Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Crying
haha, Like a baby! Mostly when Sirius dies, but yes, also Doby, Fred, Dumbledore, Cedric, Lupin...Oh and also at the end when Harry goes to face Voldemort.
I cried when cedric. dobby and fred died
I teared up when dobby did in the movie.... But I'm not one to cry over books or movies
Honestly I don't cry much during books, but the epilogue (YES I liked the epilogue so there) did make me misty eyed, as did of course the very end when Harry at last defeated Voldemort.
Yeah.... Everyone saw that coming!
My favorite part is the part about snape.... I swear if they don't show his past I will be so mad!!!
My favorite part is the part about snape.... I swear if they don't show his past I will be so mad!!!
Ohh that part was cool
I think they'll show his past. It's a crucial part to the entire series. It shows why Snape behaved how he did and why he did what he did.
They can't NOT show it.
I know.... I'm worried that all the last part is gonna be is like the fight.... There is so much more though!!!
In the last movie did they show snape's patronis? while he was with dumbldore
Ummm.... I'm drawing a blank.... But I don't think so honestly....
Umm that was an important part too
U would have to ask someone else..... Ur not talking about part one in the woods though r u......
No i think there is a part in the 6th book but not sure where
Yeah.... But I think dumbeldore just dies.... I haven't seen that movie in a while....
They didnt show snapes patronus when he was with dumbledore.
And I cried at just about every death, even Moody's, and Screamed ' Oh HECK NO!' I was an emotional wreck while reading hte last book, and I tend to skip over Sirius' death when I read the 5th book over and over
And I cried at just about every death, even Moody's, and Screamed ' Oh HECK NO!' I was an emotional wreck while reading hte last book, and I tend to skip over Sirius' death when I read the 5th book over and over
Yeah.... So many people I liked who died!!!
I was crying for the majority of the book! All of the deaths were sad, but I was also crying just because I knew it was the last book and it was going to be the last time I read a Harry Potter book for the first time. However, the deaths of Mad-Eye Moody and Hedwig were so sudden and sort of skimmed over that it was hard to get too upset. I was pretty devastated about Hedwig once it had sunk in, but Mad-Eye's death wasn't focused on all that much so I wasn't as upset about that as others. Fred's death was definitely one of the saddest :(And the part when Hagrid is carrying Harry out of the Forbidden Forest! That was one of the most upsetting parts for me, even though you know Harry's not dead. Just the idea of everyone thinking he was dead was upsetting. And of course the epilogue too.
Mad-Eye's comments in the movie were hilarious!!!!!!!
I know....... so touching!
I know....... so touching!
Kristen wrote: "haha, Like a baby! Mostly when Sirius dies, but yes, also Doby, Fred, Dumbledore, Cedric, Lupin...Oh and also at the end when Harry goes to face Voldemort."
I forgot about Cedric, I loved him!
Yeah... His death was so tragic!!!! I hated how that had to happen and poor cho!!!
I cried for Hedwig, Dobby, Fred and Snape's deaths. I didn't cry over Sirius... I sort of feel bad about that. I didn't cry over Lupin and Tonks' deaths. I got angry instead. (I hate when author's kill important - or even semi-important characters "off-camera". It feels like cheating to me.)Did anyone else notice that EVERY character she introduced from that generation - no matter how insignificant - died? Characters older than that (like Ron's parents and Neville's) were fine. But the ones from that particular year all died.
Jessica wrote: "Yeah... His death was so tragic!!!! I hated how that had to happen and poor cho!!!"not me I HATE CHO!!!!!!but I love Ced!
i literally sobbed murderously when snape died. i threw the book against the wall and locked myself in the room for 6 hours.
Mrs. Tiffany Snape wrote: "i literally sobbed murderously when snape died. i threw the book against the wall and locked myself in the room for 6 hours."I could picture that!
haha ikr?
Heather wrote: "I cried for Hedwig, Dobby, Fred and Snape's deaths. I didn't cry over Sirius... I sort of feel bad about that. I didn't cry over Lupin and Tonks' deaths. I got angry instead. (I hate when author..."Were Neville's parents older? I always just assumed they were about the same age group as Harry's...
