Twilight v. Harry Potter? Showing 1,101-1,150 of 1,501

[Asha]

Its always Harry Potter! And wait a minute, where does the comparison come from? Harry Potter Series are way better than the Twilight Series to be compared.

[Nat]

Kimberly LoVe wrote: "Avidreader wrote: "Its always Harry Potter! And wait a minute, where does the comparison come from? Harry Potter Series are way better than the Twilight Series to be compared."

Ummm...why?"

Why? Better plot twists, better overall thought out plot, written better, has deep characters that grow throughout the whole series, has an engaging story that you can't escape from, and Voldemort...he'd kick any sparkly vampire's butt any day...hands down. And Snape...he is definite win as well.

[Whitney]

Faith wrote: "comical! ludicrous! preposterous! outrageous! absurd! laughable! idiotic! irrational! illogical! imbecilic! asinine! ridiculous! "

HP wins hands down...

[Caro]

I don't think it's a good idea to compare these two books. They're different, the readers they were written for belong to two complete different ages. Don't waste your time discussing! Sometimes when you like a book just like it and there's no point trying to persuade other people to like it. With all due respect I really don't understand why people are obsessed with comparing Harry Potter with everything. It is a book I just couldn't read and I don't plan to read but I understand if other people read it.

[Rachel]

Samantha wrote: "of corse harry potter will always be in are hearts but twilight has stolen are hearts witht the amazingly untouchable edward and brittle bella nothing could compare with how myer wrote in to such d..."

I agree! I haven't read Harry Potter, but I personally think that Twilight is untouchable! All Harry Potter is is magical people fight each other, while Twilight, on the other hand is about realtionships and love! I couldn't agree more with the person who wrote this! Go team Jakeward!

[Nat]

Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and trying to thwart a Hitler like evil. The guy is trying to create a perfect race, and literally bringing about WW3. Harry Potter does have relationship and love, but not to the extent of what Twilight has, which in it's own right is okay. HP is not a full on love story, but is one that is full of heart. Yeah I don't like Twilight, but the series are totally different from each other, and have their own rights to be loved by people...just not compared, since it's just wrong.

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and trying to thwart a Hitler like evil. The guy is trying to crea..."

Yeah, exactly, you haven't read Twilight! As I said before, Twilight is untouchable. Ok, so maybe Harry Potter isn't bad, but Twilight is better that any other book out there! Team Jakeward all the way, baby! Lova ya! (Your fury makes everything much more fun to read!) :D

[Kirby]

team jakeward...that cracked me up :)

[M2 Emily]

haha but that is kinda wat i am but i call it team switzerland because switzerland is a neutral country. hahaha get it

[M2 Emily]

M2 Emily wrote: "haha but that is kinda wat i am but i call it team switzerland because switzerland is a neutral country. hahaha get it"
ah yaaa not funny!!!!!!!

[Rachel]

Kirby wrote: "team jakeward...that cracked me up :)"

Thank you vamperry much!

[Kirby]

Rachel wrote: "Kirby wrote: "team jakeward...that cracked me up :)"

Thank you vamperry much!"

ha, now that's just silly!! :)

[Nat]

Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and trying to thwart a Hitler like evil. The guy i..."

Ummm sweetie I have read Twilight...and it is still sitting on my shelf. Second shelf to be exact behind The Sight, and before Gone. Spine is a little crinkled and damaged. I keep it b/c I take a red pen to it, just for the fun of it. And saying Twilight is better than any book out there...please read other books...or try to, since there is a whole race of books far better than Twilight will ever wish to be.

[The Scarecrow]

Christine wrote: "First I would like to address this comment made by Samantha:

"of corse harry potter will always be in are hearts but twilight has stolen are hearts witht the amazingly untouchable edward and britt..."

Can I give you a cyber high-five? I know that's lame, but it's the best I can do considering you summed up my feelings perfectly. Also, I find it astounding how Potter fans are often more grammatically correct in comparison to SMeyer fans.

Please read Mark Oshiro's Twilight blog if you'd like some enlightenment. He's also blogged Potter, if you're up for a massive read.

Also, why, Cedric? Why do you SPARKLE?!

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and trying to thwart a Hitler like ..."

Thanks! Wow you must be a book expert because you know so much! And for your info., your arefighting with a 12 year old! I have read and own so many books that you wouldn't believe. Two years ago, I gave away 152 books and that wasn't even half! I have read so many books, and I know that Twilight is up ther with the best! Thanks for pointing that out, sugar plum!
Twihardy Rachel

[Nat]

Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and trying to thwar..."

