The Son of Neptune (The Heroes of Olympus, #2) The Son of Neptune discussion


1467 views
Piper or Reyna ? Who should Jason choose?

Comments Showing 1,451-1,496 of 1,496 (1496 new)    post a comment »
1 2 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 30 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1451: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker But HISTORY doesn't mean ROMANCE. If you lost your memory, woke up next to a cute person, fell in love, and then remembered someone from your past who you were NOT romantically involved with, why should you like them now? Should having his memory wiped have made him fall in love with Reyna? No! If he never liked her, he shouldn't have to date her.


Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~ Rogers/America Dria wrote: "But HISTORY doesn't mean ROMANCE. If you lost your memory, woke up next to a cute person, fell in love, and then remembered someone from your past who you were NOT romantically involved with, why s..."

True! Piper said she wanted to make real memories with him in the lost hero


message 1453: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Harrypotterginger~todiewouldbeanawefullybigadventure~ wrote: "Dria wrote: "But HISTORY doesn't mean ROMANCE. If you lost your memory, woke up next to a cute person, fell in love, and then remembered someone from your past who you were NOT romantically involve..."

No,they were FRIENDS who were EXPECTED to EVENTUALLY fall in love. Jason wasn't in love.


message 1454: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Tana~ wrote: "Dria wrote: "But HISTORY doesn't mean ROMANCE. If you lost your memory, woke up next to a cute person, fell in love, and then remembered someone from your past who you were NOT romantically involve..."

Yeah, and she did. In the months it took to build the ArgoII, time enough for Jason to develop an attachment to CHB among other things, they had real memories together and it worked out. He likes her! Why would anyone want to force him to be with Reyna?


message 1455: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker They were but they did what?


message 1456: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Why?


message 1457: by Lauren (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lauren Obviously he should choose piper even though she is annoying


message 1458: by Vansh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vansh Arora Reyna, Definitely Reyna. Frankly because I can picture Jason with Reyna, i mean both are emotionally and physically strong and piper is well, neither. plus they are leaders at their camp and have quite a lot of history together.
And piper is so infuriatingly stupid.


message 1459: by Brooke (new) - rated it 3 stars

Brooke L NICO!


message 1460: by Vansh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vansh Arora Dria wrote: "But also I just really wanted to quote Hagrid for no reason."

uh what was that?


message 1461: by Magnus (last edited Jun 24, 2014 10:39AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Magnus  Ludwig Piper clings to Jason, like a dog to the bone :) And Reyna could knock out all the arrogance, but Reyna and Jason - it's very bad!

P.S Leo forever!!!


message 1462: by Jesten (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jesten Everyone bashes piper. She's not a bad character really. She's just not had as hard a life to shape her into the hero until recently. Everyone but her and Leo had prior hero experience. But Leo had more hardships which fueled his growth.


message 1463: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Vansh wrote: "Dria wrote: "But also I just really wanted to quote Hagrid for no reason."

uh what was that?"


Okay, awfullybigadventure girl deleted all her comments... so... awkward...


message 1464: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Alexander wrote: "Piper clings to Jason, like a dog to the bone :) And Reina could knock out all the arrogance, but Reina and Jason - it's very bad!

P.S Leo forever!!!"


Dude, it's REYNA.


message 1465: by Vansh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vansh Arora Dria wrote: "Vansh wrote: "Dria wrote: "But also I just really wanted to quote Hagrid for no reason."

uh what was that?"

Okay, awfullybigadventure girl deleted all her comments... so... awkward..."


lol


message 1466: by Magnus (last edited Jun 24, 2014 10:41AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Magnus  Ludwig Dria wrote: "Alexander wrote: "Piper clings to Jason, like a dog to the bone :) And Reina could knock out all the arrogance, but Reina and Jason - it's very bad!

P.S Leo forever!!!"

Dude, it's REYNA."


It bothers you that much? I don't care how to write her name. Reyna or Reina - same thing:)

P.S Corrected for you^


Magnus  Ludwig And who does not know the names of the characters? Funny actually :)


message 1468: by Parker (last edited Jun 25, 2014 10:24AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Are you using google translate or something? Your sentences are phrased... unusually.


Magnus  Ludwig Yeah... I use a tourist phrasebook:)


message 1470: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker Okay. :D


message 1471: by Vansh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vansh Arora @ Alexander wow you must really like this discussion.


message 1472: by Fangirl (new)

Fangirl I ship Jasper. I feel as if Reyna is very independent and I don't know, I imagine her as more of a hunter of artemis. I can't really picture her with anyone lol


message 1473: by Fangirl (new)

