New Moon
discussion
How many of you have read the twighlight books?
date
newest »

message 101:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Dec 12, 2011 11:57AM
i read them all becuase i got them for my 13th biirthday and since then i enjoyed it
reply
|
flag



@ ElectrikREd - Jacob ain't a stalker she did have feeling 4 Jacob and if there was more time before Edward came back she might have given her heart to Jacob in New Moon. Yous saw how much she cried after the fight in Eclipse when they both resolved that she was going to marry Edward it scared Edward too all those tears she cried for Jake.



Books and film are different mediums so there are good points and bad to each: the films do action better - I don't feel writing 'action' scenes is one of Meyer's strong points and so those sequences are better in the films... For the books you get a better feel for the tension and friction of the relationships so I esp. like the initial development between Bella and Edward in Twilight - the additional scenes with them that are cut from the film give you more time to appreciate them getting together. Also - there is more character development for other Cullens etc. in the books, which you would probably like if you like those characters.
Just like other book to film conversions - such as the H Potter franchise, Lord of the Rings, etc. - take each one as a separate thing and look for the positives in each rather than comparing them like for like.
:)

Twilight loved it, knew what was happening because I watched the movie.
I read Twilight a few times, didn't take me long to read Twilight and New Moon lol
Loved reading Eclipse :D the fighting scene was amazing in the book & on screen :-)
Knew what was happening when I was reading the book because as before I'd seen Eclipse at the movies also because it was real vivid.

Haven't seen the movies, I'm afraid they aren't as good as the books and I will end up feeling upset. Edward looks ugly. :(

Damn, that's a ton of reading. All 4 books were large books.

You should get your hands on them, not only will it help you understand parts of the movies bette..."
Lol, when I read them I couldn't put the books down! Sometimes I stayed up till 2 or 3 in the morining reading them.



Skipped the fillers and really had a nice time. Only saw the first movie and realized I liked my version better!!!

The part about Jasper? That's was my daughter's favorite part. I'm waiting till I finish all of them to decide which one I like best.



http://divaliciouzbookreviews.blogspot.c...
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic