What will Jason do about Reyna and Piper?

[Savannah]

that was funny.

[[deleted user]]

Well I totally understand y Hera did what she did.

[[deleted user]]

Izzy99 wrote: "Jason might be confused with the Reyna Piper situation, don't ya' think?"

Poor Jason. Who'd u think he'll choose, Izzy?

[[deleted user]]

Isabelle *the face behind the crazy* wrote: "But we have the Demigod Diares! =D I'm so excited!"

Yeah....I hope its not a huge disappointment.

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

How could it be?

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

Asmaa wrote: "Izzy99 wrote: "Jason might be confused with the Reyna Piper situation, don't ya' think?"

Poor Jason. Who'd u think he'll choose, Izzy?"

I think that he'll shake his head and say, "Wait till I get my memory back,"

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Lol I'd like to see Reynas and Pipers reaction to that =P

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

Isabelle *the face behind the crazy* wrote: "Lol I'd like to see Reynas and Pipers reaction to that =P"

I think Piper might understand, just not Reyna, because she might think that if Percy has his memory back, Jason must have his back. She might be confused, because he doesn't! :-P

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

She'd probably slap him silly XD

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

Oh yeah! Go Reyna! Poor Jason.

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

Then Piper would slap Reyna. XD

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Ouch, I can just see that happening
*stares off into the distance*
Yeah that looks painful

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

XD! ROTFL!

[[deleted user]]

He'll probably take a while to decide...

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

Yeah,....

[MOVED - CHECK BIO]

With his memory lost and all........

[Savannah]

haha :) well I'm betting he has his memory back by now... it's been a couple of months

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

But he also has new memories too which makes it even harder for him, this dude can not get a break XD

[Savannah]

Yeah, poor guy. And they all came back slowly, unlike percy.

[Savannah]

:( sigh. such a tragedy. I do hope RR doesn't make this too horribly sad. ;)

[[deleted user]]

yeah, same here, but it is a children's book it prob. wont be tooooo depressing XD

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Actually it isn't now, I checked, it's teens now, RR raising the bar

[[deleted user]]

Ah I suppose that's y it has more romance. Maybe ts cuz he knows his original PJO readers must have grown up and r now teens or in their twenties even.

[Savannah]

Asmaa wrote: "yeah, same here, but it is a children's book it prob. wont be tooooo depressing XD"

probably.......... and even with teens.

[Savannah]

Asmaa wrote: "Ah I suppose that's y it has more romance. Maybe ts cuz he knows his original PJO readers must have grown up and r now teens or in their twenties even."

ya probably.

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Yeah, because seriously everyone is a freakin' couple, lol except Leo even though he's awesome XD

[-Athina-]

well....what about Hazel and Leo then ? RR is making it real complicated !!

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Well we don't know about him and Hazel yet, for now it's only Frank and Hazel but later on... u never know...

[[deleted user]]

Athina wrote: "well....what about Hazel and Leo then ? RR is making it real complicated !!"

i dont think thats gonna end up as anything anytime soon. only if frank dies.

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Yeah maybe just some confusing stuff for Hazel but I dunno

[Rhea]

For me, Jason should pick Reyna. I'm going to post here what I posted in the other group to express my opinion.

STARTS HERE:
Well... while reading The Lost Hero, I was analyzing the character development of each character and I have to say that I was a bit disappointed with Piper's. Sure, there was also something wrong with Leo and Jason but I kind of focused on Piper because she's the one that I'm trying hard to like the most because at first she seemed a decent one. I mean she's so pretty, nice and all those other characteristics that would make you want to tell that that person is perfect but I just kind of didn't 'feel' her character.

So when they were on the quest, I really tried liking her and observing her development and I'm not happy to say that she didn't (in my opinion) developed that much.

Personally, I think the flaws of a person makes that character more real. For example: Drew. She is mean, a flirt and a bully but don't we all have people like her in our lives? Then there's Octavian. He's more of like the antagonist but don't we all have a person like him that we encounter? There's also Rachel coming in between Percy and Annabeth. Then, there's Annabeth's pride and jealousy of Rachel (in the earlier books). But that's what makes them unique.

It's just that with Piper, I can't seem to find anything like those. Sure, her dad ignores her, she hates make-up and is like a tomboy, she gets kicked-out of school and is bullied by Drew, but what is her own flaw that makes her a 3D character?

I was just wondering. I don't mean to offend anyone. Plus, (for me only) she seems to be a bit clingy to Jason and I kind of don't like how she can suddenly 'charm speak' Jason to wake up without practicing with it at all. (For me) It's bad enough that she's overwhelmingly pretty and a bad-ass at the same time but making her have all those 'neat' powers without practicing in camp makes it a bit worse.

I mean I would love and adore her if I read the book when I'm around 9 or 10 but now that I'm five months away from being thirteen, I just can't can't seem to have a fandom of her. She's just flat, in my opinion.
I can't find anything else to make her realistic.

She's a bit too perfect, for me. And judging just from the Lightning Thief, her character is cheap and flat compared to Annabeth's, Percy's and Grover's. I'm sorry I had to write it but I'm merely expressing my own opinion.

Reyna, on the other hand, has things to make her interesting. Yes, she is strict, stiff and somewhat cold to others but that's what makes her mysterious and makes me want to see what's behind all that. She's strong but has a reason to be strong. She had a bad past and is willing to protect her home. She acts like she doesn't care but is willing to give things up for the legion. She's more of the type that I would want to read more about. It just makes me curious. She acts for her people and not only for her sake. It makes her somewhat like Annabeth, Rachel and Thalia: 3D characters.

