The Twilight Saga
discussion
Whose better.....Edward Cullen or Jacob Black!!!
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Aalisha
(new)
Apr 13, 2011 09:40AM
I wanted to know who was loved more......the hottest vampire in the world or the rubbish Dog!!!!Well,i like Edward cullen!!pls tell me fast!!
reply
|
flag
I HATE Jacob! Eckh! SO Edward.
you are crazy. Edward is being selfish. He risked Bella's life. Jacob never stops protecting her.
neither,, jacob is to needy and whinny, edward is only atracted to bella cuz he cant read her mind she is like an expirement to him.:/
boo you dice and brooke!!!!geez! its pretty damn obvious that edwards the best! jacob is an a******! he said he would rather have bella dead!!!!how rude! and no, edward doesnt want her just as an experiment! he loves her! why else would he fo through all that pain and trouble to protect bella! and plus- he married her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gosh!
I cant belief Im saying this but i actually agree with you.
Saraharnold wrote: "boo you dice and brooke!!!!geez! its pretty damn obvious that edwards the best! jacob is an a******! he said he would rather have bella dead!!!!how rude! and no, edward doesnt want her just as an e..."Haha you make a good point! But the only reason he even thought twice about Bella in the first place was because he couldnt read her mind...(:
@Dice-not only that fact but also her potent smell and her blood.....but thanks dice and amylia!
Edward is so much better than Jake!! I mean, where Jacob is cruel to Bella and doesn't care if he hurts her feelings, Edward cares very much for Bella and tries to protect her.
I really can't stand Jacob!
But one thing is for sure, they should have made Edward look much more handsome.. hehe
Edward Cullen is still on the lead!!!
Saraharnold wrote: "@Dice-not only that fact but also her potent smell and her blood.....but thanks dice and amylia!"
Yes i know!(: haha they both make me extremely mad.
haha...this is a fun argument just to see everyone else's opinions makes it very interesting and gives me a lot more to take into consideration...
i know, its entertaining(: lol
Amylia wrote: "Ditto :D"i wish there were like buttons, like on facebook, then i would have liked you're comment haha
Dice wrote: "Amylia wrote: "Ditto :D"i wish there were like buttons, like on facebook, then i would have liked you're comment haha"
haha ikr! lol
Thanks really...
im still wondering where all Jacob's fan are when he is losing his title against Edward Cullen his worldwide enemy..:p
im still wondering where all Jacob's fan are when he is losing his title against Edward Cullen his worldwide enemy..:p
Sarah wrote: "Dice wrote: "Amylia wrote: "Ditto :D"i wish there were like buttons, like on facebook, then i would have liked you're comment haha"
haha ikr! lol"
(:
Dice wrote: "Sarah wrote: "Dice wrote: "Amylia wrote: "Ditto :D"i wish there were like buttons, like on facebook, then i would have liked you're comment haha"
haha ikr! lol"
(:"
wow thats confusing....
i wasnt confused until you said it was confusing, now im confused to :0 lol
message 25:
by
I don't look Human, you look Timelord
(last edited Apr 25, 2011 06:20PM)
(new)
-
added it
Omg!!!Edward no question!
Totally agree withyo Sarah!!!!
Edward has sacrificed so much for Bella!!!!!
RoseTyler wrote: "Omg!!!Edward no question!
Totally agree withyo Sarah!!!!
Edward has sacrificed so much for Bella!!!!!"
why thank you rosetyler
:D:D lol!lluuuvvv edward!
Jacob is not 'rubbish', first of all, and Edward isn't exactly the right one for her. I think Bella'd be so much better off with Jacob. Just think about it:She wouldn't have to change for him- meaning she wouldn't have to become a lifeless blood sucker. Sure they only hunt animals, but that's still killing. And what if she were to be discovered?? There would be a LOT of trouble.
Edward doesn't give her the same protection that Jacob does. Edward LEFT and put her in grave danger. Sure he came back, but only because he thought it was to late!! Jacob would have never left her in the first place. She could have a normal life, a normal family. That is something Edward can't give her. Edward can't even have sex with Bella without risking her life!
Edward was attracted to her because of her 'sweet-smelling blood', and her ability to resist Edwards mind-reading powers. Does that sound like a good guy to be around? A guy that only wants you for your blood???
