Did any of you like the new Victoria or the old one was Better?

[Kit]

the transition is flawed.. i don't get why she changed all of a sudden.. the character got confusing.. really..

[Amanda]

Didnt matter to me

[Amanda]

Esther wrote: "I liked the old one. She was way better and I wonder why did they ever change her."

Because she violated the contract by working with another director for another movie.

[AlbertaJenn]

Amanda wrote: "Esther wrote: "I liked the old one. She was way better and I wonder why did they ever change her."

Because she violated the contract by working with another director for another movie."

Except that all indications were that David Slade, the director, had given his approval for her to work on the other film. Nothing was explicitly said, but she was in contact with him during the pre-production process, when she got the role for Barney's Version. That it may have been the studio heads that decided to let her go because of the other film. Which doesn't make sense, since the director sets up the schedule, not the studio.

[Samirah]

Rachelle Lefevre.

[Mary]

Rachelle Lefevre.

[aryanna]

i like the new one she looks more like i pictured her in my mind when I read the book

[Quicksilvet]

I really thought the one in Twilight was better! She was exactly how I imagined her looking. I was disappointed when they got a different actress to play Victoria in Eclipse.