پیر کامل  (Peer-e-Kamil, #1) پیر کامل discussion


293 views
what if there was a drama to be made on peer-e-kamil.what do you think who would suit imama and salar the best

Comments (showing 1-50 of 53) (53 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

Aqsa i think some new faces should be introduced...


Rania Abdullah Gandapur Mahira Khan as Imama and Imran Abbas as Salar Sikander! :)


message 3: by Awais (new) - added it

Awais Khaliq i think if u r going to make a drama on it...the whole charm of the book is going to end..so book is a complete drama in its self


Aysha J iman ali for imama's role and fawad khan for salar sikander....and i think instead of drama a feature film should b made on this novel!


Saima Mahira Khan is already playing a similar role from the same Author's book. It will ruin the uniqueness of Imama's character. Also, I am not sure if I want to relate the characters with the faces we see every day..


Shah Rabia i think fahad mustafa for salar and iman ali for imama


Rabia if the book is turned into a drama.... no1z gonna love it the way they do anymore....
n in case the drama is made....... characters shud be new ones and awesome 1s... specialy for salar sikander.. a new man is needed ... none of our already acting actors can play salar's role


Anum i think making drama of peer-e-kamil is not good idea becuz the book is so awesome and the drama couldnot compete with it


Anjaan i think the whole charm of the book is going to end..so book is a complete drama in its self..


message 10: by Syed (new) - rated it 5 stars

Syed Qasim i am sure that no drama serial will made on peer e kamil because kadiyant protest against this and banned the drama and producer also.


message 11: by Hassan (new) - added it

Hassan well said anum


Sualeha Zahid I agree..., no need to make drama


Ayesha Amin no ways...


Cihan umm If they make any drama on it, they will definitely ruin the whole essence of the book....


message 15: by Ghulam (new)

Ghulam Mirani I think Fahad Mustafa as Salar Sikandar and Aiza Khan as Imama Hashim. Perfect role


message 16: by Ghulam (new)

Ghulam Mirani I agree fahad mustafa salar sikandar and aiza khan imama hashim


message 17: by Ghulam (new)

Ghulam Mirani FAHAD MUSTAFA AS SALAR SIKANDAR AND AIZA KHAN AS IMAMA HASHIM PERFECT ROLE


Masooma Zaydee I will vote for shehreyar munawar siddiqui for salaar sikandar and ainy jaffri for imama Hashim :) perfect together


message 19: by Rabi (new)

Rabi Hussain Honestly Sadia khan would fit best as Imama Hashim because of her innocent facial features which fit best the description of Imama in the novel and Fawad Khan or Imran Abbas as Salar because they both fit the descriptions of the character ......


Neelam Zafar no no no there is no need to make drama of such a great novel. No artist can prove best for Imama and Salaar.


Faizan Ghumman i think imran abbas as salar and sadia khan or aiza khan as imama


message 23: by Nisha (last edited Mar 11, 2014 07:10AM) (new)

Nisha Khan no need to make a on his novel because its a drama in its self.If the book is going to turn into drama then shehreyar munawar as salar sikander and aimny jaffari as imama hashim will be great together


message 24: by Amna (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amna NO NO NO NO NO NO cant you all see that the perfection of every character only remains intact if the novel is not turned into a drama! in my mind Salar is so perfect that none of our actos can play him, and the whole charm of the novel will fly out the door if a drama is made on this. so no, please let it remain a novel, a much beloved novel!


message 25: by Amna (new) - added it

Amna Rabia wrote: "i think fahad mustafa for salar and iman ali for imama"

i think iman ali would nt siut


message 26: by Rana (new)

Rana Asad Hello all...listen.
Only Agha sikander as salar and ushna shah as immama will be best for darama. other wise darama will be flopped.only agha sikander and ushna sha.


message 27: by Rana (new)

Rana Asad only agha sikander as salar and ushna shah as immama...... okkkk


message 28: by Rana (new)

Rana Asad Annie wrote: "fawad khan as salar and mahira khan as imama"
only agha sikander as salar and ushna shah as immama...... okkkk


Samreen never ever.......no drama should not be ever made on peer-e-kamil(SAWW)......its out of question.....


message 30: by Kamran (new)

Kamran NO! no drama should be made on this novel because one has its own imaginations and feelings belonging to this novel , all of them are going 2 be spoiled by this drama so plzzzzz....


Aunas Manzoor Acting can't cover the real feelings and emotions of novel. So drama is never recommended for this novel. Never


message 32: by Faizan (new)

Faizan Ali fawad khan and aiza khan bilkul perfact hain iss novel k liye


message 33: by Isra (new) - rated it 5 stars

Isra Shaikh Drama,nooooooooooo,i will never recommended drama for this novel.it loses all real felings and emotions.


message 34: by Maria (new)

Maria Nadeem Please don't make drama on this novel.no one can play salaar's or Imama's role.


Nazish Islam some stories are charming only to read and feel the emotions of the characters through words. Peer-e-Kamil is perfect as it is. There is no need to make drama over it because it'd kill our imagination of Imama and Salar. And if I'm not acting over then no face in the entire drama industry will fit into character of Imama and Salar.
The dramatization of Amar bail just ruined the idea of novel, too.


Fariha Bhatti Ghulam wrote: "FAHAD MUSTAFA AS SALAR SIKANDAR AND AIZA KHAN AS IMAMA HASHIM PERFECT ROLE"



OMG PERFECTTT!!!


message 37: by Rida (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rida Rana No, if someone had written some stuff with all his/her effort and devotion of time ... it should never be turned into such an easy form !!
those who respect writing would read it, and those who dont read it dont need to watch it !! :)


message 38: by Muhammad (new)

Muhammad Naveed The drama on Peer e Kamil will not be so effective as the novel is. It is very very difficult to implement this novel into drama.


Marya Khan No Drama Plz


Marya Khan Nazish wrote: "some stories are charming only to read and feel the emotions of the characters through words. Peer-e-Kamil is perfect as it is. There is no need to make drama over it because it'd kill our imaginat..."

Yes I agree


message 41: by Rida (new) - rated it 3 stars

Rida Rana Maria wrote: "Please don't make drama on this novel.no one can play salaar's or Imama's role."
even I think the same


Zafar The book should not be dramatized. Feeling of words and imagination has no alternative.


Samah Zahid NO NO NO DRAMA


message 44: by Imama (new) - added it

Imama Yes, there should be a drama made on this novel but the lead role of IMAMA shouldn't be played by an actress, rather it would be excellent if a girl who crossed the same path like the one who changed from ahmediat to being a muslim, should be given this role..


message 45: by Ayesha (new) - added it

Ayesha Imran abbas and Sidra batool best match for both characters.


Samah Zahid NOOO DRAMA PLZ


Maria Sheheryar Munawar as Salar
I can dig Sidra Batool - with acting classes.


message 48: by Aimen (new)

Aimen Nadeem No Drama on Peer E Kamil plz plz PLZZZ NEVAAAAAAAAAAAAR!


message 49: by Hira (new)

Hira Khan MAHIRA KHAN 4 IMAMA & OSMAN KHALID BUTT 4 SALAR...


Inshal Abidi Firstly, drama should not be made as it will ruin its charm. None can portray Salar or Imama. However, if it is being made then Fawad Khan will be best for Salar . Imama needs to be someone sweet so can be anyone... Aiza Khan or Mahira.


« previous 1
back to top

all discussions on this book | post a new topic


Books mentioned in this topic

پیر کامل (other topics)