn't think names could be cliché, but apparently I was wrong."
her name basically means beautiful swan.
oh, how subtle yo..."


Sarcasm hands FOR THE WIN

Yeah, SM is so... subtle. I mean, I TOTALLY DID NOT GET that Bellaphant's stupid name means "beautiful swan." WTH?!


message 183: by [deleted user] (new)

it is so stupid, who does that as a name?? WAY cliche and disgusting


message 184: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments she's such a rubbish writer, she can't even think up names for her characters. the la push peeps are all named after her siblings. sad...


message 185: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy very sad, i mean at least J.K. Rowling makes names that mean something. like Umbridge is close to umbrage which means offense; annoyance; displeasure. and Sirius is a constellation of dog.


message 186: by Nichole. (new)

Nichole. (nicole-50) how lame Jacob Edward come up whith new crap!


message 187: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy smartly is sooo a word! :P i use it all the time!


message 188: by Bobbie (new)

Bobbie Patterson (Bobbie3) | 4 comments Tonya wrote: "I think that if you hate twilight so much then why are you guys all obsessed with writing about it? You guys are dumb, and you KNOW Twilight is better than alll ya'll so thats why you guys 'hate it..."

look Candy Rain No one is going to do anything to that blonde bimbo her name is tonya i bet she is way smarter then you retards, she is my sister. Dont talk crap about her. You guys are sp obsessed with edward its so dumb. and he is just not a character. You wanna talk crap then talk it to me leave her alone you immature people. now drop it!


message 189: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments you really put a dampener on the conversation, Bobbie. anyway...
did you know Dumbledore is old english for bumble bee?


message 190: by Jamine Isabel E. Uy, The creative makes-awesome-stuff-for-us one (new)

Jamine Isabel E. Uy (candy-rain) | 3069 comments Mod
Bobbie wrote: "Tonya wrote: "I think that if you hate twilight so much then why are you guys all obsessed with writing about it? You guys are dumb, and you KNOW Twilight is better than alll ya'll so thats why you..."

You're the immature one, Bobbie. What? Your sis can't argue back? Have you even seen how she typed shit?

And yes, DEADWARD is just a character. (By the way, it's supposed to say, "he is not just a character". Apparently, you're as much of a bimbo as your sister)

Way smarter than us? HAHAHAHA OMG, oh yeah? What course does she do? In fact... what course are YOU doing?

Does she know that Edward is not real? Hmm lemme see, NOPE! Does she make sense? Hmmm NOPE! Does she talk like a bimbo like you?

Hmm.. YES!

Finally! Something I can say YES to!

By the way, tell your sister to stop moping around her emo corner and answer back without crying to her sister for help. Oh, and for your information... I can't pretty much 'look' at anything except how you and your sister are mentally related...

It's not a compliment by the way.


message 191: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments i see a way too protective sister here...
if Tonya's gonna write stuff like that in the TWILIGHT HATERS group then let her take the comments she gets back. what does she expect if she writes that kind of stuff?


message 192: by Tonya (new)

Tonya (tonyalynn38) ~*~ Candy-Rain ~*~ wrote: "Bobbie wrote: "Tonya wrote: "I think that if you hate twilight so much then why are you guys all obsessed with writing about it? You guys are dumb, and you KNOW Twilight is better than alll ya'll s..."

Guess what!!!! I'm back!!!! =) ohh and I never sent Bobbie out to do this its called being a good sister!I never said EDWARD is real, have an imagination, and there is a movie to go off of(bet you've seen it too). From what I see you guys are all obbessed with talking about something related to Twilight. So go suck one! Ohh and yeahh I'm sooooooo emo you can see that huh?


message 193: by Tessa (new)

Tessa (tessa3) | 5 comments okay,for yall stupid ass people, YES EDWARD
is just a made up character! Hmmm he's Hot! i think, and for the blonde bimbo i got your back! The Gook candy rain is about a dumb ass!

HAHAHAHA Agreee??!!!LMAO!


Your the one having a big ass deal about EDWARD being real or not stupid ass!






I really think girls like you should grow up !
how Old are you?

your not obsessed with Twilight ?! haha your in denial!! because you ARE!!!



And for bobbie GOOD JOB FOR having your sisters back!!:P


message 194: by Bobbie (new)

Bobbie Patterson (Bobbie3) | 4 comments Bobbie wrote: "Tonya wrote: "I think that if you hate twilight so much then why are you guys all obsessed with writing about it? You guys are dumb, and you KNOW Twilight is better than alll ya'll so thats why you..."

You're the immature one, Bobbie. What? Your sis can't argue back? Have you even seen how she typed shit?

And yes, DEADWARD is just a character. (By the way, it's supposed to say, "he is not just a character". Apparently, you're as much of a bimbo as your sister)

Way smarter than us? HAHAHAHA OMG, oh yeah? What course does she do? In fact... what course are YOU doing?

Does she know that Edward is not real? Hmm lemme see, NOPE! Does she make sense? Hmmm NOPE! Does she talk like a bimbo like you?

Hmm.. YES!

Finally! Something I can say YES to!

By the way, tell your sister to stop moping around her emo corner and answer back without crying to her sister for help. Oh, and for your information... I can't pretty much 'look' at anything except how you and your sister are mentally related...

It's not a compliment by the way.


how and the heck are we immature your the one sitting here talking crap to my sister and starting crap about her. if you mess with my sister your messing with me. okay! and my sister is not emo she looks pretty normal to me unlike you. And Tonya dont mope around she says things that counts unlike you. and i know me and my sister are the prettiest little things. And were mental haha your mental. I bet were way better then you. At least she has freinds and a sister that will back her up now shut the F*** UP!


message 195: by Tonya (new)

Tonya (tonyalynn38) Tessa wrote: "okay,for yall stupid ass people, YES EDWARD
is just a made up character! Hmmm he's Hot! i think, and for the blonde bimbo i got your back! The Gook candy rain is about a dumb ass!

HAHAHAHA Agr..."


HAHAHA AGREED!! =)


message 196: by Bobbie (new)

Bobbie Patterson (Bobbie3) | 4 comments ME AND TESSA HAVE HER BACK DONT MESS WITH HER!


message 197: by Laura (new)

Laura | 170 comments does anyone else find it hard to know what she's on about? and yes i have seen the film- 'its called being a good friend'. fyi, i laughed out loud when edward proposed in new moon.


message 198: by Tonya (new)

Tonya (tonyalynn38) You make less sence than anyone here


message 199: by Tessa (new)

Tessa (tessa3) | 5 comments HMHM.. no one cares what you did !!


message 200: by Bobbie (new)

Bobbie Patterson (Bobbie3) | 4 comments What the hell are you talking about! U dont have any clue what is going on and for one i was talking about the girl taht loks manly ew. not you


back to top