If you're wondering why I'd say Rachel is a 3d character, I have several reasons:
1. She has a dad she doesn't like because of what he does, yet is willing to face his conditions for her friends.
2. Just as what Percy said, she's brave like Annabeth, only in another way.
3. She wasn't exactly described much physically but rather how she acts which makes me like her. It's more of about liking her because of all the dialogues and movement but not because of what other people think about her.
4. Despite the two stated above, she has flaws that makes her more realistic.

Same goes with Thalia and Annabeth.

Anyway, Piper is ok (even though for me, she's a flat character), and I'm interested in Reyna's character. I'd pick Reyna over Piper.

Reyna is the leader who's more like willing to make herself look bad for the sake of all. She's like willing to sacrifice her wants to satisfy others. It's just my opinion.

And if I was asked to pick who is better off with Jason, then it's Reyna for me.

Yes, they may not have been a couple but they may want to be. Besides, if Reyna is worried about Jason and is glad to have him back, there must have been more that a simple crush there to the point that she's willing to delay the elections.

Besides, we only heard it from Reyna's view. Who knows, Jason may have planned for them to be closer since his feelings may have been strong?

ENDS HERE:


Besides, I doubt that after staying in Camp Jupiter for a few years, nothing made Jason's feelings strong for Reyna. Also, it's not like there's no hope for the two of them. Surely, they have a history and if I were Rick Riordan, I'd start there relationship from there. I just don't think Jason and Piper would be a good couple. They are just too alike. For me, it's like "perfect boy" and "perfect girl".

This is also why I'd pick Piper with Leo.

Anyway, I'd pick Jason/Reyna, and if it becomes Jason/Piper in the book, then I also have no objection. After all, I don't read the series for the sake of romance. I read it because of its substance.

Thanks!

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Dude u r seriously good

[Lily]

Mercedes wrote: "For me, Jason should pick Reyna. I'm going to post here what I posted in the other group to express my opinion.

STARTS HERE:
Well... while reading The Lost Hero, I was analyzing the character ..."

I completely agree with you, I just couldn't relate to Piper as much as I could with Annabeth, Thalia, Reyna, and Rachel. I had something in common with each of them, and I loved them because of their flaws. They all made mistakes, for example, Annabeth wanted to hear the Sirens, but those mistakes made me love them more. Piper was just, there.

[Rhea]

Lily wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "For me, Jason should pick Reyna. I'm going to post here what I posted in the other group to express my opinion.

STARTS HERE:
Well... while reading The Lost Hero, I was analyzi..."

Annabeth wanting to hear the Sirens made her even more real for me. =))) I agree with you. I guess it's kind of because I can sort-of relate to them but not at all with Piper since I'm not exactly the "beauty-queen" pretty type and very rich.

[Lily]

Mercedes wrote: "Lily wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "For me, Jason should pick Reyna. I'm going to post here what I posted in the other group to express my opinion.

STARTS HERE:
Well... while reading The Lost Hero, ..."

I agree, in my opinion Piper thought her life was awful, even though it wasn't bad in demigod standards. Her father did love her, and tried to make her happy even though he wasn't that great at it. I mean look at Annabeth's life or Thalia's life vs. Piper's, whose life is worse?

[Rhea]

Lily wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "Lily wrote: "Mercedes wrote: "For me, Jason should pick Reyna. I'm going to post here what I posted in the other group to express my opinion.

STARTS HERE:
Well... while readin..."

I agree with you. I mean, compared to others, she already has a great life. Personally, I think that Rick Riordan made her somewhat a 'Mary Sue' that is cleverly hidden by her history. Sorry, it's just an opinion, again.

[Binali]

guys jason and reyena r probably going to end up togehter i mean if they had history that is. if they didnt that okay then he will probably end up with piper

Think of it this way
reyena is to jason as annabeth is to percy so jason chooseing piper is like percy at the roman camp choosing some random venus girl and if that happpened we would totally bash percy so y should jason be allowed to get another girl

[[deleted user]]

Yeah but y would the author spend so much time building a relationship between Piper and Jason?

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Maybe to add a bigger blow and more twist?

[Savannah]

Binali wrote: "guys jason and reyena r probably going to end up togehter i mean if they had history that is. if they didnt that okay then he will probably end up with piper

Think of it this way
reyena is to ja..."


ohhhh i like that!!!! :) oh i don't know!!! I will be happy with whoever jason chooses...

[Savannah]

Isabelle *the face behind the crazy* wrote: "Maybe to add a bigger blow and more twist?"

makes sense..... sigh... i'm just sooooo impatient! grrrrr

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Me too!!! I hate cliffes!!!!! And yeah I think both characters have their strengths and weaknesses which is why I'd like either of them with Jason

[Savannah]

I know!!!!! :) exactly

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

:) Lol Team Piper or Team Reyna, reverse Twilight except with demigods and such, uh oh XD

[Rhea]

Isabelle *the face behind the crazy* wrote: ":) Lol Team Piper or Team Reyna, reverse Twilight except with demigods and such, uh oh XD"

=)))) I was a bit shocked when I found out that people actually have Team Piper and Team Reyna =]

[H.P123]

Team Piper and Peeta !!!!!

[Sparkle55]

Yaaaa!

[H.P123]

Team Peeta all the way!!!!

[Sparkle55]

Yes!

[Isabelle *the face behind the crazy*, The Mark of Athena :3... I can destroy the world YAYYY!!!!- O_O]

Mercedes wrote: "Isabelle *the face behind the crazy* wrote: ":) Lol Team Piper or Team Reyna, reverse Twilight except with demigods and such, uh oh XD"

=)))) I was a bit shocked when I found out that people actu..."

Ikr? Me too but I guess every book has a teams
Authors <3 love triangles XD