Team Edward discussion
Should Stephenie Meyer continue with 'Midnight Sun'?
message 101:
by
H.M.
(new)
Jan 25, 2009 08:33PM
I am with everyone else. Stephenie Meyer is an extremely great writer, and she shouldn't stop.
reply
|
flag
yea i agree! finish the BOOK ull make heaps! lolyour such a good writter! we want more!! dont finish the twilight saga on a stuffd up angry note! leave it on a clean, clear and fresh one! we are your biggest fans understand that,
DONT LET US DOWN!
do all you can.
thanks x
Ali wrote: "yea i agree! finish the BOOK ull make heaps!"She won't make heaps if her heart isn't in it. It will suck, and then what will you txt about?
So leave her alone and indulge in the movies. And keep in mind that you have already read Twilight - Midnight Sun is just a retelling from a different perspctive. Edward is pretty vocal via Bella, so there's probably not a whole lot to say that hasn't been said.
And, I don't think she gives a crap about letting anyone down. She's already been so let down herself. She will write when she is ready.
True, true.I know what you mean, i can see your side of the story... because if she writes it in a bad mood it will b a bad book like she said on her website "If I tried to write Midnight Sun now, in my current frame of mind, James would probably win and all the Cullen’s would die, which wouldn't dovetail too well with the original story. In any case, I feel too sad about what has happened to continue working on Midnight Sun, and so it is on hold indefinitely."
And Evelynn what do u mean by: "and then what will you txt about?"...
I also think she will make money over the book no matter what, because many people want her to finish it so THEY can BUY it (and have the FULL Twilight saga at home not on the internet. so they can re-read it and not waste broadband or what ever you call it!), because we know/feel that the Twilight saga is not finished because Midnight Sun has been set/ posted of being under it. No matter weather the book is good or not people do want the whole series + Do you really think she would publish a bad book if she knows it’s not good (it would make her look bad) I don’t think she wants that.
Personally I think she should act like the internet posting didn’t happen. So people will stop bugging her, then it would be off her chest and she won’t have to worry about it any more. Then we can stop having a silly fight over the computer about it! Lol. I know everyone wants her to finish the book and again YES I know we have give her time... but the sooner she finishes it, publishes it and is feeling happy about the book, no-one will be bugging her (once shes finished that she could even start a new saga! ... if she feels the need) ... Then this topic will be done, and again I can see your side of the story. But I also know that we all want her to finish the book. THATS WHY WE ARE HAVING THIS CONVO lol
:P
Yesss!
i think it would be awesome knowing what edward in thinking all this time!
i think it would be awesome knowing what edward in thinking all this time!
I mean this in the deepest respect twoards Stephenie Meyer, but I really feel this was a marketing ploy to get everyone "hyped" about this book. Now EVERYONE wants to see how it continues (we already know how it ends). It was SOOOO much better than Twilight b/c you see Edward's POV, and not have to read about Bella making dinner for Charlie and doing her laundry. Please don't get me wrong I love the entire Twilight saga, but after reading Midnight Sun I just wanted MORE!!! Please publish it!!!
"And Evelynn what do u mean by: "and then what will you txt about?"... "uk exactly wht I mean.
Not everyone is guilty of butchering the english language, but it's rampant on the Twilight message boards. Just saying...
If I were Meyer, every time someone asked I woudld delay another year. If she gets pressured into, then it will really suck, big time.
The money is no enticement, she's already made a ton from the books and will now make more from the movies. If she publishes the rest of Midnight Sun, it will be only because she wants to.
i read the partial draft n OMG its js sooo awesome..i love edwardddddd..so my answer is YES DEFINATELY!!!!
yes i will so die if she dosent come out with it i love Edward!!!! we all need to know his side of the story!
Yea I understand what you mean about delaying the book. It’s her choice but we all obviously want her to finish the book! but once again i know we ALL want to know what Edwards thinking, from his point of view. (thats why we r here!) It would be great! I’m not meaning to be offensive… I just want her to finish the book… that’s all…I know that when ever people ask her about the book it would be annoying but she’s started it so why not finish it!
I’m a swimmer and when I start the session my goal is do to everything on the board, and if I miss a few hundreds I feel guilty lol… so I choose to finish it at the end of the session. It makes me happy that all the guilt is off my chest and then I can go into the next session knowing that I have made my goal once and that i CAN do it again… don’t you agree?
