Harry Potter discussion
Questions
>
ANYTHING YOU WOULD LIKE 2 CHANGE IN ANY OF THE HP BOOKS.
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Annalisa
(last edited Dec 07, 2008 09:36PM)
(new)
Dec 07, 2008 08:34PM
I assumed you misspelled Snape :).
reply
|
flag
Prajit wrote: "yes... the last book should be more epic instead of running around like hobos"The last is the best!
yeah...... like, most of the adventure came near the end.I would make it longer with more adventure.
I would not kill fred, tonks, and hedwig they shouldn't of died
Prajit wrote: "yes... the last book should be more epic instead of running around like hobos"
Exactly! The camping thing took over like 9/10 of the book and so at the end with the big scene, it was like oh harry killed him, the end!!
Exactly! The camping thing took over like 9/10 of the book and so at the end with the big scene, it was like oh harry killed him, the end!!
Emma wrote: "yeah...... like, most of the adventure came near the end.I would make it longer with more adventure."
Read my comment to Prajit. I totally agree!
Read my comment to Prajit. I totally agree!
but they have to kill SOME main characters!! otherwise it would be kind of plain.. though i think killing tonks and lupin was not needed..
I agree with MK about J.K.R re-explaining everything.LOL, I like in OOTP when Neville comes out screaming "STUBEFY! STUBEFY! STUBEFY!"
XD
same but other then that, shame on u people for wanting to change the best series in the world!!!
1. Harry'd fall for the girl who was always by his side unconditionally instead of going for a fangirl. (Come on, he always hated his fame.)2. Make the books after book 4 more action-driven. OK, it would have been hard to beat the excitement of the Triwizard Tournament anyway, but please... Voldy is back and then almost nothing happened. Instead of action, the Ministry is all in denial, Harry gets zero information (hello, he's the one who Voldy wants to kill, does he not deserve all info to protect himself?) and we're forced to read about a character even more despicable than Voldy (*hem hem*) or about boring romance (hey Harry, didn't Arthur tell you in book 4 to not judge a book by the cover? Yet your romances are all about good looks and not about the inside.) Sorry, but I can't help wondering what the last three books might have been like without the three year gap between book 4 and 5 due to the start of the film series.
