The Next Best Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Revive a Dead Thread
>
What are you reading?






Someone had asked what order of the Narnia Chronicles that C.S. Lewis preferred. Here is what my book says:
The Magician's Nephew
The Lion, the Witch . . .
The Horse and His Boy
Prince Caspian
The Voyage of the Dawn Treader
The Silver Chair
The Last Battle
I had this same discussion with my son... when I read them The Magicians Nephew wasn't around, and I started with tL tW and tW ... it that possible? And doesn't it give away some of the story, so wouldn't it be better to read it at the end?
EDIT: Interesting article in Wikipedia about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chro...
From the article:
But the article suggests that Lewis didn't really think there need be a set order, so we can all read them in any order we like!
EDIT: Interesting article in Wikipedia about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chro...
From the article:
... They (those who prefer the publishing order) maintain that much of the magic of Narnia comes from the way the world is gradually presented in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. They believe that the mysterious wardrobe, as a narrative device, is a much better introduction to Narnia than The Magician's Nephew — where the word "Narnia" appears in the first paragraph as something already familiar to the reader. Moreover, they say, it is clear from the texts themselves that The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe was intended to be read first, and that The Magician's Nephew was not. When Aslan is first mentioned in The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, for example, the narrator says that "None of the children knew who Aslan was, any more than you do". Fans of the original order point out that this is nonsensical if one has already read The Magician's Nephew.
But the article suggests that Lewis didn't really think there need be a set order, so we can all read them in any order we like!

Happy reading!

Claire, That's so cool that you're reading The Glass Castle too! :) We'll have to talk once we're done it. :) Glad you're enjoying it too!

On to the next one! (I feel like Henry VIII.)

There are 2 characters narrating the book, one I like and one I don't. It will be interesting to see how the two story lines combine.
It's set just after the end of the Revolutionary War, when Western Penn was the western frontier.

I agree that the magic of Lucy's discovery of Narnia is much more magical and interesting to children. So that's how my grandchildren will get them.
I figure about age 6 or 7 is a fair time to start reading these. Anybody want to suggest a different age?


Everyman wrote: "When I read them (the Narnia tales) to my grandchildren, I will certainly start with the Lion.... I actually didn't care much for The Magicians Nephew -- felt it was too much trying to explain ho..."
Lucky Kids!! I can't wait til I have some so I can read things with them too!
I read them (on my own, however) a little later, but okay I think if you're reading together. There is a part at the end of "Lion" which I found incredibly sad (don't want to give anything away) and I cried for a long time over it, even after I had finished the book and everything had been resolved, so if the grandkids are especially sensitive be careful.
Lucky Kids!! I can't wait til I have some so I can read things with them too!
I read them (on my own, however) a little later, but okay I think if you're reading together. There is a part at the end of "Lion" which I found incredibly sad (don't want to give anything away) and I cried for a long time over it, even after I had finished the book and everything had been resolved, so if the grandkids are especially sensitive be careful.
I'm taking a break from Biker Chicks, The magnetic attraction of women to bad boys and motobikes, it's just not holding my attention the way i thought it would, will pick it up every now and then and read another womens story.
Started Drink Play F@#k by Andrew Gottlieb a couple of hours ago and am really enjoying it, finding it funny and interesting and just wanting to keep reading more. This is sort of the male version to Eat Pray Live, this man has just been left by his wife of 8 years for another man and decides to take a year to find himself.
Started Drink Play F@#k by Andrew Gottlieb a couple of hours ago and am really enjoying it, finding it funny and interesting and just wanting to keep reading more. This is sort of the male version to Eat Pray Live, this man has just been left by his wife of 8 years for another man and decides to take a year to find himself.




Claire, That's so cool that you're reading..."
hi Allison - Yes, lets discuss it - I should be finished with it in the next couple of days. It IS hard to put down!







Tracy, have you read the books before? I love them. I remember asking my parents to buy me the first three books in hardback because they were out, and because even though the first was in paperback, I wanted them to match. So glad that I did!

I only read [book:Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix|2, [book:Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince|1] and Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows and then my son who had read all of them told me I need to read the first 4 books, so I read Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone and now I'm reading Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets to be followed by Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban and Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. If I have time I will reread the 3 I've already read before the new movie comes out in July.

Stephanie: I read Those Who Save Us a few months ago and loved it. It has some difficult passages to get through (not from a writing style standpoint, but from the standpoint of the horrific things that occur), but was overall very happy I read it. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did.

Claire, That's so cool that you're reading..."
Allison/Claire: The Glass Castle is one of those thought provoking memoirs that really grabs you and stays with you. Would love to see what you have to think about it when finished reading it.

I started on Hurry Down Sunshine today. I have been anxiously awaiting reading this book, and sadly I am pretty disappointed so far.

So, I'm moving on to the second book of the trilogy -- The Confusion
Just finished Amy and Isabelle A Novel. I liked it, but it bothers me that pretty much every man in the book was no damn good.
Just starting The Last Chronicle of Barset. I am thoroughly in love with Trollope, having read the other 5 Barchester books.
Just starting The Last Chronicle of Barset. I am thoroughly in love with Trollope, having read the other 5 Barchester books.


I just finished Drink Play F@#k by Andrew Gottlieb (which I only started yesterday afternoon) and have got to say that i am happy with it. It was funny, interesting, went at the right pace for me and had some great characters. I found some parts to be a little unbelievable but that only happened a couple of times during the Vegas Route. I don't think i'll read Eat Pray Live anytime soon because i know all i'll do is compare it to this and i think it will be quite different.
Now i think i might try a classic in Wuthering Heights as i haven't read any of those kinds of books.
Now i think i might try a classic in Wuthering Heights as i haven't read any of those kinds of books.

Have you ever read Savannah Blues by Mary Kay Andrews? This sounds somewhat similar, and I loved Savannah Blues. I'll have to check yours out.
Edit: Well, Savannah Blues is funny, not a ghost story. But the antiques, mystery, Southern city, hunky guy thing is similar. :-)

Now I'm starting A Northern Light. I'm about 50 pages in and I love it so far. Another main character who's a reader! Gotta love 'em!

That is my favorite as well.
As to Narnia - I personally like reading them in chronilogical order not "published" order but each person has to come to that on their own. It is still one of my favorite series.
-- Robin The Crown Conspiracy | Avempartha | Nyphron Rising (Oct 2009)

That is EXACTLY how I felt about them. The third one I think is better than the 2nd but still not as good as the first - I've not read Breaking Dawn yet.

El wrote: "Still plugging away at Tolstoy's War and Peace, but also have started Octavia Butler's Parable of the Sower and Wallace Stegner's The Spectator Bird."
Oh how I cringe when I see Stegners name....!!
Oh how I cringe when I see Stegners name....!!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Little Bee (other topics)Canada (other topics)
Her Fearful Symmetry (other topics)
I Have America Surrounded: A Biography of Timothy Leary (other topics)
Inferno (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
William Shakespeare (other topics)Kevin Wilson (other topics)
Andrea Levy (other topics)
Lauren Carr (other topics)
Lauren Carr (other topics)
More...
Two completely different love stories :)