Fangirl Although Piper and Jason's relationship WAS unreal at first, they still along the way, fell for each other. I also think that Reyna and Piper would actually made really good friends. I think Rick Riordian is going to keep Piper and Jason together though and I think that he also imagines reyna as a more independent person. And also, piper is NOT AT ALL selfish! She JUST discovered she was a demigod so why is everyone expecting her to do AMAZING things? She's new to the whole concept, so cut her some slack. Also, Why does everyone in the book HAVE to be shipped with someone? Like with Thalia, every one always shipped her and luke(people still do) but she decided she didn't need a guy and I think Reyna is very much like her. I honestly believe Reyna being a hunter would be SO cool and I can totally see it happening. Anyways, Blood Of Olympus is definitely going to answer some unanswered questions which will be interesting. I'll probably cry if Rick kills any character but I'd cry the hardest for Leo. The only certain ship as of right now is Percabeth. Some people ship Lazel but I think that Frazel will be the ship to live on. I hope Caleo can also happen. The biggest uncertainty is Jasper/ Jeyna. I don't want to disappoint any Jeyna shippers, but we can all agree, that in the end, Jasper will most likely be the one to remain.


message 1474: by Fangirl (new)

Fangirl HOLD UP HOLD UP HOLD UP. Some of you are shipping Jeyna ONLY because you are already shipping Peo and Piper can't be with two guys? I am honestly laughing. May I remind you Aphrodite and Hephaestus are MARRIED?! that makes Leo Piper's half brother. Even if they weren't related, I still think piper and leo have more of a sibling relationship. SO WITH THAT BEING SAID, GO CALEO!


message 1475: by Parker (new) - rated it 5 stars

Parker ha ha ha Peo


message 1476: by Vansh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Vansh Arora Fangirl wrote: "HOLD UP HOLD UP HOLD UP. Some of you are shipping Jeyna ONLY because you are already shipping Peo and Piper can't be with two guys? I am honestly laughing. May I remind you Aphrodite and Hephaestus..."

Wow that was detailed. o_0


message 1477: by [deleted user] (new)

I think he should chose Piper.


BriboSwaggins :) Piper. Choose. Piper. Jason. PIPER!


message 1479: by Yara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Yara There is no love triangle, for the past 4 books it was Piper and it will always BE Piper, Jason already made his chose, plus he never really was Reyna's boyfriend, he could have been but he wasn't. He knew Reyna was back home and he still chose to date Piper.


message 1480: by Briana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Briana I love Piper, I would be so sad if Jason didn't chose her.


message 1481: by Sami777 (new) - rated it 4 stars

Sami777 Reyna. I really don't like Piper all that much.


message 1482: by Alicia (new) - added it

Alicia Reyna because she is stronger then Piper in more ways than one. But wait I actually don't like Jason very much either so....


message 1483: by Chaya (new) - rated it 3 stars

Chaya Ummm... Piper? Like uh...


Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~ Rogers/America We'll i do like Piper as a character and don't hate her but sometimes it bothers me when she keeps comparing Percy and Jason and it's kinda like " Oh the world is ending!" and Piper is just worried that Jason isn't paying attention to her! But from other characters POV she seems like a good character but sometimes I get bored reading her chapters


message 1485: by Allison (new) - rated it 5 stars

Allison BRICK. HE SHOULD CHOOSE BRICK IF ANYBODY.

True love<3 :D


message 1486: by Eric (new) - rated it 5 stars

Eric Boot Definately Piper. In my opinion Reyna is a arrogant bitch, but not all of you'll agree:D I just dont like her, sorry for that...


message 1487: by Chaya (new) - rated it 3 stars

Chaya Eric wrote: "Definately Piper. In my opinion Reyna is a arrogant bitch, but not all of you'll agree:D I just dont like her, sorry for that..."

I like reyna, but piper is better for jason.


message 1488: by Briana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Briana I think Piper is perfect for Jason I don't really like Reyna for Jason.


message 1489: by Christina (new)

Christina I agree with Kimberly. Piper is the most annoying, immature character in the entire series. Definitely Reyna for this.


message 1490: by [deleted user] (new)

Uk if Rico hadn't annoyingly put Jason and Piper together at the very beginning then Reyna.


message 1491: by Kayz (new)

Kayz REYNA ALL THE WAY!!!
To be honest, I actually liked Piper in the Lost Hero, but later on, I was kind of annoyed by Piper, and when I read Lost Hero again... uh!
When I was beginning to read more and more about Reyna, I was slowly gravitating to her. Reyna is so badass, mature and very level-headed. I like her character very much. To be honest, she deserves to be one of the Seven. :)


message 1492: by [deleted user] (new)

ȘᎯɱᎯɴτħᎯ (ȘħᎯɖΘώħƲɴτεર) νετᎯιίᎯ ;) wrote: "Piper duh, I love Reyna, but I would always imagine her as a huntress of Artemis."

i sooo agree with u


message 1493: by [deleted user] (new)

Hmm.. tough question. Okay… ermm… please don't kill me, Reyna.


Piperandjasonforlife piper. totally piper. piper knows jason better than reyna does. jason likes piper. jason does not like reyna in that way. reyna needs to back off before i make her back off. reyna makes me very angry. i dont like it when she gets in the way. it ticks me off. piper and jason for life. no dout.


Piperandjasonforlife and also jason already picks pipper and he told reyna to back off so....


message 1496: by Briana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Briana Obviously Piper, he cares a lot for her so there is no way he would ever choose Reyna over Piper.


1 2 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 30 next »
back to top