But that's probably just because the only ones introduced from that time were all so significant to the plot. And they all fought against Voldemort(with the exception of wormtail, but he basically killed himself).
i still cry myself to sleep to this day even though i last read the dh months ago
oooh, I get that way when I think of Cedric's death, and Fred's!
ugh i hate cedric but fred's was pretty sad. i also cried at tonks and lupin's death because those are my second fav charries.
Oh dobby got me.... He was so cute!!!
Adrianja wrote: "Nicole wrote: "No i think there is a part in the 6th book but not sure where"it was a flashback in the 7th book. Snape's memory :) that's also when u find out it was snape's patronus"
that made me cry so hard!
I cried LIKE A BABY throughout the entire book, but when Fred died I went into hysteria for like 7 hours, and everyone thought I lost it or sth! And everytime Id pick up the book to finish it, id just start sobbing all over again! I mean HOW COULD JKR KILL HIM??! You just CANT have George without FFRED! :'(
IKR?!?!? me and my friend are called fred and george cuz we always play pranks and clever stuff :
Nice, FRED AND GEORGE WERE THE BESTEST! ALSO THE AWESOMEST, AND CLEVEREST!!!!!!!!
I KNOW!! fred and george are like part of a whole; you just can't have one without the other. It's that simple.
And I cried when Dumbledore died; it was just VERY unexpected! I think I was in shock for a while; i just couldn't think properly! And I wept forever when SNAPE was killed!! well I did later when i found out about everything he has done for harry later. He is just AMAZING!! he sacrificed practically EVERYTHING for lily :'( I think i'm just a YOU-CANT KILL-THE-GOOD-GUY kind of person.
Kaleigh wrote: "Nice, FRED AND GEORGE WERE THE BESTEST! ALSO THE AWESOMEST, AND CLEVEREST!!!!!!!!"YESSS!!!!
Judy wrote: "And I cried when Dumbledore died; it was just VERY unexpected! I think I was in shock for a while; i just couldn't think properly! And I wept forever when SNAPE was killed!! well I did later when i..."I LOVE SNAPE! (if that wasn't obvious before :D)
I LOVE HARRY POTTER (in general)
:)
LMFAO some people get way to into books...its not real its not really worth crying over.
i didnt cry reading the book..but this book is really awesome..i mean there are parts where i nearly cried myself..but then..i read the book at school..so crying isnt cool in front of the whole class..but still, the part where many of potter's friends died..it is very2 sad..and it's worth breaking into tears..
Darkrose wrote: "LMFAO some people get way to into books...its not real its not really worth crying over."dont mock me!(jk!) I don't really get emotional over anything but some books really get to me, especially when those books are the genius of Harry Potter. Also, who are you to judge someone if they cry or not? Some people are more sensitive than others and it's not your job to laugh at them.
From the amountn of *crying* i do when reading HP books (yes, i STILL do it), especially Deathly Hallows, one would siriusly doubt the fact that i am not the crying sort! But honestly, it's impossible not to cry when characters so close to your heart and so embedded in your life dies. I remember i almost couldn't go on reading when Dumbledore and Dobby died. It was unbearably painful! but i sometimes cry in happy moments too, like the epilogue and when Harry feels so grateful when Hermione and Ron confirms they are going with him.
after reading the last book of the HP series, it made me cry a bit and experienced some hp withdrawal like someone who's addicted to something. :( deep in my heart i know there will never be another harry potter. :'( too bad it ended......
Darkrose wrote: "LMFAO some people get way to into books...its not real its not really worth crying over."The way I figure it, if someone can cry/become frightened/etc. while watching a movie, they have every right to feel the same range of emotions while reading. After all, books - if they're doing their job - separate the reader from reality for the time while they are reading. A good writer can transport a reader to a different world.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
I cried when Dobby, Fred, Dumbledore, and Hedwig died, and I think I screamed(in happiness) when Harry kissed Ginny for the first time.