Books on the Nightstand discussion
What do you want us to talk/write about?
message 301:
by
Carol
(new)
Mar 09, 2011 05:39AM

reply
|
flag

I remember being shocked the first time I read Lauren Winner's memoir "Girl Meets God" where she talks about how her priest suggested she give up books for Lent. She did, and writes about the experience. Lauren is quite bookish and it was difficult 6 weeks.
I know I could not survive such an experience, but reading her account challenged me one year to give up FICTION for Lent. I felt that I was spending too much time disconnected from the real world and using fiction as an escape drug. (Granted there are worse substances to abuse.) It turned out to be a worthwhile project. During those 6 weeks I explored other genres that I would not have picked up had fiction been available. Since then, I've done a better job of incorporating non-fiction into my reading plan and feel I'm connected to both the real and fictional worlds.
This morning a goodreads member mentioned a solution to my uncomfortableness with the star ratings. She suggested that I not rate my comments. This got me thinking. It might be a solution but I wonder if members of this forum would bother to read the comments. If a book you are planning to read has a one or two star rating, do you read it? Do you read the comments? make your own decisions. I thought this might make an interesting topic. How much to you rely on comments on goodreads, booksonthenightstand or professional reviewers to guide your reading choices?

I am curious what others thing, but I rarely rely on the reviews or ratings when selecting books. I would, however, be very likely to take into account a friend or colleague's direct recommendation.

Good to know and thanks for commenting. I am truly interested.
I do watch what my goodreads friends are reading and have picked up some great books from their suggestions. I love listening to BOTN and find more to add to my shelves from this and the group. I browse many review sources, read blogs, etc. I work in a library and purchase adult materials so am always looking for good material. I'm bound to find some for myself along the way :)!
I do watch what my goodreads friends are reading and have picked up some great books from their suggestions. I love listening to BOTN and find more to add to my shelves from this and the group. I browse many review sources, read blogs, etc. I work in a library and purchase adult materials so am always looking for good material. I'm bound to find some for myself along the way :)!

I notice the "law of large numbers" has a great effect on what a book is rated when you call it up. Look at books - when more than 500 people have rated it, unless it is a fantastic or terrible read, it's rating is always somewhere in the "3"s. I think the best way to decide what books to read is to find those who have smiliar taste and ponder to their thoughts when choosing.
I can also say some of the best books I've read were totally by accident.
Leah Wrote: I think the best way to decide what books to read is to find those who have smiliar taste and ponder to their thoughts when choosing.
I can also say some of the best books I've read were totally by accident.
I think you've hit the nail on the head. Rather than worry about the stars, considert the books by friends you trust, and go with your own feelings.
I do enjoy comparing books when I come across a review on goodreads that I like. Interestingly you and I have enjoyed 6 of the same books. Of your favorites I loved Art of Racing in the Rain but absolutely did not like Pet Semetery, though I'm a big King fan :)! I'll explore the rest of your list.
And yes, those books you pick up by accident can be some of the best!
I can also say some of the best books I've read were totally by accident.
I think you've hit the nail on the head. Rather than worry about the stars, considert the books by friends you trust, and go with your own feelings.
I do enjoy comparing books when I come across a review on goodreads that I like. Interestingly you and I have enjoyed 6 of the same books. Of your favorites I loved Art of Racing in the Rain but absolutely did not like Pet Semetery, though I'm a big King fan :)! I'll explore the rest of your list.
And yes, those books you pick up by accident can be some of the best!

Specifically, I recently read an e-book (from one of the retreat authors), and the author's name and the book name were randomly placed in the middle of sentences in the middle of the book, where they obviously didn't belong.
I don't have the exact sentence with me, but I think it was along the lines of, "She felt a hard *author name* slap across her face," or something along those lines.


I agree. Ann did a great job. It doesn't get any better than interviewing Ian McEwan!!


Try "Guys Can Read." They get better with every episode.
Also, Guardian Books podcast, New York Times Book Review, BBC Book of the Month, The Next Chapter from CBC, Writers and Company from CBC.

Besides BOTNS and NYT Book Review, my regular listening includes the Kindle Chronicles which is not strictly about books but rather a fascinating and extremely well done podcast about the e-publishing industry. Len Edgerly often mentions a terrific book or two and I like his recommendations, that's why I mention it here--especially for you Kindle lovers! Another favorite is Book Lust with Nancy Pearl, the Seattle librarian who published several "Book Lust" books. She interviews an interesting mix of authors.
I always look forward to my daily exercise because that's when I plug in my white earpods and listen up.



I had wondered if they were going in the first place- maybe we'll go to Toronto next time? :)

PS I like structure of some kind in my podcast not a laugh a thon or drink a thon.


To me, the only downside is the sound quality, but since I listen to a lot of AM radio, it doesn't bother me too much! Definitely makes you appreciate the sound quality of BotNS, which has definitely improved over time!



Looking forward to the next podcast as always...
Kbrown wrote: "I know BOTNS has covered prize-winning books before but I always enjoy hearing whether Anne's and Michael's opinions of these books are in synch with the literary panels/committees who choose them...."
I haven't read this one yet, but my book club is reading it in June -- I was lucky enough to win a book club call-in from Ms Egan for this book so we shuffled our schedule to accommodate!
I haven't read this one yet, but my book club is reading it in June -- I was lucky enough to win a book club call-in from Ms Egan for this book so we shuffled our schedule to accommodate!

