Harry Potter discussion

FanFiction & Other Series > anyone there to discuss the "other" hp7 book?

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:01PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments as we have said in another topic there were lots of snogging, but in case you guys haven't finished this other hp7 don't go to this topic. i just love their search for the horcruxes there WITH GINNY!!!!

message 2: by Mel (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:03PM) (new)

Mel I agree. I loved the way they were able to search all together. Ginny definitely adds something, and her argument about being an underage which does make sense in the context of Dumbledore's earlier search with Harry. And, I have to admit, I liked the Dragon guarding the cup better than the bank fiasco.

message 3: by Meghan (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:03PM) (new)

Meghan | 686 comments I have to admit that the Gringotts thing was a little annoying in the real book and I liked the other part better. But I still think the real book is better. The whole Dudley thing was just to wierd.

message 4: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:05PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments yeah, isn't that weird? especially the ending where dudley's gone missing and his parents died of fright. it's like tom riddle all over again. but ginny really got spunk just like a small molly that's why i laughed out loud when i read the part "not my daughter, you bitch!" in the real book coz ginny was fighting the trio nail & tooth to be with the search. but don't you like the ministry scene? i think harry was fantastic in there exuding all that power in front of voldemort when remus and tonks died....

message 5: by Jayme (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:06PM) (new)

Jayme | 13 comments Where can I find a copy of this other book?

message 6: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:06PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments i don't know where my friend downloaded it but if you'll give me your email add i'll forward it to you. ^_^

message 7: by Cindy (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:06PM) (new)

Cindy (wanna_read_all_the_books) Can you send it to me as well please? I'll send you my email address.

message 8: by Meghan (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:08PM) (new)

Meghan | 686 comments Does anyone think that Dudley is now a DArk Lord and Harry will have to kill him too? If so do you think Ginny should kill him or Harry?

message 9: by Anj_bookster (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:09PM) (new)

Anj_bookster alcala | 22 comments i havn't finishd reading the fake copy of the book though. but i think harry's gone gaga w/ just the mere thought of Ginny..and that's not how i knew harry potter in all the books. i have a copy of the mnauscript but i think the story's the same w/ all those who read the fake one.

message 10: by Meghan (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:09PM) (new)

Meghan | 686 comments Brianna,

In the other version, which was not written by J.K. Rowling, Dudley is a wizard. Dumbledore just hid his magic. Weird, huh?

message 11: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:10PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments yeah, and there was even the suspicion that aunt petunia was a squib (but jk cleared that she was not at all a witch). with the fake one though, the writer was insinuating that dudley is the next dark lord (the ending was kinda left hanging). but i know harry would be on to him after defeating the "real deal". i mean, dudley has loads to learn first and harry was already exposed with all kinds of magic, even the dark ones! but come to think of it, if dudley decides to learn for himself there might be a lot of casualties with all the violence in his personality (uncaring bully that he is!).

anj, i think it's the same book, too, go on and read it. it's kinda good weird. i love their search for the hufflepuff horcrux in a domelike place, don't you, meghan? i just love harry on a broomstick!

oh, i wish the others would finish the book! i'd like to discuss the other happenings!

message 12: by Michele (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:10PM) (new)

Michele | 20 comments --semi spoiler---

Dudley being a wizard is a bit weird because he's so thick but I thought it made for a good explanation as to why Petunia kept Harry all those years and why she hated him so much. I thought it was a nice ironic twist. You'd have to read it to see if the pieces go together.

message 13: by Meghan (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:10PM) (new)

Meghan | 686 comments Guess what!

J.K. Rowling caught the people who wrote it! (I still don't know who they are) Well, you can tell it's ouch time for them! :\

message 14: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:11PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments ooops, read and commented first on the other book topic, meghan.....

yeah, michele, coz harry is their only relative and it was really weird for petunia to feel that strong loathing to him when he really hasn't done anything wrong. so maybe petunia was punishing harry for what dudley is doing magically. and it seems ironic, too, that draco and dudley would hit it of there! the two boys who made harry's life miserable...

message 15: by Meghan (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:11PM) (new)

Meghan | 686 comments Speaking of Draco and Dudley, did anyone think it was wierd that Draco would just become friends with a "Mudblood" as he puts it? I mean he's always despised them and now he's friends with Big D. It just didn't cut it.
I suppose an argument for this could be that he felt alone and was hurting because of his father, so he immediately made friends with the other bully.
If Dudley became a dark lord would Draco forget what happened with Voldemort and join forces with him?

message 16: by Peng (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:12PM) (new)

Peng | 317 comments yeah, draco and dudley have 1 thing in common, they both hate harry. i'm guessing draco would teach dudley the dark arts but stay safe in the dark, you know what i mean? he likes having glory but wants to stay out of trouble.

message 17: by [deleted user] (new)

someone please send me this info. this is the first i have heard of it. I would LOVE to read it. Thank you.

message 18: by Holly (last edited Aug 25, 2016 01:39PM) (new)

Holly Thompson (rabbitt32) | 7 comments oh me too plz...

message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

the website to find this book is www.pheonixsong.org

back to top