I know it’s her choice and she won’t give a crap about what I’m writing atm but “don’t you feel guilty letting us all read the first half, and leave us hanging for the second? Don’t you feel guilty knowing that you haven’t finished something and not wanting to turn back and finish it?” that’s all I’m saying…
Just get it off your chest and finish the book it will make you happy in the end :)... doesn’t it make you happy that many people of all age groups love your books and are looking up to you, waiting for more? (Well I am, and I’m waiting)
+ i dont bloody txt about the books! i only go on this! AND the only reason that im on here is to see other peoples point of view and to put in mine!
yea i need another book to read!! im reading twilight AGAIN!!! haha tho it still feels like i havent read it! new suprises, things i probably missed the first time becos i was so stuck into it! haha
Ali, forgive me for being the only one to say "ok, maybe she shouldn't finish the book." I have to say, this has been the most boring message board I have ever followed because basically everyone says "yes, omg, finish it."I didn't say I don't want to read it. And Stephanie Meyer has NOTHING to feel guilty about it. Except writing the worst ending in literary history...but that's another topic.
And I don't mean txt as in phone, I mean txt-speak, as in total lack of punctuation and half-formed words. You don't do it so much...but check out Justin's post above. How is anyone supposed to read that?
Lol ok I do understand what you mean by mayb her not finishing the book... im just saying it would be cool and a good idea to because so many people want to read it and want more! :POk... well personally i would feel guilty... but that is just and i did say she probably won't give a crap to what im saying. lol... and yes that would suck if she made all the Cullens die and let James win! because that is totaly off the topic from the first book (twilight)
Oh ok lol sorry... i will try to write better so you can read it.... well to be honest my keyboard dusnt always work lol :P so im sorry if a few letters are missing :P haha lol + im not a very good speller haha :P i'm just not good at it :P so i sometimes find it easier to write in short lol
:P
OMG!! why shouldnt she finish it? who cares that someone decided to ruin the beginning? its not like its gonna stop anyone from buying it, or stop it from being a hit. she has to finish it. the world will stop turning if we dont get midnight sun!
IF SHE DOESNT FINISH MIDNIGHT SUN I MIGHT DIE besides its way better in edwards point of view
Sophia wrote: "OMG!! why shouldnt she finish it? who cares that someone decided to ruin the beginning? its not like its gonna stop anyone from buying it, or stop it from being a hit. she has to finish it. the wor..."I totally agree!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
l me too i agree!! haha we just want the book as i said above... that she will still make tonns!!!!! lol and everyone will love it!!! lol the begining was awesome and if she finishes the second half will be awesome!! lol
I never attacked anyone's spelling. Can we all get over that now?I also did not say that I don't want her to finish it, but I understand if she doesn't. Someone had to say it. What's that point in everyone saying "omg finish it like i will die if u dont"? It's not like she's reading this.
CHECK THIS OUT!! I SAW IT ON BEBO!!!! xxWant to get in touch with Robert Pattinson?
Then this is your chance!
Robert.Pattinson@tvstar.com
Robert Pattinson
C/O Endeavor Agency
Stephanie Rittz 9601
Wilshire Blvd. Floor 3
Beverly Hills, CA 90210
Send all your love nots to the addresses above
CHECK THIS OUT!! I SAW IT ON BEBO!!!! xxWant to get in touch with Robert Pattinson?
Then this is your chance!
Robert.Pattinson@tvstar.com
Robert Pattinson
C/O Endeavor Agency
Stephanie Rittz 9601
Wilshire Blvd. Floor 3
Beverly Hills, CA 90210
Send all your love nots to the addresses above
Evelynn, if you don't like what people are saying about saving Midnight Sun then why on earth are you even posting. This is a board on should Midnight Sun be continued or not... not a board on dissing the books. And first of all the series had an amazing ending!, Second, even though it is a retelling of Twilight it would still be amazing! I have read the first 12 chapters and there is a lot of things Edward thinks that isnt in Twilight. Third, this message board is amazing because it is about saving the 5th book Midnight Sun. If we want to hope about her continuing Midnight Sun then we should be allowed to without you being mean about it. Find a different board if you want to go talking crap about the Twilight Series
I think she should finish it but, i don't think it was fair that her friends entered it into the internet
lol taylor ... thats kinda what ive been trying to say haha good on you lol, i still can see evelynns side but..... i agree with you about "Find a different board if you want to go talking crap about the Twilight Series"because it would be awesome!! (to have a 5th book!!!!) lol
Taylor wrote: "Evelynn, if you don't like what people are saying about saving Midnight Sun then why on earth are you even posting. This is a board on should Midnight Sun be continued or not... not a board on diss..."Last I checked, the question was "should she finish Midnight Sun?" That's not much of a question if someone has predetermined the answer. I'm allowed to say no.
I just don't see how it's entertaining for everyone to write exactly the same thing. For people who want to be so independent, you sure don't like it when someone disagrees.
And I do like the books, I just don't think they are the best books on the whole planet. I'm still Team Edward, but I can criticize if I want to. The point of these boards is to discuss, good or bad. Excuse me for having an opinion.
