American Military Vehicles of World War I
discussion
Dreadful
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
James
(new)
Mar 07, 2011 08:05PM
For all i know, the information about American vehicles is correct in every detail. Trouble is, I don't know about them, which is why I read the book. But I have serious reason to doubt it, since the chapter on Tanks is by far the most wildly inaccurate and misinformed I have read in more than 30 years of studying the subject. Parts of the account of early Tank development are sheer fantasy and bear little or no resemblance to the facts. The historical errors, not to mention the misspellings of important people and places, are too numerous to list here. It is the sloppiest and worst-informed work on the subject i have ever come across. I cannot believe that Mr. Mroz has had the gall to offer this to a publisher or that a publisher has been so misguided as to print it.
reply
|
flag
