Isabelle or Maia?

[Ash]

For Simon? If so, then (duh) ISABELLE! She and Simon are totally meant for each other and she's a powerful young lady! Maia is very powerful, but she has her own problems to deal with and I'm not sure having a boyfriend is one of them.

If you have only read a couple books and see that Maia and Isabelle are with Simon, then you need to read on, baby! Everything gets better and you'll see who is perfect for each other.

Isabelle is a beautiful girl with a strong attitude. She seems so perfect for Simon and I think ANYONE would agree. I really love her character and I feel like the author (Cassandra Clare) did a great job with Simon and Isabelle's romance.

Maia is a strong girl who can fight on her own. Please skip two lines if you haven't read past Simon dating both girls at the same time. Maia is the leader of the wolf pack and she earned it. That shows true girl power! Of course, she's not meant for Simon because their romance is.... NOTHING! In the book, I felt NO sparks between them.

So, I guess what I'm saying is...... TEAM ISABELLE!!

[Hanita]

Izzy, Because ( She's Honestly Gorgeous ) and Even Though She Looks Like She Want's To Hurt You, She Is Still Amazingly Kind. Plus Mia is Already Starting To Like Her Ex-Boyfriend Jordan Again...So Consider Simon Lucy To Have Isabelle To Fall In Love With Him Because Iz Already Has A Waiting List Of Boy's That Love Her. "FAVORITE'S: Mangus, Alec, Clary, Simon, ISABELLE, Oh And Jace"

[Vanna]

Isabelle

[Sara]

Isabelle! Maia was a bit annoying for me

[Jennifer]

This is almost a moot question. In the books Simon dated both girls, (a real player!) and was dumped by both upon their finding out. His relationship with Maia was briefer than Isabelle's (as Izzy was a more prominent character) and Maia later had her own baggage in the return of Jordan which prevented them from rekindling anything.

If it were the books, I would say Isabelle. They showed more care for each other.

In the television show, Maia seems to be the more prominent character between the two girls. We have seen how adorable she and Simon are together and if life didn't get in the way, they would be perfect for each other. That being said, we haven't got any Sizzy yet on the show and cannot judge their relationship yet, so this vote will have to wait until season 3.

I'm inclined to believe Maia would win in the show but...let's give Isabelle a chance first. ; )

[Teresa Faliq ☼]

For me, it’s Isabelle. I don’t really think that Maia has much of a point in being in the series. She’s just kind of there. Not to say I didn’t like her character, but I personally like Isabelle more. She’s the badass girl who also has a sweet peronsality. Love Izzy!

[Louise]

Izzy, 100%.
even though Maia is cool, Sizzy forever.
I stopped liking Maia after the last book