True True... i dont want to be in this fight again!! haha but i guess it is for opinions ... :P
lol na its not your fault!!!!!!! thats why we are all here!!! haha to talk about what we think and ofcourse the are going to be people who object :PBUT MAN I WANT HER TO FINISH IT SO BAD!!!! IM RE READING TWILIGHT! HAHA :P its real good tho koz i missed a few bits without realizing haha so its all new to me lol :p
ya ive read the series twice and i always seem to miss something good... My favorite part of twilight is when he says breakfast time for the human and she covers her neck jokingly... i thought that was hilarious
And then in eclipse when they were having the conversation about him not telling her about victoria coming and they were passing the notes and she said "so lets say my bad luck did crah the plane. what exactly were you going to do about it?" and then he said "why is the plane crashing?" and she said "the pilots are passed out drunk" and he said "easy. id fly the plane" and she said "both engines have exploded and were falling in a death spiral toward the earth" and then she he said "i'd wait till we were close enough to the ground, get a good frip on you, kick out the wall, and jump. Thenn i'd run you back to the scene of the accident, and we'd stumble around like the 2 luckiest survivors in history" lol ya i thought that was funny
yea that was hilarious!!!!! i loved that PART!!!!i liked all the BOOKS!!! i just thought it was real sad in the second one when EDWARD LEFT!!!
:( i cryed when he came back!! i was SOO HAPPY!!! lol im emotional like that!! esp if i like them!! :P lol
Xox.
:P
:D
<3
lol yea When He left and came backi cried when he left because i was sad :(
and,
i cried when he came back because i was so happy! :) but also a bit angry at him for leaving in the first place! but i was also crying at thee words he said were SO CUTE!
I know I should have jus put the page number :P but I was bored :P lol its page 509/510 from new moon if you want to read it from there :P but anyway: ------>
I cried real bad in the Part where he said:
'he shook my shoulder, trying to loosen my rigid pose. "Let me finish! i'm a good liar, but still, for you to believe me so quickly." he winced. "that was… excruciating."
i waited, still frozen.
"when we were in the forest, when i was telling you goodbye-"
i didnt allow myself to remember. i fought to keep myself in the present second only.
"you wernt going to let go," he wispered. "i could see that. i didnt want to do it-it felt like it would kill me to do it-but i knew that if i couldn't convince you that i didnt love you anymore, it woukld just take you that much longer to get on with your life. i hoped that, if you thought i'd moved on, so would you."
"A clean break," i wispered through unmoving lips.
"Exactly. But i never imagined it would be so easy to do! i thought it would be next to impossible- that you would be so sure of the truth that i would have to lie through my teeth for hours to even plant the seed of doubt in your head. i lied, and im so sorry- sorry because i hurt you, sorry because it was worthless effort. Sorry that i couldn’t protect you from what i am. i lied to save you, and it didn’t work. im sorry.”
“but cow could you believe me? After a thousand times i've told you i love you, how could you let one word break your faith in me?"
i didn’t answer. i was too shocked to form a rational response.
"i could see it in your eyes, that you honesty believed that i didn’t want you any more. the most absurd, ridiculous concept- as if there were any way i could exist without needing you!"
I was still frozen. His words were incomprehensible, because they were impossible.
He shook my shoulder again, not hard, but enough that my teeth rattled a little.
“bella,” he sighed. “really, what were you thinking!”
And so I started to cry. The tears welled up and then gushed miserably down my cheeks.
“I knew it,” I sobbed. I knew i was dreaming.”
“you’re impossible,” he said, and he laughed once- a hard laugh, frustrated. “how can I put this so that you’ll believe me? You’re not asleep, and your not dead. Im here, and I love you. I have always loved you, and I will always love you. seeing your face in my mind, every second I was away. When I told you that I didn’t want you, it was the very blackest kind of blasphemy.” ‘
Lol, I loved that part!! I cried so hard! :( :P
xox
Ali
and to make that part worse i was listening to river flow in you by uruima :( i love that song :P :(
YUP!!!! HAHA lol i was! i had nuthing to do lol :P but that part was so good that it made me cry real bad! lol it was reali sad!!! and good! haha
YA! I love how were like off topic on this board lol oh well!i remember that part well to cuz i just finished new moon again
... jus wondering do you know what the twilight saga book is??? and also can you buy the special additon Twilight DVD from the DVD store or tdo you have to order it online??
isnt the twilight saga the whole series? and idk what dvd ur talking about but ya u could probably buy it at a dvd store
lol im not sure ae i heard others talking about it :S i reali want the spical addtion but im not sure what it is lol is it the movie with xtra features or is it jus special features or what??? im so confused! LOL