ok u know what....all of that is incorrect...i WILL come up with a ebuttle to that but not right now cuz im really tired and its past midnight so ya but probably tomorrow i will come up with a good argument to all of that, SCOUCGE(LYLA)
ok so im taking this open window of opportunity to prove u incorrect, Scourge(Lyla). k, so first of all, u basically just quoting most of what jacob said. second, she wouldnt have to change for either of them-its not like edwards saying "oh well if u want to be with me than u have to become a vampire" thats exactly what he DOESNT want for her-he doesnt want her to change for him- its HER decision. and yes, vamps do kill animals TO SURVIVE!!!! if u didnt notice, we as humans kill animals for food as well, and in Breaking Dawn, it shows Jacob killing an animal with Leah to eat... so HE IS JUST AS GUILTY!!!! so yes, jacob kills too, and if u were to look at it broadly, we as humans(who arent vegetarians) kill animals too- i bet u u r just as guilty.(yeah thats right, hot dogs, hamburgers, ribs, chicken - ya that stuff ACTUALLY COMES FROM ANMALS IF U HAD NOT NOTICED AND IN ORDER TO EAT THOSE FOODS< WE MUST KILL THE ANIMALS-so unless u r a vegitarian, then u r JUST AS GUILTY AS VAMPIRES!!!) and what do u mean if she was discovered? by the volturi? SHE ALREADY WAS!!! and was she killed? NO! u would know that if u read the books thouroughly! Edward protects her MORE THAN JACOB! he's always with her (with the exception of New Moon but that was because he was under the impression that that would be whats best for her- he didnt think he was doing wrong)and when he's not with her, he constantly is near her where she cant see or has Alice watching as always- Does Jacob do those things-NOPE! and EDWARD CAME BACK BECAUSE HE REALIZED HE MADE A MISTAKE- everyone makes mistakes!!!! what do u mean because he thought it was too late? too late for what? AND JACOB DID LEAVE HER! AND HURT HER-MANY TIMES! She would most certainly NOT HAVE A NORMAL LIFE CUZ JACOB IS A FRIGGIN WEREWOLF!!!!! and also, JACOB CANT HAVE SEX WITHOUT RISKING HER LIFE EITHER!!! he could get overwhelmed and CHANGE right next to her, putting her in the line of death cuz he has anger issues and temper tantrums! and edward was not only attracted to her blood and ability to resist his mind reading! he liked her because she was apparently unlike anyone else he had ever met and HE LOVED HER FOR WHO SHE WAS! WHY ELSE IN THE WORLD WOULD HE MARRY HER?!?!?! and yes he does sound like a good guy to be around becuz he cares about her WELL-BEING WHILE JACOB DOES NOT! HE JUST WANTS TO MAKE OUT WITH HER!and he always hurts her just becuz of her own opinions and she's just too forgiving to not just leave him in the dirt like any NORMAL PERSON WOULD DO NO MATTER HOW HOT THE GUY WAS!!!!! so there, any questions? annyone who does not agree with me has lost their sanity! no offense
sorry that was so long
Sarah wrote:
oh so im taking........no offense
I totally agree!!!
oh so im taking........no offense
I totally agree!!!
hey no problem, fans need to stick together right?
Im totally picking Edward!!!
Amylia wrote: "hey no problem, fans need to stick together right?"haha yeppurooni! haha :)
Sarah wrote: "ok u know what....all of that is incorrect...i WILL come up with a ebuttle to that but not right now cuz im really tired and its past midnight so ya but probably tomorrow i will come up with a good..."thats supposed to say rebuttle not ebuttle
Sarah wrote: "ok so im taking this open window of opportunity to prove u incorrect, Scourge(Lyla). k, so first of all, u basically just quoting most of what jacob said. second, she wouldnt have to change for ei..."
i totaly agree. people need 2 get their facts STRAIGHT!!!!
i totaly agree. people need 2 get their facts STRAIGHT!!!!
Sarah wrote: I totaly agree. people need 2 get their facts STRAIGHT!!!!Im supporting you by 100%!!!
Well.....Sarah....We can obviously tell that you are a huge fan of EDWARD CULLEN and so is everyone one else so the final result is that EDWARD CULLEN ROCKS AND JACOB BLACK SUCKS!!!!!! But the thread isn't over so you people can still write more!!!!!!!
Aalisha wrote: "Well.....Sarah....We can obviously tell that you are a huge fan of EDWARD CULLEN and so is everyone one else so the final result is that EDWARD CULLEN ROCKS AND JACOB BLACK SUCKS!!!!!! But the thre..."haha...wait me sarah, or my friend sarah with the pink converse as her pic?
which Sarah? high heels or converse??
y does this ALWAYS happen. people can't get which Sarah they r talking 2.
I would pick Edward Cullen as the best :)
I was talking about the high heels sarah!!!
High Priestess of all Vampyres wrote: "I would pick Edward Cullen as the best :)"
same here. dont get me wrong. jacob is pretty hot but edward IS the best
same here. dont get me wrong. jacob is pretty hot but edward IS the best
i think bella is the best because if you put them in a crime the men are guiltybecause bela cheats on edward once by kissing jacob. and edward gets her preg without permission aANnD jacob tries to kill edward and renessme but tries to kidnapp her intead.
a bella swan quote ...Even more, I had never meant to love him
deleted user wrote: "High Priestess of all Vampyres wrote: "I would pick Edward Cullen as the best :)"same here. dont get me wrong. jacob is pretty hot but edward IS the best"
yep they are both hot- for edward the jaw line and those eyes. jacob. everything
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
