TWILIGHT HATERS discussion
Twilight Lover's Topics
>
why do you hate twilight :)
date
newest »
newest »
![Maria [the clockwork creeps on useless lives] (mariachhile)](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1322709957p1/2412416.jpg)
i hate it cuz every1 else loves it. And it's taking away HP's fame.
i truly do not know who HP is. I dislike it because its rlly very over rated and then you have these crazy fan girls running at Rob pattinson (who looks like he just flew into a window) and making him jump in front of a cab to escape them (YES that did really happen. google that shit).
AND TWI LOVERS ARE NOT TAKING OVER
i think the harry potter movies are better than the twilight movies
Really, Incredibly, Extremely Overrated!Theres this whole big thing about it, when its not even that good!
Harry Potter on the other hand, is the exact opposite.
You never get bored of it.
Monique wrote: "HP is Harry Potter..."oh lol, that was painfully obvious. oops
Geneva wrote: "i think the harry potter movies are better than the twilight movies"duh. EVERY movie is better than the twilight movie. the Harry Potter movies are especially kick ass, though
i agree. Twilight seriously overrated.
I hate Twilight because it's frikin retarded and people make such big deal over it when it isn't that great!
i know!
I hate it because the vampire in Twilight were suppose to be like super heros. Well, none of them except for the vampire who was a doctor ever helped anybody. The only person they helped was Bella! And instead of the vampires sitting there and acting all emo, they should help more then one person. That's what pisses me off the most.
Thats makes no sense. The vampires in Twilight are suppose to be "villins"... Hello, haven't read all about Edwards angst and how he wishes he wasn't going to hell?
That makes no sense either, considering the point had nothing to do with angst. I was responding to Sid. 
It's like Harry Potter in the Order of the Phoenix and in the Half Blood Prince, man was he annoying...so "angsty"...I was irritated to the point I wished he would be the next character to die...and of course in my all time favourite book (The Lord of the Rings, Frodo also irritated the crap out of me!
so if characters in books that I actually love could irritate me, how could such winy horrible characters like those in twilight NOT annoy the living crap out of me.....
(hi!! i just joined this group :D)The first time i read twilight, i was like, "this is awesome!" but i thought about it and heard what twilight haters had to say and.... i agreed with everything. so now i've read all of the books and i don't know which side to choose. can someone please convince me why i should love it or hate it?
please help!!!
Hate it! It maketh no sense, its unrealistic and stupid and basically, it ruins the vampire image!I used to be one of those crazy fangirls that would be like "I LOVE TWILIGHT!" "OMG ROB P IS SOOO HOT!!!!!!" "BELLA AND EDWARD ARE SO CUTE TOGETHER!" But finally, all that changed.
yeah, your probably right. i think i wanted to like it because it was so popular. people obsess over something that sucks!!!! I mean, twilight got ELEVEN teen choice awards. There were better people to choose from, but people see the word twilight and vote while screaming and jumping up and down. Its like a few people decide to obesess over one topic and everyone says they like it becacase they think thats cool when the don't even really like it that much. They just don't tell themselves that.
Okay, so, I read all the books. No one made me, I was just curious. I tried reading twilight not long after it was released in paperback and I confess I think I got to the point where Bella actually starts pining away for Edward and I just couldn't continue reading. I had issues, with characters, with writing style. In my opinion if you are going to write first person, you had been be very, very good at it, and your first person point of view should really have a brain in her head, and be engaging. I ended up actually finishing twilight and reading new moon and eclipse right before breaking dawn came out. I read breaking dawn because at this point I figured it couldn't get any worse. I was wrong. The characters are two dimensional, badly written, and lack any sort of grounding in anything resembling reality. So I suppose I have to wonder with the rest of you, is it that you hate twilight on principle, or that there is something aside from Bella’s terminal stupidity, and Edward’s over the top stalker like persona that bothers you? Would you have liked the story if Bella had been better written, developed more through the course of the books? Would it have helped if Edward was not taking stalker 101 classes in the first novel?
''Would you have liked the story if Bella had been better written, developed more through the course of the books? Would it have helped if Edward was not taking stalker 101 classes in the first novel?''Yes it would have been better if those errors didn't happen.
Sheeky wrote: "''Would you have liked the story if Bella had been better written, developed more through the course of the books? Would it have helped if Edward was not taking stalker 101 classes in the first nov..."The funny thing is that in my experience, which is in no way expansive, things like this should have been caught and brought to the authors attention long before the book ever made it to print.
Now perhaps the publish really didn't see these things as issues, or figured that Twilight would not sell well enough to warrant the work who knows, but it seems strange that in subsequent volumes some of the issues were not addressed.
Saved By Grace wrote: "I would have liked it if Bella had been better written and actually developed character throughout the books, if Edward was not a stalker and not so angsty, if there was a plot, and if the vampires..."It would have been a different book true, with those improvements, but than new moon, eclipse and breaking dawn would have perhaps been bearable.
The only thing I didn't really mind was what she did to the vampires. I mean okay the idea that they sparkle was a little over the top, but not having proper fangs didn't really bother me, nor did the alterations that becoming a vampire seemed to afford the characters. I actually sort of thought it was a neat way to create a new species of monster.
I like vampire novels in general, so being introduced to creatures that are worlds away from the original vampire concept is not bothersome for me. I find it interesting as rule, as long as the author sticks by the rules once they've been created. No half breed brats.
I find that this is the most accurate bit in the entire series when it comes to showing the development of a typical teenage girl. Nothing really exciting happens if you sit around and expect it to just because you hit puberty and all that extra oxytocin tends to make you horny