Sorry if I didn't know your age. :/ You don't have to get so angry about something I clearly had no clue about. Good on ya for the book count. And sugar plum...really? You're calling a 20 year old sugar plum? Okay...

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and ..."

Well, now I know your age! Thanks for saying that I knew a lot about Twilight! I haven't had this much fun about talking about Twilight ever! I am the only Twihard at my school and I never have anyone to talk about the amazing works of Twilight to! If you want, Sometime you should "friend" me! You seem like tons of fun!

[Nat]

Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about friendship, loyalty..."

Haha...okay. Hey I use to like Twilight...just grew out of it, and read more stuff. I don't mind if people read it, just glad that they DO read. And tons of fun? Me FUN? That makes me so happy. :D

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a series about frie..."

Hey sometime do you want to be my friend?

[Nat]

Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harry Potter is a s..."

Yeah sure. :D

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Magical people fighting each other...that is simply hilarious. To me Harr..."

OK! That would be awesome! Whenever you want to request me you can!

[Leeza]

Harry Potter has a bit of something for everybody of all ages. It has spellbinding magic, clever wit, humour and mystery, recognisable protagonists and antagonists, captures its audiences attention has a unique story plot and increases in character development not just from one chapter to another, but also from book to book as the series proceeds onwards and readers are enlightened to realise answers to questions they wondered from the beginning.

It has influenced younger children into reading, which unfortunately does not occur too often in today's early youth and its good to see literary skills burn brightly in children as young as the age of someone attention primary school.

I say, without a doubt, Harry Potter. Hands down.

[Rachel]

Leeza wrote: "Harry Potter has a bit of something for everybody of all ages. It has spellbinding magic, clever wit, humour and mystery, recognisable protagonists and antagonists, captures its audiences attention..."

Yeah well, you haven't talked about the awesome features of Twilight yet! HP has made more may than twilight, sure, but harry Potter has like 10 movies ou and Twilight only has 3 out! As for the kids reading, there are only a handful of the kids at my school who are actually proud to be a HP fan and talk about it, unlike us Twihards who have many followers and love to talk and have book discussions about it!
Peace out! Twihardy-Rachel

[Nat]

Harry Potter has 8 movies. And honestly I don't mind you liking Twilight, but I don't care for Twihards...since one literally mauled me with a hard cover book. I don't like the fact that a book was used to cut my forehead open and give me some nice stitches. See in all the years of reading, I have never known any fan of HP to attack anyone over opinions. :/

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Harry Potter has 8 movies. And honestly I don't mind you liking Twilight, but I don't care for Twihards...since one literally mauled me with a hard cover book. I don't like the fact that a book was..."

Sorry from all the Twilight fans! That person must have been a little over board! I can't believe that someone would actually do that!

[Nat]

Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Harry Potter has 8 movies. And honestly I don't mind you liking Twilight, but I don't care for Twihards...since one literally mauled me with a hard cover book. I don't like the fact..."

Well she asked me if I liked Twilight and I just said "No sorry...I really don't." Then she grabbed a hard cover book, and yeah. :/ I just don't see how a book/movie could make people go nuts. It's just a book, written on paper. Nothing more.

[Rachel]

Natalie wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Harry Potter has 8 movies. And honestly I don't mind you liking Twilight, but I don't care for Twihards...since one literally mauled me with a hard cover book. I don'..."

Well, then she is just plain old nuts then! Have to go to bed! Bye! Talk tomorrow!

[Abigail]

Do I even need to say it? Ok. I will.

Harry Potter >.<

[Leeza]

Rachel wrote: "Leeza wrote: "Harry Potter has a bit of something for everybody of all ages. It has spellbinding magic, clever wit, humour and mystery, recognisable protagonists and antagonists, captures its audie..."

I don't disagree with you at all, Rachel. Stephenie Meyer's did have very good ideas and I did enjoy reading Twilight. Its quite a intricate, good series. Its good that you're a proud Twihard fan, but although I do vouch for the Twilight book series, the movies didn't do much for me unfortunately lol but at heart, I'll always be a Potter fan :3

[Lea (Peeta's #1 Fangirl!)]

Yes, I do know Kimberly that you do not like HP. I vote for HP for this one. I personally enjoyed reading HP more than Twilight. Plus they are about completely different things. The only similar thing is that they are both very popular. HP has more complexity and has a lot of themes to it and unforgetable characters...Twilight is a good idea and has good writing...But I enjoyed HP more. My opinion. There is not one better than the other.