You are going to have a book chat with a Pulitzer Prize-winning author! Wow!!
After you've read "Goon Squad" you should check out The Morning News' Tournament of Books competition bracket for 2011 (an NCAA basketball type bracket but with BOOKS).You can access this by visiting their website at themorningnews.org/tob/. Egan's book makes it to the final round and each time it's evaluated by a reviewer judging their specific match-up they provide further insight into the novel. I look forward to this tournament every year. Hope you feel the recommendation worthwhile! I was directed to their website by Anne and Michael at BOTNS. Yet another of their recommendations that continues to enrich my reading experience!
Hopefully we'll hear about your book club's experience with the author chat. Have fun!

This article presents an interesting concept for readers. Might make a good discussion topic.

This article presents an interesting concept for r..."
Great article Cindy...thanks for sharing!

the following.If a book has two authors listed like this
one

Gerald wrote: "I thought it might be a good idea for BOTNS to discuss
the following.If a book has two authors listed like this
one
what does the second listed author do? I mean..."
I think that James Patterson has become the Thomas Kincaid of authors. He "interns" other writers, giving them a formula, they write it and then puts his name on the book so it will sell.
the following.If a book has two authors listed like this
one

I think that James Patterson has become the Thomas Kincaid of authors. He "interns" other writers, giving them a formula, they write it and then puts his name on the book so it will sell.

I keep hearing how little translated fiction Americans generally read, and was wondering, if you could do a couple of theme episodes about translated fiction.
Like great French/European/Icelandic/Asian/Brasillian authors, that have been translated into English. Or great foreign love stories/crime novels etc.
Just an idea :-)
Thanks for a great podcast
Louise
Louise wrote: "Hi
I keep hearing how little translated fiction Americans generally read, and was wondering, if you could do a couple of theme episodes about translated fiction.
Like great French/European/Icela..."
Ooh yes please!
I keep hearing how little translated fiction Americans generally read, and was wondering, if you could do a couple of theme episodes about translated fiction.
Like great French/European/Icela..."
Ooh yes please!

I keep hearing how little translated fiction Americans generally read, and was wondering, if you could do a couple of theme episodes about translated fiction.
Like great French/European/Icela..."
I agree. This would be a great topic.


Chris wrote: "This may be a bit on the morbid side, but I thought of this thread when I was driving in this morning, listening to a wonderful interview with Reynolds Price, who recently passed away. How about to..."
Not morbid! A good idea.
Not morbid! A good idea.
Tamara wrote: "Love, love, loved the interview with Ian McEwan! More interviews with authors would be awesome. I especially liked his take on 2 book we can't wait for you to read :)"
I agree! I would love to hear more interviews with authors. It´s always so fun to hear about other peoples favorite books, more of that please!
I agree! I would love to hear more interviews with authors. It´s always so fun to hear about other peoples favorite books, more of that please!


Mary, I've wanted to do an episode like that for years -- but I'm too afraid to reread my childhood favorites in case they don't hold up!



Sweet Valley High and Sweet Valley Twins by Francine Pascal were my absolute favs when I was a kid. I too devoured them much to the chagrine of my parents who had to keep buying me books because the library couldn't get them fast enough! The author recently published a brand new adult (I think) book about the twins 10 years later. I bought it on my Nook, but I have been afraid to read it in case I too am let down.



I agree! I wo..."
Although I enjoyed Ann's interview with Ian McEwan, I feel there are enough podcasts out there with author interviews. I most enjoy the episodes with just Ann and Michael discussing books and publishing.

Melissa wrote: "Although I enjoyed Ann's interview with Ian McEwan, I feel there are enough podcasts out there with author interviews...."
Melissa, we agree, which is why Michael and I agreed from the very start that we wouldn't do author interviews on BOTNS. But really, how could I say no to Ian McEwan?
I think we may see a few more author interviews going forward but they will be rare, and they will be authors that Michael and/or I feel very passionate about wanting you to "meet." Also, they won't be standard interviews about the current book, etc. Instead, I think they would be more focused on topics surrounding books and reading, and maybe a topic relevant to their new book -- but not all about the book, if that makes sense. I tried to do that with Ian McEwan -- you guys can tell me if I was successful or not -- but people seemed to really love his "2 books I can't wait for you to read" segment.
Melissa, we agree, which is why Michael and I agreed from the very start that we wouldn't do author interviews on BOTNS. But really, how could I say no to Ian McEwan?
I think we may see a few more author interviews going forward but they will be rare, and they will be authors that Michael and/or I feel very passionate about wanting you to "meet." Also, they won't be standard interviews about the current book, etc. Instead, I think they would be more focused on topics surrounding books and reading, and maybe a topic relevant to their new book -- but not all about the book, if that makes sense. I tried to do that with Ian McEwan -- you guys can tell me if I was successful or not -- but people seemed to really love his "2 books I can't wait for you to read" segment.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Looking-Glass Sisters (other topics)Leviathan Wakes (other topics)
The Glass Room (other topics)
The Invisible Bridge (other topics)
Ancillary Justice (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Annie Dillard (other topics)Lia Purpura (other topics)
Joni Tevis (other topics)
Athol Dickson (other topics)
Mark Helprin (other topics)
More...