Hello again! Theres always been an on-going question about whether or not the Harry Potter films are as good as the books. What do you think?

[Gabby]

Of course the book is better than the movie.
That's how it always is. I will give major props to hte director though. Let's face it, Harry Potter is a huge book with a good amount of internal things going on that would not be very easy to portay in a movie with only pictures and actors. I think the producers and director and everyone else did great on these movies, but to measure up to the book it would have to be a four and a half hour movie and no one would want to sit through that.

[Meeeriams]

I think you cannot truly love and understand the movies unless you have read and understood the books.

[Shay]

Books by far, but I tend to favor books more than the films anyway, lol.