[Rachel]

Lea (Peeta's #1 Fangirl!) wrote: "Yes, I do know Kimberly that you do not like HP. I vote for HP for this one. I personally enjoyed reading HP more than Twilight. Plus they are about completely different things. The only similar th..."

Yes there is because Twilight is better!
Twihardy-Rachel signing out!<3

[Nat]

Once again Lea was stating her opinion...and her opinion is that HP is better, and I agree. Aren't opinions great...respecting them and all? Okay enough out of me, going back to Supernatural...and then work.

[Karli]

Faith wrote: "comical! ludicrous! preposterous! outrageous! absurd! laughable! idiotic! irrational! illogical! imbecilic! asinine! ridiculous! "

That just about sums it up i guess!! :)

[Valerie]

Both Harry Potter and The Twilight Saga are very enjoyable in their respective ways, but plot for plot, character for character, and even pound for pound in net weight there is no comparison. It’s Harry Potter every time. The real question is: Why are people still having this argument? It’s as pointless as Pepsi vs. Coke.

[Sonali]

can't believe someone would have the nerve to compare Twilight to Harry Potter! WTH?!?? The books are soo very different - Harry Potter's for adults, kids, boys and girls whereas Twilight is a romance!! - ithink that sums it up!!! lol!!! i thik my mouth dropped when i saw this!!!

[Kerri]

Valerie wrote: "Both Harry Potter and The Twilight Saga are very enjoyable in their respective ways, but plot for plot, character for character, and even pound for pound in net weight there is no comparison. It’s..."

Amen sister!

[Nat]

Valerie wrote: "Both Harry Potter and The Twilight Saga are very enjoyable in their respective ways, but plot for plot, character for character, and even pound for pound in net weight there is no comparison. It’s..."

Agree with you on that. I should take pictures of my Twilight book. It is badly marked with a red pen do to all the errors and horrible structures, and how badly characters react to on another and ect. That book is nothing but one big ginormous grammatical error. :/

[Kirby]

Natalie wrote: "Valerie wrote: "Both Harry Potter and The Twilight Saga are very enjoyable in their respective ways, but plot for plot, character for character, and even pound for pound in net weight there is no c..."

if I had a red pen here, your post would be marked :)

[Nat]

Kirby wrote: "Natalie wrote: "Valerie wrote: "Both Harry Potter and The Twilight Saga are very enjoyable in their respective ways, but plot for plot, character for character, and even pound for pound in net weig..."

Hahaha probably considering I'm typing with one hand...broken wrist. XD

[Kirby]

I was just kidding- everybody lets mistakes slip by...including SM and her editors...

sorry about your wrist, I've actually been through that...is it your dominant hand? mine was, it sucked :(

[Nat]

Oh haha i knew you were kidding...i'm a horrible uhhhh....typer...since my keyboard makes me rage. But yeah it's my dominant hand...I can sort of draw and type still it's just ick to me. Working isn't fun either...the fact that they made me work after the incident was just horrible. :/

[Kirby]

yeah, employers generally are not very understanding...hope it heals up soon! and, oh, don't let them leave you in the cast too long...and if they do, be sure to do the physical therapy- I've had maybe 50% function in my wrist for 8 years b/c of that.

[Nat]

Kirby wrote: "yeah, employers generally are not very understanding...hope it heals up soon! and, oh, don't let them leave you in the cast too long...and if they do, be sure to do the physical therapy- I've had ..."

yeah employers don't care at all...I was put on sandwiches...major pain, plus in that wrist I have tendinitis, and carpal tunnel syndrome...so yay me...

[Allie]

This series and Harry Potter a my favorite series, i honestly cant decide! I've read like the H.P. series like five time, but i just recently read the Twilight series, I so cant wait for the last movie 2 come out!!!!!

[M2 Emily]

see i like the H.P series but i like the movies more and i loket twilight more.....so it depends if u r tlking about the movie or the books or well...idk iam confusing myself..haha...yeah

[Valerie]

M2 Emily wrote: "see i like the H.P series but i like the movies more and i loket twilight more.....so it depends if u r tlking about the movie or the books or well...idk iam confusing myself..haha...yeah"

This is a website dedicated to books, so I would imagine that the topic of discussion would be books... :P

[M2 Emily]

ya thx captain obvious i was tlking n general :)

[Valerie]

M2 Emily wrote: "ya thx captain obvious i was tlking n general :)"

Want to be my sidekick Duh?

[M2 Emily]

haha i get it! it took me a minute but i finally git it haha...

[Nat]

Well tell that to the other people in the world who like to compare everything with Twilight...even the book I'm writing is getting compared to that book series by the Twitards in my friend group. :/